Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Email Me
or
Email Me
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC

Natalie Kelley

Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC (she, her)

Verified by Psychology Today Verified by Psychology Today
2 Endorsed
Call Me
Let's Connect (463) 222-5034
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Available both in-person and online
2135 Prospect Street Indianapolis, IN 46203
I work with teens (15+), young adults, college students, and adults who may feel overwhelmed, stuck, disconnected from themselves, or uncertain about how to move forward. Many are navigating anxiety, depression, trauma, relationship challenges, stress, identity exploration, life transitions, burnout, or the pressures that come with balancing school, work, relationships, and everyday life. Some clients come to therapy feeling emotionally exhausted or unsure where to begin, while others are looking to better understand themselves, improve coping skills, process difficult experiences, or create healthier patterns and relationships.
I help clients navigate anxiety, depression, trauma, relationship challenges, stress, and life transitions. I hold a Behavioral Health Trauma Certification. I offer a warm, collaborative approach focused on building coping skills, processing difficult experiences, and helping clients feel more empowered and connected in their daily lives.
Starting therapy can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re used to handling things on your own. You don’t have to navigate it all alone. I strive to create a supportive, nonjudgmental space where you can feel heard, understood, and comfortable showing up as yourself. I’d be honored to support you in your healing and growth.
Call or Natalie Kelley now for a free 15 minute consultation - (463) 222-5034

My Practice at a Glance

Available both in-person and online

2135 Prospect Street

Indianapolis, IN 46203 map

(463) 222-5034
My website
I offer in-person and virtual therapy for teens and adults across Indiana, with weekday daytime and some evening availability.
$150 Per Session, I accept insurance 
I see individuals, couples and families  
Let's Connect (463) 222-5034
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC

My Practice at a Glance

Available both in-person and online

2135 Prospect Street

Indianapolis, IN 46203 map

(463) 222-5034
My website
I offer in-person and virtual therapy for teens and adults across Indiana, with weekday daytime and some evening availability.
$150 Per Session, I accept insurance 
I see individuals, couples and families  

Finances

Fees

  • Individual Sessions $150
  • Couple Sessions $150
  • Sliding scale: apply if you may be eligible

Payment Methods

American Express, Discover, Health Savings Account, Mastercard

Insurance

  • Ambetter
  • Anthem
  • BlueCross and BlueShield
  • CareSource
  • Cigna and Evernorth
  • Managed Health Network (MHN)
  • Medicaid
  • Medicare
  • Optum
  • TRICARE
  • United Medical Resources (UMR)
  • UnitedHealthcare UHC | UBH
  • Out of Network
"
I offer individual, couples, and family counseling sessions for teens, college students, and adults. We accept most major insurance plans, including Indiana Medicaid and Medicare, as well as self-pay clients. If you have questions about coverage, fees, or scheduling, feel free to reach out.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call or for a free 15 minute consultation now - (463) 222-5034
"
I offer individual, couples, and family counseling sessions for teens, college students, and adults. We accept most major insurance plans, including Indiana Medicaid and Medicare, as well as self-pay clients. If you have questions about coverage, fees, or scheduling, feel free to reach out.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call or for a free 15 minute consultation now - (463) 222-5034

Qualifications

  • Verified by Psychology Today Prelicense by State of Indiana / 88003311A Supervised by Sam Leffers (Indiana / 39005534A) Natalie Kelley
  • Education and Years In Practice

  • In Practice for 1 year
  • Attended University of Indianapolis, Master of Arts in Mental Health Counseling, Graduated 2026
  • Additional Credentials

  • Degree/Diploma from DePauw University Master of Arts in Communication / 2021
"
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate (LMHCA) with a BH Trauma Certification and experience working with teens, college students, and adults in university and community mental health settings. My approach is warm, collaborative, trauma-informed, and focused on helping clients feel empowered.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call or for a free 15 minute consultation now - (463) 222-5034
"
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate (LMHCA) with a BH Trauma Certification and experience working with teens, college students, and adults in university and community mental health settings. My approach is warm, collaborative, trauma-informed, and focused on helping clients feel empowered.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call or for a free 15 minute consultation now - (463) 222-5034

