BlueCross BlueShield Therapists in Amherst, NY

Susan Sperrazza
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
1 Endorsed
Amherst, NY 14228
Life can sometimes present challenges that feel overwhelming, and it's important to seek support during these times. I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) with 20 years of experience dedicated to helping children and families navigate their difficulties. My approach is straightforward and honest, focusing on collaborative problem-solving strategies that empower you and your family.
Life can sometimes present challenges that feel overwhelming, and it's important to seek support during these times. I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) with 20 years of experience dedicated to helping children and families navigate their difficulties. My approach is straightforward and honest, focusing on collaborative problem-solving strategies that empower you and your family.
(716) 351-5974 View (716) 351-5974
Cara Maluchnik
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LMSW, CCM
Amherst, NY 14228
Asking for help can be one of the hardest things to do. If you are here reading this, then you have already taken the first step towards the path of healing. This journey doesn't have to be done alone, and it would be my honor to walk alongside you. Life can be unpredictable and many times we face difficult situations that impact our ability to live up to our full potential. I believe in your unlimited capacity to grow and change, and my passion is to help you improve your quality of life. Together, we will find solutions and create long-term changes.
Asking for help can be one of the hardest things to do. If you are here reading this, then you have already taken the first step towards the path of healing. This journey doesn't have to be done alone, and it would be my honor to walk alongside you. Life can be unpredictable and many times we face difficult situations that impact our ability to live up to our full potential. I believe in your unlimited capacity to grow and change, and my passion is to help you improve your quality of life. Together, we will find solutions and create long-term changes.
(716) 321-2127 x120 View (716) 321-2127 x120
Katie Janik
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R
Amherst, NY 14226
I specialize in the treatment of anxiety, depression and trauma informed care. I also specialize in the treatment of women's issues, not limited to infertility, pregnancy, and postpartum depression, anxiety & OCD. I have worked in the field of mental health for over 19 years and have developed trainings in mental heath, treatment and professional authority.
I specialize in the treatment of anxiety, depression and trauma informed care. I also specialize in the treatment of women's issues, not limited to infertility, pregnancy, and postpartum depression, anxiety & OCD. I have worked in the field of mental health for over 19 years and have developed trainings in mental heath, treatment and professional authority.
(716) 309-4345 View (716) 309-4345
Kristen T Wojtaszek
Counselor, LMHC-D
3 Endorsed
Amherst, NY 14228
I work with children (ages 6+), teens, and adults navigating anxiety, depression, trauma, PTSD, stress, relationship and communication challenges, parenting concerns, life transitions, low self-esteem, emotional regulation difficulties, and substance use recovery. My approach is person-centered, trauma-informed, and strength-based, creating a safe, supportive environment where clients feel heard and understood. Together, we build practical coping skills, improve relationships, increase confidence, and develop lasting strategies that promote resilience, healing, and meaningful personal growth.
I work with children (ages 6+), teens, and adults navigating anxiety, depression, trauma, PTSD, stress, relationship and communication challenges, parenting concerns, life transitions, low self-esteem, emotional regulation difficulties, and substance use recovery. My approach is person-centered, trauma-informed, and strength-based, creating a safe, supportive environment where clients feel heard and understood. Together, we build practical coping skills, improve relationships, increase confidence, and develop lasting strategies that promote resilience, healing, and meaningful personal growth.
(716) 354-3064 View (716) 354-3064
Matthew H. Davis
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Amherst, NY 14228
Waitlist for new clients
Are you feeling overwhelmed by anxiety, weighed down by depression, or stuck in patterns that are affecting your relationships or sense of self-worth? You're not alone—and you don’t have to navigate it alone. I work with individuals, couples, and families to help create real, sustainable change through compassionate, evidence-based therapy. I integrate CBT, DBT, mindfulness, and relational work, while also offering animal-assisted therapy. My goal is to create a space that feels both safe and empowering, where you can uncover deeper self-awareness and move toward growth with practical tools and emotional support.
Are you feeling overwhelmed by anxiety, weighed down by depression, or stuck in patterns that are affecting your relationships or sense of self-worth? You're not alone—and you don’t have to navigate it alone. I work with individuals, couples, and families to help create real, sustainable change through compassionate, evidence-based therapy. I integrate CBT, DBT, mindfulness, and relational work, while also offering animal-assisted therapy. My goal is to create a space that feels both safe and empowering, where you can uncover deeper self-awareness and move toward growth with practical tools and emotional support.
(716) 355-0306 View (716) 355-0306
Jean M Brandt
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R
Amherst, NY 14228
