Cigna and Evernorth Therapists in Orchard Park, NY

Photo of Kelly Thompson, Counselor, LMHC
Kelly Thompson
Counselor, LMHC
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Cigna and Aetna through Headway
Tired of feeling stuck or trying to be perfect? Let’s move past the survival mode and into what’s next. If you’re exhausted from just surviving the day, I’m here to help. With 20+ years of experience, I help adults move beyond the heavy weight of depression and the constant chatter of anxiety. You aren't your symptoms; you're likely just trapped by limiting beliefs. In my inclusive, judgment-free space, we’ll identify the mental blocks holding you back and build a practical toolkit for resilience. Stop surviving and start discovering who you are without fear. Immediate openings for March 2026—let’s start your journey today.
Cigna and Aetna through Headway
Tired of feeling stuck or trying to be perfect? Let’s move past the survival mode and into what’s next. If you’re exhausted from just surviving the day, I’m here to help. With 20+ years of experience, I help adults move beyond the heavy weight of depression and the constant chatter of anxiety. You aren't your symptoms; you're likely just trapped by limiting beliefs. In my inclusive, judgment-free space, we’ll identify the mental blocks holding you back and build a practical toolkit for resilience. Stop surviving and start discovering who you are without fear. Immediate openings for March 2026—let’s start your journey today.
(716) 466-5383 View (716) 466-5383
Photo of Tori Leighbody, Counselor, LMHC
Tori Leighbody
Counselor, LMHC
Orchard Park, NY 14127
I am passionate about working with individuals to help them recognize their strengths, overcome challenges, and become the best version of themselves. I pride myself in forming relationships with my clients that make them feel trust and heard. Navigating new situations and conflict can be difficult, but you don't need to do it alone. I offer therapy in-office and telehealth.
I am passionate about working with individuals to help them recognize their strengths, overcome challenges, and become the best version of themselves. I pride myself in forming relationships with my clients that make them feel trust and heard. Navigating new situations and conflict can be difficult, but you don't need to do it alone. I offer therapy in-office and telehealth.
View
Photo of Steven Comeau, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Steven Comeau
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Orchard Park, NY 14127
I help adults age 18 and older better understand themselves, their relationships, and the impact of past experiences. My work focuses on self-worth, life transitions, grief, and the challenges that can come with relationships, identity, and faith. In my practice, I work with men and women from their late teens through older adulthood who feel stuck, whether in relationships, in patterns of self-doubt, or in a life that no longer feels aligned.
I help adults age 18 and older better understand themselves, their relationships, and the impact of past experiences. My work focuses on self-worth, life transitions, grief, and the challenges that can come with relationships, identity, and faith. In my practice, I work with men and women from their late teens through older adulthood who feel stuck, whether in relationships, in patterns of self-doubt, or in a life that no longer feels aligned.
(716) 899-1653 View (716) 899-1653
Photo of Elizabeth Anton, Counselor, LMHC
Elizabeth Anton
Counselor, LMHC
Online Only
Welcome! I am an LMHC with 20+ years of clinical experience in the field. My practice focuses on the "life story" of the whole client, including family, interests, and personal characteristics. Are you struggling through a separation, divorce, or co-parenting problem? Do you worry that your relationship could be healthier, or that you and your partner can do more to support one another rather than argue? These are my areas of specialty, along with adults/young adults struggling with life transitions, relationships, work/life stress, depression, anxiety, body image, disordered eating, and/or eating disorders.
Welcome! I am an LMHC with 20+ years of clinical experience in the field. My practice focuses on the "life story" of the whole client, including family, interests, and personal characteristics. Are you struggling through a separation, divorce, or co-parenting problem? Do you worry that your relationship could be healthier, or that you and your partner can do more to support one another rather than argue? These are my areas of specialty, along with adults/young adults struggling with life transitions, relationships, work/life stress, depression, anxiety, body image, disordered eating, and/or eating disorders.
