Breaking the Cycle of People-Pleasing

Source: simplehappyart/AdobeStock

As a marriage and family therapist grounded in Bowen Family Systems Theory, I've seen countless examples of how people-pleasing behaviors can lead to anxiety in relationships. Let's consider the case of Jennifer and Michael. Jennifer continually conformed to Michael's desires, always wanting to avoid conflict. Over time, this pattern leads to Jennifer feeling unheard, unappreciated, and anxious about expressing her needs and wishes.

People-pleasing is a helpful strategy on the surface. After all, who doesn't want to make others happy? However, research shows that it can have unintended consequences, particularly when it becomes a habitual way of interacting in relationships. A study published in the Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology found that people high in sociotropy, or excessive concern with pleasing others, often experience distress around relationship conflict.

This behavior often stems from a fear of abandonment or rejection, leading individuals to suppress their needs in favor of others. However, when emotional wounds are left unresolved, they can manifest in relationship anxiety. This is because constant people-pleasing doesn't allow for authentic communication or expressing personal needs, which are crucial for healthy relationships.

Bowen Family Systems Theory suggests that individuals cannot be understood in isolation from one another but rather as a part of their family, as the family is an emotional unit. People-pleasers often develop their habits in response to family dynamics, and these patterns can persist into adulthood and intimate relationships.

Consider the dynamics in Jennifer's family while growing up. Her parents placed a high value on harmony and sought to minimize conflicts. They praised her when she prioritized her siblings' needs above her own, interpreting this as "sharing" and "being considerate." Thus, Jennifer learned early on that pleasing others was a route to gaining affection and approval. This pattern of behavior continued into her adult life, shaping her interactions in her intimate relationships, including the one with Michael.

So, how can we break this cycle? From a Bowenian perspective, the key lies in developing differentiation of self. This involves becoming more emotionally self-reliant, distinguishing between thoughts and feelings, and maintaining a strong sense of self in interactions with others. It requires us to face our fears of rejection and abandonment and to assert our own needs in relationships.

Here are a few steps to start with:

1. Recognize the Pattern: Awareness is the first step toward change. Acknowledge your tendency to people-please and how it's affecting your relationships and personal well-being. Reflect on your family dynamics and how they may have influenced this behavior. For Jennifer, the first step might involve delving into her past interactions with her family and intimate relationships. She could consider situations in which she suppressed her own desires to appease others. For instance, did she often agree with her partner Michael, even when she didn't share his opinion, to avoid conflict? Or did she frequently find herself taking on tasks at home or work that she didn't necessarily want to, merely to keep peace? Recognizing these instances will help Jennifer understand the depth of her people-pleasing tendencies and the situations in which they commonly arise.
2. Set Boundaries: It's essential to establish boundaries in relationships and stick to them. This means saying "no" when needed without feeling guilty or responsible for others' reactions. Jennifer can start establishing boundaries with her family members. For instance, if she finds herself constantly catering to her sibling's demands at the expense of her own needs, she could try voicing her concerns and negotiate a more balanced approach. Explaining her need for personal space and time in a respectfully assertive manner can also help. In her relationship with Michael, Jennifer may need to learn to disagree respectfully and assert her perspectives. This might involve openly discussing her feelings about their relationship dynamics, expressing her need for mutual respect, and creating a comfortable space for open communication. In doing this, she reinforces her identity while maintaining the relationship.
3. Practice Self-Care: Taking care of yourself is not selfish; it's necessary for your well-being. Jennifer should prioritize her own needs and make self-care a priority. This could involve finding hobbies or activities that bring her joy, setting aside time for relaxation and recharging, and caring for her physical and emotional health. It's important to remember that when you take care of yourself, you can better take care of others.
4. Understand Your Triggers: Identify the situations or people that trigger your people-pleasing behavior. This can provide valuable insights into why you behave this way. For Jennifer, certain family members or situations could make her feel obligated to please others. By recognizing these triggers, she can work on setting boundaries and finding healthier coping methods.
5. Learn to Say No: Saying "no" can be difficult for people-pleasers, but it's an essential skill to learn. It's OK to decline requests or invitations if they don't align with your needs or values. Jennifer can practice saying "no" respectfully and assertively without feeling guilty. It's important to remember that saying "no" does not make you a bad person.
6. Express Your Needs: Practice respectfully communicating your needs. It might initially feel uncomfortable, but it will become easier with time. Jennifer can start by expressing her needs to those closest to her, such as friends and family. This will help build her confidence in expressing herself and standing up for what she wants.
7. Seek Professional Help: A skilled therapist can provide a safe space to explore these patterns and facilitate personal growth. They can help identify underlying issues and provide strategies to manage people-pleasing behaviors. Jennifer can benefit from therapy to help her understand the root causes of her behavior and learn healthier ways to cope.

By understanding and addressing our people-pleasing tendencies, we can develop healthier relationship dynamics, reduce anxiety, and improve our overall emotional well-being. It's important to remember that we are not responsible for the happiness of others, and it's OK to prioritize our own needs. With time and effort, Jennifer can break free from this pattern and live a more fulfilling life. So, if you find yourself in a situation in which you feel compelled to say "yes" when you want to say "no," take a step back and evaluate your needs and boundaries. Remember that saying "no" is not a personal attack on others but an act of self-care.