Sometimes people find themselves thinking about going into counseling for a number of reasons such as feelings of sadness, excessive worry, sleep difficulties, irritability, low energy, loss of interest in activities, or due to problems in relationships. The decision of whether or not to start counseling and who to see, is not an easy one, and can take trial and error in finding the "right fit". I recognize that there are many options in the Buffalo/Niagara area, but I would like to offer you something different from what you may have experienced or heard about counselors in the past.
Sometimes people find themselves thinking about going into counseling for a number of reasons such as feelings of sadness, excessive worry, sleep difficulties, irritability, low energy, loss of interest in activities, or due to problems in relationships. The decision of whether or not to start counseling and who to see, is not an easy one, and can take trial and error in finding the "right fit". I recognize that there are many options in the Buffalo/Niagara area, but I would like to offer you something different from what you may have experienced or heard about counselors in the past.
(716) 437-6520 View (716) 437-6520
Nicole Cornell
Counselor, MS, LMHC-D
2 Endorsed
Amherst, NY 14228
You don’t have to face it alone. Whether you're navigating the overwhelming waves of anxiety, the deep fog of depression, or the complex emotions that can arise during or after pregnancy, support is here. I specialize in helping women and teens find clarity, resilience, and hope during some of life’s most difficult moments. With a compassionate and non-judgmental approach, I provide a safe space where you can explore what you’re feeling, understand what’s beneath it, and begin to heal. Whether you're a teen feeling lost in the pressure to be “okay,” or a new mother struggling to recognize herself in the midst of postpartum changes,
You don’t have to face it alone. Whether you're navigating the overwhelming waves of anxiety, the deep fog of depression, or the complex emotions that can arise during or after pregnancy, support is here. I specialize in helping women and teens find clarity, resilience, and hope during some of life’s most difficult moments. With a compassionate and non-judgmental approach, I provide a safe space where you can explore what you’re feeling, understand what’s beneath it, and begin to heal. Whether you're a teen feeling lost in the pressure to be “okay,” or a new mother struggling to recognize herself in the midst of postpartum changes,
(716) 300-2366 View (716) 300-2366
Jennifer Halper
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R
3 Endorsed
Online Only
Waitlist for new clients
I know it can seem like a challenge to find a good therapist, but it is absolutely worth it to push forward until you find the best fit for you! I prioritize helping my clients find the strength and resilience needed to get through what life brings to the table. I use multiple therapeutic approaches with each client and tailor therapy to your individual needs. As a trauma therapist specifically, I take great pride in building a strong therapeutic relationship with the clients I see, as I believe that is the foundation of effective therapy. I am licensed to see clients in New York, Colorado, Florida, South Carolina and Nevada.
I know it can seem like a challenge to find a good therapist, but it is absolutely worth it to push forward until you find the best fit for you! I prioritize helping my clients find the strength and resilience needed to get through what life brings to the table. I use multiple therapeutic approaches with each client and tailor therapy to your individual needs. As a trauma therapist specifically, I take great pride in building a strong therapeutic relationship with the clients I see, as I believe that is the foundation of effective therapy. I am licensed to see clients in New York, Colorado, Florida, South Carolina and Nevada.
(917) 909-8027 View (917) 909-8027
Paula J Ruefli-Spears
Counselor, MA, LMHC, MFT
Amherst, NY 14226
Attollo Counseling Services was born from a passion for promoting satisfying relationships, healthy families, meaningful marriages, and strong resilient individuals as they pursue their hopes, dreams, and happiness. While we all want these things, nothing is guaranteed except life will present challenges to take us off-course. Whether you are going through a major life adjustment, experiencing grief/loss, struggling to decide what steps to take towards your future, experiencing relationship challenges, or embarking on a new journey in life; you don't have to do it alone. We believe in compassion, collaboration, and creativity.
Attollo Counseling Services was born from a passion for promoting satisfying relationships, healthy families, meaningful marriages, and strong resilient individuals as they pursue their hopes, dreams, and happiness. While we all want these things, nothing is guaranteed except life will present challenges to take us off-course. Whether you are going through a major life adjustment, experiencing grief/loss, struggling to decide what steps to take towards your future, experiencing relationship challenges, or embarking on a new journey in life; you don't have to do it alone. We believe in compassion, collaboration, and creativity.
(716) 226-5130 View (716) 226-5130
Dr. Kristin L. Keller
Verified Verified
Amherst, NY 14228
Therapy is a tool to help a person become the best version of themselves. Trauma, stress, unhealthy relationships, poor coping skills, emotional dys-regulation are all factors that contribute to being unwell. Counseling allows a person to work through those barriers and improve the way that they manage stress, find healthy ways to express emotions, work through trauma that has caused you harm, build tools to have healthy, productive, relationships with others and ultimately find alternate ways to cope with distressing events within our lives. A counselor is not only a therapist, but a guide and facilitator of growth.