(332) 263-4024 View (332) 263-4024
Photo of Alicia Kimmerly, Art Therapist, LCAT
Alicia Kimmerly
Art Therapist, LCAT
Orchard Park, NY 14127
I am in-network for Cigna, but I can also provide a superbill for my out-of-network clients and help with reimbursement.
Getting started in therapy can be difficult. I understand that making the choice of taking care of you may feel overwhelming or even intimidating. With this in mind, I believe in an approach to therapy that allows you to have a voice to express. In turn, I provide a compassionate ear to listen. Together we can explore what has led you to therapy, and work through challenges together focusing on your goals and values, while offering the opportunity for creativity and expression.
I am in-network for Cigna, but I can also provide a superbill for my out-of-network clients and help with reimbursement.
Getting started in therapy can be difficult. I understand that making the choice of taking care of you may feel overwhelming or even intimidating. With this in mind, I believe in an approach to therapy that allows you to have a voice to express. In turn, I provide a compassionate ear to listen. Together we can explore what has led you to therapy, and work through challenges together focusing on your goals and values, while offering the opportunity for creativity and expression.
(716) 413-5599 View (716) 413-5599
Photo of Jenna Colern, Mental Health Counselor, LMHC
Jenna Colern
Mental Health Counselor, LMHC
Orchard Park, NY 14127
In my counseling practice, I specialize in trauma work, substance use, and grief, with a focus on supporting frontline workers. With tailored approaches and compassionate care, I help individuals navigate through life's challenges. From coping with trauma to overcoming addiction and grieving losses, I provide a safe space for healing and growth. My dedication to frontline workers stems from understanding their unique stressors, and I am committed to offering them the specialized support they deserve. Together, we work towards resilience, recovery, and renewed hope.
In my counseling practice, I specialize in trauma work, substance use, and grief, with a focus on supporting frontline workers. With tailored approaches and compassionate care, I help individuals navigate through life's challenges. From coping with trauma to overcoming addiction and grieving losses, I provide a safe space for healing and growth. My dedication to frontline workers stems from understanding their unique stressors, and I am committed to offering them the specialized support they deserve. Together, we work towards resilience, recovery, and renewed hope.
(716) 413-3935 View (716) 413-3935
Photo of Lindsay Richardson, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Lindsay Richardson
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
1 Endorsed
Orchard Park, NY 14127
I understand that before someone is ready to seek therapy, they have usually already been down a difficult road. Making the decision to finally seek help is truly half the battle, and an accomplishment in itself. We may have been disappointed by past attempts at change, because while we can logically understand that our painful thoughts and beliefs may be untrue, they nonetheless still feel true. My approach to therapy bridges this gap by offering EMDR, amongst other therapeutic techniques. EMDR is a research-supported treatment for trauma, anxiety and other related concerns which allows for meaningful, long-lasting relief.
I understand that before someone is ready to seek therapy, they have usually already been down a difficult road. Making the decision to finally seek help is truly half the battle, and an accomplishment in itself. We may have been disappointed by past attempts at change, because while we can logically understand that our painful thoughts and beliefs may be untrue, they nonetheless still feel true. My approach to therapy bridges this gap by offering EMDR, amongst other therapeutic techniques. EMDR is a research-supported treatment for trauma, anxiety and other related concerns which allows for meaningful, long-lasting relief.
(716) 321-0159 View (716) 321-0159
Photo of Lisa N. Mann - Lisa Mann Mental Health Counseling PLLC, Counselor, LMHC-D, CASAC-G, MSEd
Lisa Mann Mental Health Counseling PLLC
Counselor, LMHC-D, CASAC-G, MSEd
2 Endorsed
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Are you seeking balance or change in your life? Has placing yourself first suddenly stopped being a priority? Are you struggling and unsure where to begin? You've come to the right place. I've worked closely helping many individuals over the past 12 years with these same thoughts, questions and feelings. Let me help you too. Let's work toward putting your goals and aspirations first. Let's re-discover who you are. I will encourage you to identify your goals so that we can create a plan together of how you will work toward achieving them.
