BlueCross BlueShield Therapists in Lancaster, NY

Photo of Alexis Matusiewicz, Psychologist, PhD
Alexis Matusiewicz
Psychologist, PhD
Lancaster, NY 14086
Waitlist for new clients
I am in-network with Aetna, BlueCross and BlueShield, and Independent Health.
You may come to therapy wishing for change, wanting things to improve for you. Whether you are looking for symptom relief, growth in relationships, healing from past wounds, or starting a new chapter, therapy can be a useful tool. To regard your inner experience as worthy of curiosity and exploration is an act of hope, and the foundation of healing.
I am in-network with Aetna, BlueCross and BlueShield, and Independent Health.
You may come to therapy wishing for change, wanting things to improve for you. Whether you are looking for symptom relief, growth in relationships, healing from past wounds, or starting a new chapter, therapy can be a useful tool. To regard your inner experience as worthy of curiosity and exploration is an act of hope, and the foundation of healing.
(716) 321-2371 View (716) 321-2371
Photo of Ruth Johnson, Counselor, LMHC
Ruth Johnson
Counselor, LMHC
Online Only
I'm a Licensed Mental Health Counselor with a deep passion for helping individuals navigate anxiety and relationship struggles. I specialize in supporting individuals in managing depression, low self-esteem, and anger. I support adults who feel overwhelmed, stuck, or uncertain about the future—whether it’s balancing career and personal life, processing difficult emotions, or building self-worth. I’m dedicated to helping you identify and challenge negative thought patterns that affect your emotions and behaviors. Together, we’ll work on creating healthier coping strategies and building resilience to improve your well-being.
I'm a Licensed Mental Health Counselor with a deep passion for helping individuals navigate anxiety and relationship struggles. I specialize in supporting individuals in managing depression, low self-esteem, and anger. I support adults who feel overwhelmed, stuck, or uncertain about the future—whether it’s balancing career and personal life, processing difficult emotions, or building self-worth. I’m dedicated to helping you identify and challenge negative thought patterns that affect your emotions and behaviors. Together, we’ll work on creating healthier coping strategies and building resilience to improve your well-being.
(646) 718-4010 View (646) 718-4010
Photo of Jessica Allen, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, AAT-I, C-AAIS
Jessica Allen
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, AAT-I, C-AAIS
Lancaster, NY 14086
Waitlist for new clients
I strive to meet my clients where they are at without judgment or expectation; to offer a guiding light in the storms of life and provide a safe harbor. My approach to therapy is to provide individuals with a person-centered and strengths-based partnership grounded in trauma-informed evidence-based practices including EMDR, IFS-informed Parts Work, and Animal-Assisted Therapy Interventions (AAT).
I strive to meet my clients where they are at without judgment or expectation; to offer a guiding light in the storms of life and provide a safe harbor. My approach to therapy is to provide individuals with a person-centered and strengths-based partnership grounded in trauma-informed evidence-based practices including EMDR, IFS-informed Parts Work, and Animal-Assisted Therapy Interventions (AAT).
(716) 687-0288 View (716) 687-0288
Photo of Matthew Ryan McCabe, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, CISM
Matthew Ryan McCabe
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, CISM
1 Endorsed
Lancaster, NY 14086
I work with patients that experience a broad spectrum of mental health diagnoses including Depression, Bipolar Disorder, Anxiety, PTSD. I also have experience treating first responders and military/veterans. My patients that start with me are usually at a crossroads and need help solving problems that are paralyzing them in the moment.
I work with patients that experience a broad spectrum of mental health diagnoses including Depression, Bipolar Disorder, Anxiety, PTSD. I also have experience treating first responders and military/veterans. My patients that start with me are usually at a crossroads and need help solving problems that are paralyzing them in the moment.
(716) 412-2853 View (716) 412-2853
Photo of Dale Winchell, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Dale Winchell
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Serves Area
I am an in-network with BCBS, Independent Health, Nova, Univera, and Aetna insurances, accepting commercial plans and senior Medicare Advantage plans.
I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker who works with adolescents and adults. I believe anyone can benefit from counseling with an experienced, knowledgeable, and empathetic therapist like myself. I approach counseling from a trauma-informed perspective and use evidence-based practices and clinical techniques to help my clients. Every client is different, and thus, no single approach works with every client. I work with each client to identify their unique therapy goals, and together we make a plan and forge a path forward to achieve those goals together.