Therapy is a tool to help a person become the best version of themselves. Trauma, stress, unhealthy relationships, poor coping skills, emotional dys-regulation are all factors that contribute to being unwell. Counseling allows a person to work through those barriers and improve the way that they manage stress, find healthy ways to express emotions, work through trauma that has caused you harm, build tools to have healthy, productive, relationships with others and ultimately find alternate ways to cope with distressing events within our lives. A counselor is not only a therapist, but a guide and facilitator of growth.
(716) 272-1282 View (716) 272-1282
Peter Meglin
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R
1 Endorsed
Amherst, NY 14226
I am a licensed and seasoned clinical social worker (LCSW-R) in practice for 30+ years, specializing in couples and individual therapy. My academic training was at the University at Buffalo; my post-graduate and continuing education was at The Marriage Counseling Center, where I mentored new therapists and developed a strong word-of-mouth following. Couples work included, but was not limited to, these critical issues: emotionally focused communication, destructive conflict patterns, emotional and physical intimacy, infidelity and trust repair, pre-marital assessment, commitment, and discernment of ultimate relationship habitability.
I am a licensed and seasoned clinical social worker (LCSW-R) in practice for 30+ years, specializing in couples and individual therapy. My academic training was at the University at Buffalo; my post-graduate and continuing education was at The Marriage Counseling Center, where I mentored new therapists and developed a strong word-of-mouth following. Couples work included, but was not limited to, these critical issues: emotionally focused communication, destructive conflict patterns, emotional and physical intimacy, infidelity and trust repair, pre-marital assessment, commitment, and discernment of ultimate relationship habitability.
(716) 638-2185 View (716) 638-2185
Lauren Walters
Mental Health Counselor, LMHC
1 Endorsed
Amherst, NY 14226
Every human being deserves to feel loved, connected, and validated. Therapy can help you build a better relationship with yourself and others. Although it may be difficult, you have the ability to learn how to cope more effectively. I strive to create a space where all parts of you are welcome.
Every human being deserves to feel loved, connected, and validated. Therapy can help you build a better relationship with yourself and others. Although it may be difficult, you have the ability to learn how to cope more effectively. I strive to create a space where all parts of you are welcome.
(716) 261-2817 View (716) 261-2817
Olivia Piegay
Psychologist, PhD
Amherst, NY 14226
Waitlist for new clients
In my current practice, I provide a range of evaluation services including comprehensive evaluations for autism spectrum disorder, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), cognitive assessments, assessments of adaptive and social/emotional functioning, and more. I also provide individual therapy services on a limited basis. Please reach out to learn more.
In my current practice, I provide a range of evaluation services including comprehensive evaluations for autism spectrum disorder, Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), cognitive assessments, assessments of adaptive and social/emotional functioning, and more. I also provide individual therapy services on a limited basis. Please reach out to learn more.
(716) 528-6679 View (716) 528-6679
Glenn W Frost
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R
Amherst, NY 14226
My clients come to see me seeking assistance for a wide variety of issues related to anxiety, depression, mental/physical illness, grief and loss, trauma, stress, and unexplained anger. I believe in exploring issues from a family perspective; where did you come from and how did you come to be who, and how, you are? When you struggle in your life, it can sometimes become too easy to focus solely on what is wrong, forgetting what is right. Working together, you can get back on the right path.
My clients come to see me seeking assistance for a wide variety of issues related to anxiety, depression, mental/physical illness, grief and loss, trauma, stress, and unexplained anger. I believe in exploring issues from a family perspective; where did you come from and how did you come to be who, and how, you are? When you struggle in your life, it can sometimes become too easy to focus solely on what is wrong, forgetting what is right. Working together, you can get back on the right path.
(716) 417-9998 View (716) 417-9998
Lindsey Bala
Counselor, LMHC-D
3 Endorsed
Amherst, NY 14228
Hi, I am a psychotherapist who works with adult (18+) individuals to address a wide range of emotional, relational, and life challenges. I believe the most effective therapy is a collaborative process, where we work together as a team to identify what’s not working and build practical, meaningful solutions that fit your life. My goal is to help you feel supported, understood, and actively involved in your own healing. We begin by establishing a strong therapeutic alliance—creating a space that feels safe, nonjudgmental, and grounded in trust.
Hi, I am a psychotherapist who works with adult (18+) individuals to address a wide range of emotional, relational, and life challenges. I believe the most effective therapy is a collaborative process, where we work together as a team to identify what’s not working and build practical, meaningful solutions that fit your life. My goal is to help you feel supported, understood, and actively involved in your own healing. We begin by establishing a strong therapeutic alliance—creating a space that feels safe, nonjudgmental, and grounded in trust.
(716) 466-9368 View (716) 466-9368
Kariann Hickein
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R
1 Endorsed
Amherst, NY 14221
Seeking therapy can be frustrating, overwhelming and scary. You hope to find someone who understands what you're going through, what you've been through or what you're about to face. Life can be difficult and complicated. Sometimes we feel alone and need someone to talk to or we just want someone who is not in our circle. Someone who won't judge. Someone who will take the time to listen and give a different perspective. We all have different ways of approaching problems, managing them and getting the outcomes we desire. Therapy is about finding what works best for you and working together towards it.