Are you seeking balance or change in your life? Has placing yourself first suddenly stopped being a priority? Are you struggling and unsure where to begin? You've come to the right place. I've worked closely helping many individuals over the past 12 years with these same thoughts, questions and feelings. Let me help you too. Let's work toward putting your goals and aspirations first. Let's re-discover who you are. I will encourage you to identify your goals so that we can create a plan together of how you will work toward achieving them.
(716) 589-2020 View (716) 589-2020
Photo of Lisa Noelle Sears-Ricotta, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, CASAC
Lisa Noelle Sears-Ricotta
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, CASAC
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Are you struggling? Feel like something is missing in your life? Having problems in your relationships? Call me. Ignoring these problems only makes them worse! I help empower individuals so that they are able to cope with and overcome these life challenges. I will work with you to help you gain the tools, resources and techniques to put you on a path to a healthier and more fulfilling life. I know its not easy. Anxiety, depression, fear and self-doubt can creep in when confronting these issues. Or maybe these are some of the issues you are already dealing with.
Are you struggling? Feel like something is missing in your life? Having problems in your relationships? Call me. Ignoring these problems only makes them worse! I help empower individuals so that they are able to cope with and overcome these life challenges. I will work with you to help you gain the tools, resources and techniques to put you on a path to a healthier and more fulfilling life. I know its not easy. Anxiety, depression, fear and self-doubt can creep in when confronting these issues. Or maybe these are some of the issues you are already dealing with.
(716) 514-4018 View (716) 514-4018
Photo of Dayna Sickau, Counselor, LMHC-D
Dayna Sickau
Counselor, LMHC-D
2 Endorsed
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Hi, I'm Dayna! I'm a Licensed Mental Health Counselor and Life Coach who is passionate about helping adults navigate mental health symptoms (anxiety, depression, PTSD/Trauma, etc.) and the stressors of everyday life that can leave you feeling stuck or disconnected from yourself. If you're feeling overwhelmed, exhausted, or unsure of how to move forward, you don't have to figure it out alone.
Hi, I'm Dayna! I'm a Licensed Mental Health Counselor and Life Coach who is passionate about helping adults navigate mental health symptoms (anxiety, depression, PTSD/Trauma, etc.) and the stressors of everyday life that can leave you feeling stuck or disconnected from yourself. If you're feeling overwhelmed, exhausted, or unsure of how to move forward, you don't have to figure it out alone.
(716) 281-1689 View (716) 281-1689
Photo of Ryan Elizabeth Brotz, Psychologist, PhD
Ryan Elizabeth Brotz
Psychologist, PhD
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Hello! I’m glad you’re here and thinking about reaching out. I provided a wide variety of psychological testing and diagnostic services and am one of only a few actively practicing Certified Forensic Child Custody Evaluators in Erie County, NY, however, Telehealth allows me to provide services state wide. I would love to hear from you and talk about how I can help!
Hello! I’m glad you’re here and thinking about reaching out. I provided a wide variety of psychological testing and diagnostic services and am one of only a few actively practicing Certified Forensic Child Custody Evaluators in Erie County, NY, however, Telehealth allows me to provide services state wide. I would love to hear from you and talk about how I can help!
(716) 588-1815 View (716) 588-1815
Photo of Alissa Schmidt, Licensed Psychoanalyst, MA, LMHC
Alissa Schmidt
Licensed Psychoanalyst, MA, LMHC
1 Endorsed
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Starting therapy can be a scary and also exciting time. You have decided to make a change! I work hard to create a safe, positive place for you to process, reflect and grow. I am a licensed mental health counselor and have been working in the field for 9 years. I have worked with all different populations and diagnoses and strive to build honest and solid therapeutic relationships with those that I work with.
