How to Hire a Leadership Coach

In the ever-evolving world of leadership coaching, there's a noticeable surge of younger individuals stepping into the spotlight, eager to make their mark on the world of personal and professional development.

Source: deagreez / Adobe Stock

While their enthusiasm is palpable and their marketing prowess undeniable, it's essential to tread carefully and avoid the potential pitfalls that come with their inexperience.

Some newer coaches may exude an air of confidence and capability, bolstered by shiny marketing campaigns and claims of expertise. However, beneath the surface lies a crucial question:

Do they possess the substantive experience and wisdom needed to guide clients effectively?

While they may present themselves as knowledgeable and capable, lack of experience may lead them to offer recommendations that are generic, impractical, or even detrimental to the client's growth journey. It takes a lot of first-hand experience in leadership positions to offer relevant insights rooted in practical wisdom.

And, the research backs it up. In a 2014 study (1), for example, two of the top three reasons cited for negative effects of coaching for clients, included:

1) had no intimate knowledge about workplace dynamics

2) had too little professional experience.

The findings highlight a primary concern about working with inexperienced leadership coaches: They simply don’t know what they don’t know!

Certainly, leadership theory is essential. However, it can take one only so far in helping others learn to lead. Effective leadership requires the ability to navigate nuanced interpersonal dynamics, make tough decisions under pressure, and adapt to ever-changing circumstances. Indeed, leadership ability is earned through years of effort, learned from both successes and failures and demonstrated by the ability to inspire and motivate others.

A Credential Doesn't Make Anyone a Great Coach

Clients seeking guidance from a coach naturally expect someone with a track record of leadership excellence whose advice carries weight based on demonstrated achievements. Inexperienced coaches can’t make up for what they lack, regardless of how many coaching credentials they hold.

Let’s face it; becoming an exceptional leader is a deeply personal journey, influenced by individual strengths, weaknesses, and organizational contexts. Effective coaching requires the ability to tailor strategies and interventions to meet the unique needs of each client. Inexperienced coaches, relying solely on theoretical frameworks, may overlook such critical distinctions, leading to imprudent recommendations that fail to yield tangible results.

The likelihood of receiving misguided or ineffective advice from an inexperienced leadership coach is high. Again, if you've never been in the trenches yourself, how solid can your counsel really be?

Many Struggle to Navigate Ethical Dilemmas and Boundaries

Any leadership coach worth their salt knows that the work often involves delving into sensitive topics, including interpersonal conflicts, performance issues, and organizational politics. Without the wisdom gained from years of experience, novice coaches may inadvertently overstep boundaries, disclose confidential information, or offer biased advice. Such lapses in professionalism not only compromise the integrity of the coaching process but also jeopardize the trust and confidentiality essential for effective coaching relationships.

It's essential to acknowledge that not all inexperienced coaches are destined to fail. Some may possess natural talent, a genuine passion for coaching, and a commitment to continuous learning and development. However, the risks associated with working with inexperienced coaches cannot be overlooked or understated.

Poor Coaching Can Have a Serious Psychological Impact, too

In a now-classic article in Harvard Business Review (2), psychologist and executive coach Steven Berglas pointed out what has since become well-recognized among coaches and therapists:

“Misguided coaching ignores—and even creates—deep-rooted psychological problems that often only psychotherapy can fix.”

Leadership Essential Reads

3 Strategies to Reclaim Ownership of Your Work Day

Why High-Potential Women Are Ambivalent About Leadership

Berglas describes two instances in which a coach did more harm than good because inexperienced coaches tend to define the problems plaguing a leader in the terms they understand best. More experienced coaches tend to recognize an array of factors contributing to poor leadership performance and can refer a client to qualified professionals for further assistance.

Ask the Right Questions in Hiring a Coach

When evaluating the quality of a coach, asking the right questions is essential. Here are five questions to help distinguish a good coach from an inexperienced one, along with guidance on interpreting answers.

1. What is your coaching philosophy?

An experienced coach will offer a clear, well-articulated philosophy that focuses on development, motivation, and tailored strategies, while an inexperienced one will be vague or generic. They may even rely heavily on clichés to avoid discussing the process.

2. Can you provide examples of how you've helped others achieve their goals?

An experienced coach will deliver specific, detailed examples with measurable outcomes, while an inexperienced coach will provide only broad, nonspecific anecdotes, struggling to give concrete evidence of their impact.

3. How do you tailor your coaching approach to fit individual needs?

An experienced coach will describe various methods and techniques used to assess individual needs and adapt their coaching style, while a less qualified coach will offer one-size-fits-all answers, with little to no emphasis on customization.

4. How do you stay current with leadership trends and strategies?

A solid coach will discuss regular participation in professional leadership development activities such as workshops, courses, and conferences and staying updated with the latest research, while an inexperienced coach will likely not emphasize ongoing learning and will not be able to site specific examples of how they stay current on leadership information.

5. How do you measure and track progress with your clients?

A highly qualified coach will describe clear methods used to measure and track progress as well as explain how they adapt their coaching based on progress, while less experienced coaches provide vagueness or rely too heaviiy on subjective assessments in monitoring client development.

By asking these questions and carefully interpreting the answers, you can better assess whether a coach has the experience, knowledge, and adaptability to effectively support your goals.

In Closing

It's crucial to approach hiring a leadership coach with extreme caution. Clients must be vigilant in evaluating the credentials and experience of potential coaches, resisting the allure of fancy marketing and exaggerated claims.

By prioritizing substance over style and seeking out coaches with a demonstrated track record of leadership excellence, clients can mitigate the risks associated with inexperienced coaching and embark on their growth journey with confidence and clarity.