I am an in-network with BCBS, Independent Health, Nova, Univera, and Aetna insurances, accepting commercial plans and senior Medicare Advantage plans.
I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker who works with adolescents and adults. I believe anyone can benefit from counseling with an experienced, knowledgeable, and empathetic therapist like myself. I approach counseling from a trauma-informed perspective and use evidence-based practices and clinical techniques to help my clients. Every client is different, and thus, no single approach works with every client. I work with each client to identify their unique therapy goals, and together we make a plan and forge a path forward to achieve those goals together.
(716) 458-0055 View (716) 458-0055
Photo of Shannon Curry-Izzo, Licensed Mental Health Counselor, LMHC
Shannon Curry-Izzo
Licensed Mental Health Counselor, LMHC
1 Endorsed
Serves Area
Shannon Curry-Izzo is a person -centered and trauma informed clinician that graduated from Canisius College with a Masters in Clinical Mental Health Counseling. Shannon's expertise includes harm reduction, Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR), Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT), Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), and internal family systems. Whether facing challenges associated with trauma, mood disorders, grief and loss or life transitions, Shannon commits to honoring the individual experience through a lense of intersectionality, humility and compassion. Neurodivergent, LGBTQAI2+, disability affirming.
Shannon Curry-Izzo is a person -centered and trauma informed clinician that graduated from Canisius College with a Masters in Clinical Mental Health Counseling. Shannon's expertise includes harm reduction, Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR), Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT), Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), and internal family systems. Whether facing challenges associated with trauma, mood disorders, grief and loss or life transitions, Shannon commits to honoring the individual experience through a lense of intersectionality, humility and compassion. Neurodivergent, LGBTQAI2+, disability affirming.
(716) 961-7273 View (716) 961-7273
Photo of Cayla Cappello, Counselor, LMHC
Cayla Cappello
Counselor, LMHC
1 Endorsed
Serves Area
Often in life we are faced with challenges that can be difficult to overcome on our own. Everyone has their own story, and sometimes these stories are filled with pain and can leave us feeling stuck, overwhelmed, wounded. Whatever you're experiencing that brought you to this step may feel so huge and it may feel like things will never be okay, but they can be. Therapy is a process.
Often in life we are faced with challenges that can be difficult to overcome on our own. Everyone has their own story, and sometimes these stories are filled with pain and can leave us feeling stuck, overwhelmed, wounded. Whatever you're experiencing that brought you to this step may feel so huge and it may feel like things will never be okay, but they can be. Therapy is a process.
(716) 869-9156 View (716) 869-9156
Photo of Alicia Kohlhagen, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R, PMH-C
Alicia Kohlhagen
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R, PMH-C
1 Endorsed
Serves Area
I am a firm believer that our mental and emotional health are just as important as our physical health and wellness. More often than not, we put ourselves on the back burner, taking care of others needs and then ignoring our own. In the world we live in, it’s also easy to push our emotions to the side and tell ourselves we "shouldn't" feel this way. Living well doesn't have to mean sacrificing your needs for others, it might just mean, we chose to intentionally put our energy into things that fill us up and allow us to feel more centered.
I am a firm believer that our mental and emotional health are just as important as our physical health and wellness. More often than not, we put ourselves on the back burner, taking care of others needs and then ignoring our own. In the world we live in, it’s also easy to push our emotions to the side and tell ourselves we "shouldn't" feel this way. Living well doesn't have to mean sacrificing your needs for others, it might just mean, we chose to intentionally put our energy into things that fill us up and allow us to feel more centered.
(716) 324-3747 View (716) 324-3747
Photo of Kim Emminger, Counselor, LMHC
Kim Emminger
Counselor, LMHC
Serves Area
I am passionate about working with grief and loss clients, working through Trauma and PTSD, Co-occurring mental health Issues and womens issues across the lifespan. I utilizes CBT, DBT, Schema, ACT, Solution Focused, Motivational Interviewing and EMDR treatment modalities.