Starting therapy can be a scary and also exciting time. You have decided to make a change! I work hard to create a safe, positive place for you to process, reflect and grow. I am a licensed mental health counselor and have been working in the field for 9 years. I have worked with all different populations and diagnoses and strive to build honest and solid therapeutic relationships with those that I work with.
(716) 452-9488 View (716) 452-9488
Photo of Courtney Belcher, Counselor, MA, LMHC
Courtney Belcher
Counselor, MA, LMHC
8 Endorsed
Orchard Park, NY 14127
We experience and go through a lot in our lives, and sometimes life feels very hard and heavy. The therapeutic relationship can be a helpful and powerful tool to help you along the way. You may be struggling with a specific issue, or a more general challenge in your life. Finding the right therapist, who is the right fit for you is a wonderful step to take in beginning your healing process. As a therapist, I strive to create an environment of safety, curiosity, discovery, and courage for everyone seeking therapeutic services and I look forward to collaborating with people in creative ways to reach therapeutic goals.
We experience and go through a lot in our lives, and sometimes life feels very hard and heavy. The therapeutic relationship can be a helpful and powerful tool to help you along the way. You may be struggling with a specific issue, or a more general challenge in your life. Finding the right therapist, who is the right fit for you is a wonderful step to take in beginning your healing process. As a therapist, I strive to create an environment of safety, curiosity, discovery, and courage for everyone seeking therapeutic services and I look forward to collaborating with people in creative ways to reach therapeutic goals.
(716) 458-8311 View (716) 458-8311
Emily M Higgins
Counselor, LMHC
2 Endorsed
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Thank you for visiting my page. Everyone needs help from time to time - sometimes things can just get tough. Navigating difficult symptoms, stressors, unsettling life events on our own can be challenging. Therapy can help you find relief and hope for a better tomorrow. Being vulnerable and discussing difficult areas of our lives can be hard to do - but the long term benefits of working on yourself are worth it… You are worth it! And I am here to help.
Thank you for visiting my page. Everyone needs help from time to time - sometimes things can just get tough. Navigating difficult symptoms, stressors, unsettling life events on our own can be challenging. Therapy can help you find relief and hope for a better tomorrow. Being vulnerable and discussing difficult areas of our lives can be hard to do - but the long term benefits of working on yourself are worth it… You are worth it! And I am here to help.
(716) 589-4426 View (716) 589-4426
Photo of Courtney Kadish-Smith, Counselor, LMHC, LPC
Courtney Kadish-Smith
Counselor, LMHC, LPC
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Are you currently struggling with anxiety, depression, a mood disorder or trauma? My overall goal is to help you be the best version of yourself. In order to do this I use education to help you build insight to the barriers preventing from this happening. With this I also provided a safe, non-judgmental environment for you to navigate through the hardships of mental health while focusing on your strengths in order for you to feel like your true self again.
Are you currently struggling with anxiety, depression, a mood disorder or trauma? My overall goal is to help you be the best version of yourself. In order to do this I use education to help you build insight to the barriers preventing from this happening. With this I also provided a safe, non-judgmental environment for you to navigate through the hardships of mental health while focusing on your strengths in order for you to feel like your true self again.
(716) 320-9442 View (716) 320-9442
Photo of Tizza Creighton, Counselor, LMHC
Tizza Creighton
Counselor, LMHC
Online Only
Welcome! Seeking support is a meaningful step, and I strive to create a nonjudgmental space where you can feel heard, understood and empowered. As a Licensed Mental Health Counselor, I work collaboratively with individuals navigating anxiety, ADHD, depression, grief stress, life transitions, relationship challenges, trauma, perinatal/postpartum period, and self-esteem concerns.
Welcome! Seeking support is a meaningful step, and I strive to create a nonjudgmental space where you can feel heard, understood and empowered. As a Licensed Mental Health Counselor, I work collaboratively with individuals navigating anxiety, ADHD, depression, grief stress, life transitions, relationship challenges, trauma, perinatal/postpartum period, and self-esteem concerns.
(716) 265-4655 View (716) 265-4655
Photo of Kayla Woodruff, Mental Health Counselor, LMHC
Kayla Woodruff
Mental Health Counselor, LMHC
