Borderpolar: A Diagnostic Whiplash

Source: Taylor Deas-Melesh/Unsplash

Mental health diagnoses can be particularly complex, significantly when symptoms of different disorders overlap. Two conditions that are often confused are Bipolar Disorder (BD) and Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD). When someone exhibits symptoms of both, they may be dealing with what some mental health professionals refer to as "Borderpolar." This combination can lead to diagnostic whiplash, where individuals receive multiple, shifting diagnoses before finding clarity. Understanding this dual presentation is crucial for appropriate treatment and management.

Understanding the Complexity

Bipolar Disorder involves distinct mood episodes that include manic, hypomanic, and depressive states. These episodes are typically cyclical and may have periods of stability in between. Borderline Personality Disorder is marked by pervasive emotional instability, where mood changes can be more abrupt and are often closely tied to external stressors, particularly in relationships (Gunderson, 2001).

For example, a person with Bipolar Disorder might experience a week-long manic episode, followed by a period of everyday mood, and then a depressive episode. Conversely, someone with BPD might wake up feeling relatively stable but then experience intense sadness or anger triggered by a perceived slight from a friend or loved one (Zanarini & Frankenburg, 2007). When both sets of symptoms coexist, it creates a complex clinical picture that requires nuanced understanding and treatment (Phelps, 2006).

Diagnostic Challenges

Diagnosing Borderpolar, a term used to describe the coexistence of Bipolar Disorder (BD) and Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) symptoms, is particularly challenging due to several factors:

Symptom Overlap:

• Mood Swings: Both BD and BPD involve significant mood changes, but the nature of these changes can differ. BD is characterized by distinct episodes of mania/hypomania and depression, whereas BPD mood shifts are often rapid and triggered by interpersonal events.
• Impulsivity: Both disorders exhibit impulsive behaviors, but in BD, impulsivity is usually linked to manic or hypomanic states. In contrast, BPD impulsivity is often a response to emotional distress and fear of abandonment.
• Emotional Instability: BPD features pervasive emotional instability, while BD mood changes tend to be episodic, with periods of everyday mood in between.

Diagnostic Criteria:

• The criteria for diagnosing BD and BPD can overlap, making it difficult to distinguish between them. For example, both conditions may include irritability, risk-taking behaviors, and severe mood swings.

Clinical Presentation:

• Patients with both BD and BPD symptoms often present a complex clinical picture that can lead to misdiagnosis. A clinician might diagnose BD during a manic episode and miss the underlying BPD traits, or vice versa.
• The cyclical nature of BD and the more reactive, situation-dependent nature of BPD symptoms can confuse the diagnostic process. This complexity often results in a "diagnostic whiplash" where patients receive multiple shifting diagnoses before reaching a clear understanding.

Impact of Misdiagnosis:

• Misdiagnosis can lead to inappropriate treatment plans. For instance, mood stabilizers and antipsychotic medications used for BD might not address the emotional regulation and interpersonal difficulties central to BPD, and vice versa. This can result in inadequate symptom control and increased patient distress.

Integrated Treatment Approaches

Effective treatment for Borderpolar involves strategies that address the symptoms of both BD and BPD. This requires a comprehensive and multi-faceted approach:

Pharmacotherapy:

• Mood Stabilizers: Medications like lithium, valproate, or lamotrigine can help stabilize mood swings associated with BD.
• Antidepressants and Antipsychotics: These can be used carefully to manage depressive episodes and severe mood disturbances. However, the use of antidepressants must be monitored closely to avoid triggering manic episodes in BD patients.

Psychotherapy:

• Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT): DBT is particularly effective for BPD. It focuses on skills training to improve emotional regulation, distress tolerance, and interpersonal effectiveness. This can be crucial for managing the rapid emotional changes and impulsivity in BPD.
• Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT): CBT can be beneficial for addressing negative thought patterns and behaviors in both BD and BPD. It helps patients develop coping strategies for dealing with mood swings and emotional distress.

Integrated Care Models:

• An integrated care approach involves coordinating between various healthcare providers to ensure comprehensive treatment. This includes collaboration between psychiatrists, psychologists, and other mental health professionals to provide a cohesive treatment plan.
• Regular monitoring and adjustment of treatment plans based on the patient’s progress and response to therapy can help address the changing needs of individuals with Borderpolar.

Bipolar Disorder Essential Reads

How Common Is Recovery in Bipolar Disorder?

Could Your Depression Be Bipolar Disorder?

Psychoeducation:

• Educating patients and their families about the nature of BD and BPD, their symptoms, and treatment options is essential. This helps set realistic expectations and improve adherence to treatment plans.
• Psychoeducation can also empower patients with self-management strategies, reducing the impact of symptoms on their daily lives.

Lifestyle Modifications and Support:

• Encouraging healthy lifestyle choices, such as regular exercise, proper sleep hygiene, and stress management techniques, can support overall mental health.
• Support groups and community resources can provide additional emotional support and reduce feelings of isolation for patients dealing with Borderpolar.

By combining these approaches, healthcare providers can create a tailored treatment plan that addresses Borderpolar's unique challenges, helping patients achieve better outcomes and an improved quality of life.

Source: Luiz Rogério Nunes/Unsplash

Stigma

Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) often carries a stigma, even within the mental health community. This stigma arises from the interpersonal relationship challenges, self-image issues, and emotional regulation difficulties experienced by those with BPD. However, as research progresses, there is a growing understanding and compassion for individuals with BPD, helping to reduce this stigma.

Bipolar Disorder also faces stigma, mainly due to the need for medication, the impact of mood swings, and, in severe cases, the presence of hallucinations and delusions. These symptoms can sometimes be mistaken for schizophrenia, which can discourage individuals from seeking the help they need.

Conclusion

Borderpolar represents the intersection of Bipolar Disorder and Borderline Personality Disorder, leading to a complex and often confusing clinical picture. An integrated approach that combines medication for mood stabilization and psychotherapy for emotional regulation and interpersonal skills can significantly improve the quality of life for individuals dealing with Borderpolar.

Prolonged misdiagnosis can lower quality of life, leading to intense feelings of helplessness and self-blame. It is crucial to understand that these symptoms are not personal failings but part of a mental health disorder. Accurate diagnosis and tailored treatment are vital to managing this multifaceted condition and helping individuals achieve stability and well-being.

Despite the seriousness of these diagnoses, there is hope. With the right therapist, doctor, and treatment plan, individuals with Borderpolar can lead healthy and fulfilling lives. Proper support helps many manage their symptoms effectively and thrive.

To find a therapist, visit the Psychology Today Therapy Directory.