I am passionate about working with grief and loss clients, working through Trauma and PTSD, Co-occurring mental health Issues and womens issues across the lifespan. I utilizes CBT, DBT, Schema, ACT, Solution Focused, Motivational Interviewing and EMDR treatment modalities.
(716) 357-0100 View (716) 357-0100
Photo of Alexandra Wolf, Counselor, LMHC
Alexandra Wolf
Counselor, LMHC
Serves Area
Sometimes in life we find ourselves looking for a change or improvement but are unsure of how to go about doing so. My mission is to join you in creating a safe, non-judgmental space to conquer life’s challenges. Whether you want to find joy again, build self-esteem, improve your interpersonal relationships or identify tools to deal with life stressors, together we can develop an individualized plan to meet your goals. My approach to therapy is collaborative, direct, and compassionate. I often combine cognitive behavioral therapy, person centered therapy, and solution focused techniques based on individual need and therapy goals.
Sometimes in life we find ourselves looking for a change or improvement but are unsure of how to go about doing so. My mission is to join you in creating a safe, non-judgmental space to conquer life’s challenges. Whether you want to find joy again, build self-esteem, improve your interpersonal relationships or identify tools to deal with life stressors, together we can develop an individualized plan to meet your goals. My approach to therapy is collaborative, direct, and compassionate. I often combine cognitive behavioral therapy, person centered therapy, and solution focused techniques based on individual need and therapy goals.
(716) 281-5243 View (716) 281-5243
Photo of Jeffrey Fazzino, Counselor, LMHC-D
Jeffrey Fazzino
Counselor, LMHC-D
Serves Area
Now offering video, phone and in-person sessions! I am clinical mental health counselor specializing in depression, anxiety, personality disorders and marital/relationship concerns. My practice is currently accepting new clients and I am excited about working with new individuals. I offer counseling services to adolescents, adults, families, and couples. We will work in a collaborative relationship to get your needs met. If you are looking for a new and unique opportunity to explore yourself, contact me for more information on counseling services. I also provide supervision for counselors.
Now offering video, phone and in-person sessions! I am clinical mental health counselor specializing in depression, anxiety, personality disorders and marital/relationship concerns. My practice is currently accepting new clients and I am excited about working with new individuals. I offer counseling services to adolescents, adults, families, and couples. We will work in a collaborative relationship to get your needs met. If you are looking for a new and unique opportunity to explore yourself, contact me for more information on counseling services. I also provide supervision for counselors.
(716) 961-7273 View (716) 961-7273
Photo of Sarah Hartman - Sarah Hartman LMHC pllc, LMHC
Sarah Hartman LMHC pllc
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
Serves Area
Do you feel trapped in a cycle of anxiety, tension, or emotional overwhelm? At our practice we offer you a grounded, supportive space to begin or continue your mental health journey. We gently explore the roots of anxiety, trauma, and self-doubt, and life stressors to help you break free from patterns, build self-compassion, and reconnect with your inner resilience. Through a blend of cognitive and somatic therapies, we gently work with the mind and body to release discomfort in the body, explore nervous system regulation, and quiet the inner tension. Healing is journey filled possibilities and we aim to support you through it.
Do you feel trapped in a cycle of anxiety, tension, or emotional overwhelm? At our practice we offer you a grounded, supportive space to begin or continue your mental health journey. We gently explore the roots of anxiety, trauma, and self-doubt, and life stressors to help you break free from patterns, build self-compassion, and reconnect with your inner resilience. Through a blend of cognitive and somatic therapies, we gently work with the mind and body to release discomfort in the body, explore nervous system regulation, and quiet the inner tension. Healing is journey filled possibilities and we aim to support you through it.
View
Photo of Tracy Welch, Counselor, LMHC
Tracy Welch
Counselor, LMHC
2 Endorsed
Online Only
Exhaustion and overstimulation are your baseline these days, and it takes all you’ve got just to keep everything afloat. It feels like everyone wants a piece of you—at work, at home, everywhere. You want to show up for the people who count on you, but honestly, it's just too much—and you wish you could just set it down for a while. Even the simplest things—a noisy restaurant, or a bright grocery store—can feel like too much. You find yourself literally wanting to hide in a closet, hoping to slow everything down and find some peace, even for just a moment.