Seeking therapy can be frustrating, overwhelming and scary. You hope to find someone who understands what you're going through, what you've been through or what you're about to face. Life can be difficult and complicated. Sometimes we feel alone and need someone to talk to or we just want someone who is not in our circle. Someone who won't judge. Someone who will take the time to listen and give a different perspective. We all have different ways of approaching problems, managing them and getting the outcomes we desire. Therapy is about finding what works best for you and working together towards it.
(716) 437-6483 View (716) 437-6483
Kristine E Pieczonka
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
1 Endorsed
Amherst, NY 14228
Waitlist for new clients
My goal is to provide every client with a safe and supportive space where they feel heard, respected, and empowered. I offer a compassionate listening ear, honest guidance, and practical strategies tailored to each individual’s unique needs. My areas of focus include: couples therapy: communication/ relationship, emotion regulation, self-care, , school-related challenges, behavioral concerns, and conflict management. Every challenge is unique, and every person’s experience matters. Whether you’re navigating anxiety, relationship concerns, conflict, identity exploration; I am here to support and look forward to speaking with you.
My goal is to provide every client with a safe and supportive space where they feel heard, respected, and empowered. I offer a compassionate listening ear, honest guidance, and practical strategies tailored to each individual’s unique needs. My areas of focus include: couples therapy: communication/ relationship, emotion regulation, self-care, , school-related challenges, behavioral concerns, and conflict management. Every challenge is unique, and every person’s experience matters. Whether you’re navigating anxiety, relationship concerns, conflict, identity exploration; I am here to support and look forward to speaking with you.
(716) 221-6994 View (716) 221-6994
John Catalino
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R
1 Endorsed
Amherst, NY 14226
Feeling overwhelmed and feel your thoughts and moods run your life? And do you feel this prevents you from living life to its fullest? I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (R), and have been a therapist since 2008. I can begin therapy within 1 week of your initial call! Often through sharing our thoughts and struggles with a skilled, empathetic professional, hope can be restored. Also, by learning a few key thinking strategies and other simple mental techniques, together we can reduce and eliminate the feelings of being powerless over how our minds automatically can work against us. NOTE: Couples sessions are cash only - $150.
Feeling overwhelmed and feel your thoughts and moods run your life? And do you feel this prevents you from living life to its fullest? I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (R), and have been a therapist since 2008. I can begin therapy within 1 week of your initial call! Often through sharing our thoughts and struggles with a skilled, empathetic professional, hope can be restored. Also, by learning a few key thinking strategies and other simple mental techniques, together we can reduce and eliminate the feelings of being powerless over how our minds automatically can work against us. NOTE: Couples sessions are cash only - $150.
(716) 221-8728 View (716) 221-8728
Kristopher Stiles
Counselor, LMHC
Amherst, NY 14221
Welcome! I'm Kristopher Stiles, a licensed mental health counselor, and I'm dedicated to providing a safe and nurturing environment for individuals and families seeking support for anxiety, depression, and behavioral concerns. Is your child struggling with anxiety, depression, or behavioral challenges? My approach blends evidence-based therapeutic techniques with a compassionate understanding of young minds. Together, we'll work to uncover the root causes and develop coping strategies to foster emotional resilience.
Welcome! I'm Kristopher Stiles, a licensed mental health counselor, and I'm dedicated to providing a safe and nurturing environment for individuals and families seeking support for anxiety, depression, and behavioral concerns. Is your child struggling with anxiety, depression, or behavioral challenges? My approach blends evidence-based therapeutic techniques with a compassionate understanding of young minds. Together, we'll work to uncover the root causes and develop coping strategies to foster emotional resilience.
(716) 325-4320 View (716) 325-4320
Sara Kathleen Lis
Counselor, LMHC
Amherst, NY 14226
Sigmund Freud once said, “Out of your vulnerabilities will come your strength.” For me, this quote has always encapsulated one of the most important aspects of mental health. I believe that our ability to grow comes from our ability to heal; and for us to heal we need to be able to cope with our deepest struggles. It is in the act of opening up that we make our day-to-day existence an opportunity to develop as people; it’s how we become more resilient, and in the process of being vulnerable with others, we learn to love ourselves.
Sigmund Freud once said, “Out of your vulnerabilities will come your strength.” For me, this quote has always encapsulated one of the most important aspects of mental health. I believe that our ability to grow comes from our ability to heal; and for us to heal we need to be able to cope with our deepest struggles. It is in the act of opening up that we make our day-to-day existence an opportunity to develop as people; it’s how we become more resilient, and in the process of being vulnerable with others, we learn to love ourselves.
(716) 356-2022 View (716) 356-2022