Specialties and Expertise

Expertise

  • Anxiety
  • Borderline Personality (BPD)
  • Chronic Illness
  • Coping Skills
  • Depression
  • Dissociative Disorders (DID)
  • Dual Diagnosis
  • Emotional Disturbance
  • Emotional Regulation
  • Family Conflict
  • Grief
  • LGBTQ+
  • Mood Disorders
  • Peer Relationships
  • Personality Disorders
  • Relationship Issues
  • School Issues
  • Self Esteem
  • Self-Harming
  • Sports Performance
  • Stress
  • Substance Use
  • Suicidal Ideation
  • Trauma and PTSD
  • Women's Issues
"
I help clients navigate anxiety, depression, trauma, stress, relationship challenges, burnout, and life transitions. Treatment may involve building coping skills, processing difficult experiences, improving communication and boundaries, and developing healthier patterns. Clients often gain greater insight, confidence, resilience, and balance in daily life.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call or for a free 15 minute consultation now - (463) 222-5034
"
I help clients navigate anxiety, depression, trauma, stress, relationship challenges, burnout, and life transitions. Treatment may involve building coping skills, processing difficult experiences, improving communication and boundaries, and developing healthier patterns. Clients often gain greater insight, confidence, resilience, and balance in daily life.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call or for a free 15 minute consultation now - (463) 222-5034

2 Endorsements

Lauren Bojrab
Lauren Bojrab
Pre-Licensed ProfessionalMALMHCA
Natalie brings such an amazing energy and passion into her work with her clients. She is a very genuine counselor with a calming and welcoming presence who works alongside her clients to support them in their healing. Highly recommend her!
Hope Yeoman
Hope Yeoman
Licensed Mental Health Counselor AssociateLMHCAMA
Natalie is a thoughtful and open-minded clinician. She approaches clients with empathy and warmth, giving them a space to feel heard and understood. She is a wonderful choice for a therapist!

Client Focus

Age

Children (6 to 10)
Preteen
Teen
Adults
Elders (65+)

Participants

Individuals
Couples
Family

Age

Children (6 to 10)
Preteen
Teen
Adults
Elders (65+)

Participants

Individuals
Couples
Family

Treatment Approach

Types of Therapy

  • Cognitive Behavioral (CBT)
  • Cognitive Processing (CPT)
  • Culturally Sensitive
  • Dialectical Behavior (DBT)
  • Eclectic
  • Humanistic
  • Integrative
  • Internal Family Systems (IFS)
  • Mindfulness-Based (MBCT)
  • Motivational Interviewing
  • Multicultural
  • Person-Centered
  • Somatic
  • Strength-Based
  • Trauma Focused
"
I use a person-centered/eclectic, collaborative, and trauma-informed approach that may incorporate CBT, ACT, mindfulness, solution-focused therapy, and strengths-based techniques tailored to each client's needs. Sessions are supportive, nonjudgmental, and focused on helping you better understand yourself, build practical coping skills, and feel more empowered and connected in your daily life.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call or for a free 15 minute consultation now - (463) 222-5034
"
I use a person-centered/eclectic, collaborative, and trauma-informed approach that may incorporate CBT, ACT, mindfulness, solution-focused therapy, and strengths-based techniques tailored to each client's needs. Sessions are supportive, nonjudgmental, and focused on helping you better understand yourself, build practical coping skills, and feel more empowered and connected in your daily life.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call or for a free 15 minute consultation now - (463) 222-5034

Location

Primary Location

2135 Prospect Street

Indianapolis, IN 46203

(463) 222-5034

Nearby Areas

Counties

Zips

Neighborhoods

"
I offer in-person and virtual therapy for teens and adults across Indiana, with weekday daytime and some evening availability.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call for a free consultation now - (463) 222-5034
"
I offer in-person and virtual therapy for teens and adults across Indiana, with weekday daytime and some evening availability.
Photo of Natalie Kelley, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Natalie Kelley
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, LMHCA, MA, NCC
Call for a free consultation now - (463) 222-5034