2 Endorsed
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Welcome! I'm Kayla, a Licensed Mental Health Therapist passionate about helping adults navigate stress and improve their overall well-being. I am dedicated to supporting, empowering, and encouraging individuals during challenging times. Watching people transform from struggling to flourishing is the reason I love this work. My own positive experiences with therapy inspire me to offer the same benefits to my clients. Together, we’ll create a space where you feel understood and guided on your path to healing and personal growth.
Welcome! I'm Kayla, a Licensed Mental Health Therapist passionate about helping adults navigate stress and improve their overall well-being. I am dedicated to supporting, empowering, and encouraging individuals during challenging times. Watching people transform from struggling to flourishing is the reason I love this work. My own positive experiences with therapy inspire me to offer the same benefits to my clients. Together, we’ll create a space where you feel understood and guided on your path to healing and personal growth.
(716) 356-4730 View (716) 356-4730
Photo of Korie Scott, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Korie Scott
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Online Only
I specialize in working with teens/adolescents, and young adults who struggle with anxiety, depression, attachment disorders, trauma, and behavioral concerns. I approach therapy sessions with unconditional positive regard. I see you doing your best, and I want to help you reach your highest potential.
I specialize in working with teens/adolescents, and young adults who struggle with anxiety, depression, attachment disorders, trauma, and behavioral concerns. I approach therapy sessions with unconditional positive regard. I see you doing your best, and I want to help you reach your highest potential.
(585) 632-6745 View (585) 632-6745
Photo of Jeff Roach - Family Counseling Associates, Psychologist, PhD
Family Counseling Associates
Psychologist, PhD
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Family Counseling Associates is a group of seasoned, knowledgeable, mental health professionals who provide mental health care services for children, adolescents, adults and their families in private-practice settings. Psychologists, Psychiatrists, Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioners, Licensed Clinical Social Workers, and Licensed Mental Health Counselors provide the full range of outpatient mental health care services necessary to help children, adolescents, adults and their families feel and function at their best. We currently provide services from offices in Orchard Park and Tonawanda in WNY.
Family Counseling Associates is a group of seasoned, knowledgeable, mental health professionals who provide mental health care services for children, adolescents, adults and their families in private-practice settings. Psychologists, Psychiatrists, Psychiatric Mental Health Nurse Practitioners, Licensed Clinical Social Workers, and Licensed Mental Health Counselors provide the full range of outpatient mental health care services necessary to help children, adolescents, adults and their families feel and function at their best. We currently provide services from offices in Orchard Park and Tonawanda in WNY.
(716) 245-7142 View (716) 245-7142
Photo of Michelle Choy, Counselor, LMHC
Michelle Choy
Counselor, LMHC
Online Only
Being a teen or young adult today isn’t easy. Between academic pressure, social stress, identity questions, and navigating independence, it’s a lot to manage — and you don’t have to do it alone. I specialize in supporting teens and young adults who feel overwhelmed, anxious, stuck, or just not like themselves, and am experienced in working with adolescents across outpatient, hospital, and foster care settings. Whether you're struggling with your mental health, relationships, or major life transitions, therapy can be a space to slow down, make sense of your experience, and move toward a more grounded, confident version of you.
Being a teen or young adult today isn’t easy. Between academic pressure, social stress, identity questions, and navigating independence, it’s a lot to manage — and you don’t have to do it alone. I specialize in supporting teens and young adults who feel overwhelmed, anxious, stuck, or just not like themselves, and am experienced in working with adolescents across outpatient, hospital, and foster care settings. Whether you're struggling with your mental health, relationships, or major life transitions, therapy can be a space to slow down, make sense of your experience, and move toward a more grounded, confident version of you.
(929) 445-2107 View (929) 445-2107