Exhaustion and overstimulation are your baseline these days, and it takes all you’ve got just to keep everything afloat. It feels like everyone wants a piece of you—at work, at home, everywhere. You want to show up for the people who count on you, but honestly, it's just too much—and you wish you could just set it down for a while. Even the simplest things—a noisy restaurant, or a bright grocery store—can feel like too much. You find yourself literally wanting to hide in a closet, hoping to slow everything down and find some peace, even for just a moment.
(716) 321-5198 View (716) 321-5198
Photo of Veronica Schiavone, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
Veronica Schiavone
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
Online Only
Many clients come to me because they're struggling with anxiety, burnout, or reproductive mental health concerns. You might be navigating fertility challenges, pregnancy loss, birth trauma, or PMDD. Others come in while planning for pregnancy or adjusting to postpartum changes. I also work with individuals managing OCD, mood disorders, autism, schizophrenia, or personality disorders. Together, we focus on reducing overwhelm, setting boundaries, and creating habits that support a more balanced life.
Many clients come to me because they're struggling with anxiety, burnout, or reproductive mental health concerns. You might be navigating fertility challenges, pregnancy loss, birth trauma, or PMDD. Others come in while planning for pregnancy or adjusting to postpartum changes. I also work with individuals managing OCD, mood disorders, autism, schizophrenia, or personality disorders. Together, we focus on reducing overwhelm, setting boundaries, and creating habits that support a more balanced life.
(646) 212-1021 View (646) 212-1021
Photo of Katie Oberg, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Katie Oberg
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
2 Endorsed
Serves Area
Waitlist for new clients
Immediate availability for clients with BCBS, Aetna and Cigna.
Hi, I’m Katie and I’m so glad you’re here! Does it sometimes feel like you have stress and unresolved feelings that have been hanging around since your MySpace profile was active? Have you spent years trying to analyze your feelings, attempting to overthink your way to relief, and still find yourself uncomfortable? Do everyday tasks sometimes make you feel like you’re being chased by a bear while your brain has 55 tabs open that are all making sound? Maybe you’ve been looking for a safe and cozy place where you can work on the feelings you've been carrying that have the deepest roots, and may have even triggered a chronic illness.
Immediate availability for clients with BCBS, Aetna and Cigna.
Hi, I’m Katie and I’m so glad you’re here! Does it sometimes feel like you have stress and unresolved feelings that have been hanging around since your MySpace profile was active? Have you spent years trying to analyze your feelings, attempting to overthink your way to relief, and still find yourself uncomfortable? Do everyday tasks sometimes make you feel like you’re being chased by a bear while your brain has 55 tabs open that are all making sound? Maybe you’ve been looking for a safe and cozy place where you can work on the feelings you've been carrying that have the deepest roots, and may have even triggered a chronic illness.
(716) 638-2303 View (716) 638-2303
Photo of Tabitha Vaughan, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Tabitha Vaughan
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
2 Endorsed
Serves Area
I have worked in the human services field for over 20 years and have been a licensed social worker since 2010. Throughout that time, I’ve had the privilege of working with individuals from diverse backgrounds as they navigate a wide range of life challenges. Many of the individuals I have worked with have experienced traumas that have led to struggles with either their emotional/mental well being and/or substance use. I deeply believe that regardless of the struggles people experience, everyone is capable of being a better version of themself and building a quality of life that gives them meaning and purpose.
I have worked in the human services field for over 20 years and have been a licensed social worker since 2010. Throughout that time, I’ve had the privilege of working with individuals from diverse backgrounds as they navigate a wide range of life challenges. Many of the individuals I have worked with have experienced traumas that have led to struggles with either their emotional/mental well being and/or substance use. I deeply believe that regardless of the struggles people experience, everyone is capable of being a better version of themself and building a quality of life that gives them meaning and purpose.
(716) 325-1414 View (716) 325-1414
Photo of Erin M Ruston, Counselor, MSEd, LMHC
Erin M Ruston
