Should I See a Male or Female Therapist?

Source: Prostock-studio/Shutterstock

Therapists of all types generally agree that the strongest predictor of whether therapy helps someone is the connection that therapist and client create, known as the therapeutic alliance. Importantly, this alliance is built on empathy, acceptance, and mutual respect, and not the therapist’s gender. That said, you may find yourself more drawn to a therapist of a specific gender due to past experiences or other preferences.

The following steps can help you gain a better understanding of what gender therapist may be right for you and how to find a good fit.

Step 1: Understand what may be shaping a gender preference

Ask yourself whether your preference is rooted in a specific concern, such as feeling more understood by someone of a particular gender, past experiences with trauma or abuse, cultural or religious background, or simply a gut feeling you cannot fully explain yet. None of these reasons are wrong. Understanding the “why” behind your preference helps you communicate it clearly to a therapist, which can make your search more focused and less overwhelming.

Certain clinical contexts do warrant more careful consideration of gender. Research finds that women who have experienced trauma often feel more comfortable with a female therapist, which can facilitate a stronger bond. Similarly, gender-diverse clients may feel hesitant to raise gender-related issues with cisgender therapists, even ones they otherwise like, and may find more ease with a gender-diverse clinician.

Step 2: Weigh preferences against availability

Your preference may also run up against practical limits. The therapy workforce skews female in most countries, so male therapists can be harder to find, particularly in smaller areas or in specific areas of practice.

Also, while it is worth understanding your own preferences, they are worth examining closely, particularly those rooted in stereotype rather than personal history. Good therapists are flexible and continually adapt their approach to the specific needs of each client. A therapist’s training, clinical approach, and areas of specialty should carry more weight in determining outcomes than gender alone.

Step 3: Test preferences in initial sessions

If gender was a significant concern going into therapy, pay attention to whether it is actually affecting your ability to open up in the room in an initial therapy session. To assess whether a prospective therapist was a good fit, consider asking yourself the following questions after the first session:

• Did you feel seen and heard?
• Did the therapist pick up on subtleties?
• Was the therapist responsive and engaged?
• Did the therapist add to your understanding of your condition/concerns?

You may find that a strong connection overrides your original preference, or that your preference turns out to matter more than you expected. Ultimately, remember that the goal is to find a good fit, regardless of gender.