See more therapy options for Amherst

BlueCross and BlueShield Therapists
Does insurance cover therapy, prescriptions and other behavioral health services?
In general, yes. Laws in the U.S. require insurers to cover essential behavioral health care at the same level as other health care services. Most health plans require a medical diagnosis and treatments that are evidence based and medically essential. This means that life coaching and alternative therapies are not covered, nor is therapy without a diagnosis. Call the number on the back or your insurance card or visit your insurance company's website to review your Summary of Benefits. If you have insurance through your employer, your Human Resources department may also be able to answer questions.

How much does therapy cost with insurance?
The cost of therapy depends on your region, how much training and experience your therapist has, and the type of treatment. The rate for talk therapy generally falls between $100 and $250. For a client seeing an in-network provider, the cost of therapy is often similar to the cost of other health care services. Clients pay co-pays and may need to satisfy a plan’s deductible before benefits kick in.

What is the difference between In-Network and Out-of-Network insurance coverage?
An in-network provider has contracted with an insurer to get paid directly for services, and to accept the insurer’s rate of compensation. Clients are responsible for deductibles and copays. If a therapist is out of network, that means that the client pays the therapist directly for services at the therapist’s regular fee. Out-of-Network providers often give clients a receipt so that they can file for partial reimbursement with their insurance company.

Is it difficult to find an In-Network therapist?
It is not unusual for therapists to limit the number of insurance patients in their practice, so it’s important to check in-network availability when you schedule your first appointment. In regions and times where therapy is in high demand it may take longer to get scheduled with an in-network therapist.

What is the difference between HMO and PPO insurance plans?
HMO health plans only cover in-network services, there is no reimbursement for out-of-network providers. PPO plans often cover both in- and out-of-network services, though the client may pay more for out-of-network services.

What is a Superbill?
A superbill is a receipt for therapy services. It provides all the information required by insurance companies to reimburse you for out-of-network services, including the diagnostic codes for your care, the amount paid, and the dates and duration of care.

Does insurance cover Online therapy?
Many therapists who shifted their practice to online therapy during the pandemic have kept that arrangement. And most insurers continue to cover telehealth services, with a few exceptions. Preventive care (such as an annual depression screening) is often required to be in-person to be covered, and some states require prescribers of controlled substances to see those patients in person.

Does insurance cover Group therapy?
Many insurance plans provide coverage for group therapy provided there is a medical diagnosis for group members, but there are some noteworthy exceptions. For example, Medicare does not always cover group therapy. Group therapy tends to cost less than individual therapy.

Does insurance cover Couples therapy?
Most insurance companies do not cover the cost of couples therapy because there is no medical diagnosis or medically necessary treatment. However, a few plans will offer a limited benefit, so it is still worth checking with your insurance company. Sometimes therapy is covered for a couple when one person has a diagnosis and another family member joins them for joint therapy, but it is considered therapy for the medical condition that includes a family member as a listener or helper, not couples counseling. Without insurance, most clients pay between $100-300 per 60-90 min session for couples therapy. Often clients can find classes or workshops that make it more affordable to work on their relationship. And some employers offer benefit plans that help defray the cost of couples therapy. Learn more about Insurance Coverage and Finding Affordable Therapy