Counselor, MSEd, LMHC
3 Endorsed
Serves Area
Are you struggling with communication, lack of intimacy, feeling stagnant, or feel like you are living with a roommate and not a partner? I would love to work with you to explore how to improve your relationship in a variety of ways. I can help you explore the barriers within your relationship and how to improve communication, fair fighting, work through infidelity, and heighten sex/intimacy, both physically and emotionally.
Are you struggling with communication, lack of intimacy, feeling stagnant, or feel like you are living with a roommate and not a partner? I would love to work with you to explore how to improve your relationship in a variety of ways. I can help you explore the barriers within your relationship and how to improve communication, fair fighting, work through infidelity, and heighten sex/intimacy, both physically and emotionally.
(716) 771-2949 View (716) 771-2949
Photo of Richard Jimenez, Counselor, LMHC, CASAC
Richard Jimenez
Counselor, LMHC, CASAC
Serves Area
Feeling stuck, unfulfilled, or trapped in patterns you want to change? Are you struggling to shake feelings of depression, anxiety, unreasonable anger, negative self-talk, trauma, or difficult life transitions? Perhaps you're feeling disconnected from yourself or others, facing relationship or family conflicts, battling low self-esteem, or overwhelming stress and burnout. Maybe you've achieved many of the things you thought would bring happiness, yet still find yourself searching for purpose, meaning, and direction. Whatever brings you to therapy, I am committed to helping you gain insight and move towards a more meaningful life.
Feeling stuck, unfulfilled, or trapped in patterns you want to change? Are you struggling to shake feelings of depression, anxiety, unreasonable anger, negative self-talk, trauma, or difficult life transitions? Perhaps you're feeling disconnected from yourself or others, facing relationship or family conflicts, battling low self-esteem, or overwhelming stress and burnout. Maybe you've achieved many of the things you thought would bring happiness, yet still find yourself searching for purpose, meaning, and direction. Whatever brings you to therapy, I am committed to helping you gain insight and move towards a more meaningful life.
(716) 357-0100 View (716) 357-0100
Photo of Jillian Sternberg, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LMSW
Jillian Sternberg
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LMSW
Serves Area
If you find yourself facing the aftermath of trauma, or navigating the intricate landscape of grief and loss, I am here to offer support and understanding. Whether you're seeking affirmation and a safe space to explore your LGBTQ+ identity or dealing with the challenges of depression, anxiety, personality disorders, or substance use, your needs and goals are my priority. From kids to seniors, my practice spans across generations. Each age group receives personalized support designed to address their specific life stages and challenges.
If you find yourself facing the aftermath of trauma, or navigating the intricate landscape of grief and loss, I am here to offer support and understanding. Whether you're seeking affirmation and a safe space to explore your LGBTQ+ identity or dealing with the challenges of depression, anxiety, personality disorders, or substance use, your needs and goals are my priority. From kids to seniors, my practice spans across generations. Each age group receives personalized support designed to address their specific life stages and challenges.
(716) 961-7273 View (716) 961-7273
Photo of Christina Wojciechowski, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Christina Wojciechowski
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
1 Endorsed
Serves Area
Christina is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker who graduated from Daemen University. With several years of experience working with adults, children, adolescents, and families in both inpatient and outpatient settings, Christina has developed a well-rounded approach to mental health care utilizing a variety of evidence-based therapeutic tools, including play therapy, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR), and more. Christina’s approach is person-centered and trauma-informed, aimed at creating a safe, supportive environment for healing and growth.
Christina is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker who graduated from Daemen University. With several years of experience working with adults, children, adolescents, and families in both inpatient and outpatient settings, Christina has developed a well-rounded approach to mental health care utilizing a variety of evidence-based therapeutic tools, including play therapy, cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR), and more. Christina’s approach is person-centered and trauma-informed, aimed at creating a safe, supportive environment for healing and growth.
(716) 961-7273 View (716) 961-7273