See more therapy options for Orchard Park

Cigna and Evernorth Therapists
Does insurance cover therapy, prescriptions and other behavioral health services?
In general, yes. Laws in the U.S. require insurers to cover essential behavioral health care at the same level as other health care services. Most health plans require a medical diagnosis and treatments that are evidence based and medically essential. This means that life coaching and alternative therapies are not covered, nor is therapy without a diagnosis. Call the number on the back or your insurance card or visit your insurance company's website to review your Summary of Benefits. If you have insurance through your employer, your Human Resources department may also be able to answer questions.

How much does therapy cost with insurance?
The cost of therapy depends on your region, how much training and experience your therapist has, and the type of treatment. The rate for talk therapy generally falls between $100 and $250. For a client seeing an in-network provider, the cost of therapy is often similar to the cost of other health care services. Clients pay co-pays and may need to satisfy a plan’s deductible before benefits kick in.

What is the difference between In-Network and Out-of-Network insurance coverage?
An in-network provider has contracted with an insurer to get paid directly for services, and to accept the insurer’s rate of compensation. Clients are responsible for deductibles and copays. If a therapist is out of network, that means that the client pays the therapist directly for services at the therapist’s regular fee. Out-of-Network providers often give clients a receipt so that they can file for partial reimbursement with their insurance company.

Is it difficult to find an In-Network therapist?
It is not unusual for therapists to limit the number of insurance patients in their practice, so it’s important to check in-network availability when you schedule your first appointment. In regions and times where therapy is in high demand it may take longer to get scheduled with an in-network therapist.

What is the difference between HMO and PPO insurance plans?
HMO health plans only cover in-network services, there is no reimbursement for out-of-network providers. PPO plans often cover both in- and out-of-network services, though the client may pay more for out-of-network services.

What is a Superbill?
A superbill is a receipt for therapy services. It provides all the information required by insurance companies to reimburse you for out-of-network services, including the diagnostic codes for your care, the amount paid, and the dates and duration of care.

Does insurance cover Online therapy?
Many therapists who shifted their practice to online therapy during the pandemic have kept that arrangement. And most insurers continue to cover telehealth services, with a few exceptions. Preventive care (such as an annual depression screening) is often required to be in-person to be covered, and some states require prescribers of controlled substances to see those patients in person.

Does insurance cover Group therapy?
Many insurance plans provide coverage for group therapy provided there is a medical diagnosis for group members, but there are some noteworthy exceptions. For example, Medicare does not always cover group therapy. Group therapy tends to cost less than individual therapy.

Does insurance cover Couples therapy?
Most insurance companies do not cover the cost of couples therapy because there is no medical diagnosis or medically necessary treatment. However, a few plans will offer a limited benefit, so it is still worth checking with your insurance company. Sometimes therapy is covered for a couple when one person has a diagnosis and another family member joins them for joint therapy, but it is considered therapy for the medical condition that includes a family member as a listener or helper, not couples counseling. Without insurance, most clients pay between $100-300 per 60-90 min session for couples therapy. Often clients can find classes or workshops that make it more affordable to work on their relationship. And some employers offer Employee Assistance Plans that help defray the cost of couples therapy.

What is an Employee Assistance Plan (EAP)?
Employee Assistance Plans are purchased by employers for the benefit of their employees. EAPs typically assist employees with referrals and may also provide the first few sessions of therapy free of charge, with the patient's regular health insurance kicking in after those initial sessions. EAP benefits often apply to all types of therapy without the need for a medical diagnosis, making it easier to access couples therapy, therapy for life transitions, and other non-medical counseling. Just as with standard health insurance, clients should always check that a provider accepts their EAP benefits before scheduling. Learn more about Insurance Coverage and Finding Affordable Therapy