See more therapy options for Lancaster

BlueCross and BlueShield Therapists
Does insurance cover therapy, prescriptions and other behavioral health services?
In general, yes. Laws in the U.S. require insurers to cover essential behavioral health care at the same level as other health care services. Most health plans require a medical diagnosis and treatments that are evidence based and medically essential. This means that life coaching and alternative therapies are not covered, nor is therapy without a diagnosis. Call the number on the back or your insurance card or visit your insurance company's website to review your Summary of Benefits. If you have insurance through your employer, your Human Resources department may also be able to answer questions.

How much does therapy cost with insurance?
The cost of therapy depends on your region, how much training and experience your therapist has, and the type of treatment. The rate for talk therapy generally falls between $100 and $250. For a client seeing an in-network provider, the cost of therapy is often similar to the cost of other health care services. Clients pay co-pays and may need to satisfy a plan’s deductible before benefits kick in.

What is the difference between In-Network and Out-of-Network insurance coverage?
An in-network provider has contracted with an insurer to get paid directly for services, and to accept the insurer’s rate of compensation. Clients are responsible for deductibles and copays. If a therapist is out of network, that means that the client pays the therapist directly for services at the therapist’s regular fee. Out-of-Network providers often give clients a receipt so that they can file for partial reimbursement with their insurance company.

Is it difficult to find an In-Network therapist?
It is not unusual for therapists to limit the number of insurance patients in their practice, so it’s important to check in-network availability when you schedule your first appointment. In regions and times where therapy is in high demand it may take longer to get scheduled with an in-network therapist.

What is the difference between HMO and PPO insurance plans?
HMO health plans only cover in-network services, there is no reimbursement for out-of-network providers. PPO plans often cover both in- and out-of-network services, though the client may pay more for out-of-network services.

What is a Superbill?
A superbill is a receipt for therapy services. It provides all the information required by insurance companies to reimburse you for out-of-network services, including the diagnostic codes for your care, the amount paid, and the dates and duration of care.

Does insurance cover Online therapy?
Many therapists who shifted their practice to online therapy during the pandemic have kept that arrangement. And most insurers continue to cover telehealth services, with a few exceptions. Preventive care (such as an annual depression screening) is often required to be in-person to be covered, and some states require prescribers of controlled substances to see those patients in person.

Does insurance cover Group therapy?
Many insurance plans provide coverage for group therapy provided there is a medical diagnosis for group members, but there are some noteworthy exceptions. For example, Medicare does not always cover group therapy. Group therapy tends to cost less than individual therapy.

Does insurance cover Couples therapy?
Most insurance companies do not cover the cost of couples therapy because there is no medical diagnosis or medically necessary treatment. However, a few plans will offer a limited benefit, so it is still worth checking with your insurance company. Sometimes therapy is covered for a couple when one person has a diagnosis and another family member joins them for joint therapy, but it is considered therapy for the medical condition that includes a family member as a listener or helper, not couples counseling. Without insurance, most clients pay between $100-300 per 60-90 min session for couples therapy. Often clients can find classes or workshops that make it more affordable to work on their relationship. And some employers offer benefit plans that help defray the cost of couples therapy. Learn more about Insurance Coverage and Finding Affordable Therapy