Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR

Email Me

(845) 205-7670 Call Me

Email Me

Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR

Verified by Psychology Today Verified by Psychology Today

12 Endorsed

Call Me

Let's Connect (845) 205-7670

Available both in-person and online

New York, NY 10016

My website

For the past 12 years, I have worked with individuals navigating anxiety, codependency, addiction, and eating disorders. I work best with people who are motivated and ready to make meaningful changes—especially those who have been struggling on their own and are looking for additional support. I strive to create a warm, honest, and nonjudgmental space where you feel seen, understood, and accepted for who you are. My approach is relational and collaborative, meeting you where you are while gently challenging the limiting beliefs and patterns that may be keeping you from the life you want.

My expertise is as a EMDR-certified therapist, specializing in treatment for both "big T" and "little t" traumas. I also am trained in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Dialectical Behavioral Therapy (DBT), Internal Family Systems (IFS), and mindfulness techniques. My approach is warm, collaborative, and rooted in trauma-informed work.

I believe that human connection is at the heart of meaningful therapy. My goal is to build a genuine, trusting relationship where you feel supported and empowered to grow. I work with a diverse range of clients, including healthcare providers, parents, and high achievers. I invite you to reach out for a 15 min consultation to see if we are a good match.

Call or Email Lindsay McGarril now for a free 15 minute consultation - (845) 205-7670

My Practice at a Glance

Available both in-person and online

McGarril Mental Health Counseling

McGarril Mental Health Counseling, P.C.

New York, NY 10016

(845) 205-7670

upper east side

New York, NY 10075

My website

I am offering both virtual and in person appointments in midtown Manhattan. I am licensed in NY, CT, VT & FL.

I specialize in Depression, Eating Disorders and Anxiety

$225 Per Session, I accept insurance

I see individuals, couples and families

Hello! I aim to offer support with whatever challenges you may be struggling with and will work with you to create new ways to cope!

Let's Connect (845) 205-7670

My Practice at a Glance

Available both in-person and online

McGarril Mental Health Counseling

McGarril Mental Health Counseling, P.C.

New York, NY 10016

(845) 205-7670

upper east side

New York, NY 10075

My website

I am offering both virtual and in person appointments in midtown Manhattan. I am licensed in NY, CT, VT & FL.

I specialize in Depression, Eating Disorders and Anxiety

$225 Per Session, I accept insurance

I see individuals, couples and families

Hello! I aim to offer support with whatever challenges you may be struggling with and will work with you to create new ways to cope!

Finances

Fees

Individual Sessions $225
Couple Sessions $250
Sliding scale: apply if you may be eligible

Payment Methods

American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, Health Savings Account, Mastercard, Paypal, Venmo, Visa

Insurance

1199SEIU
Aetna
Aetna Student Health
Affinity Health Plan
Anthem
Blue Cross
Blue Shield
BlueCross and BlueShield
Carelon Behavioral Health
CDPHP
Cigna and Evernorth
EmblemHealth
Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield
Government Employees Health Association (GEHA)
Group Health Incorporated (GHI)
HIP | Health Plan of New York
Humana
MagnaCare
NYSHIP | NY State Empire Plan
Optum
Oscar Health
Oxford
TRICARE
United Medical Resources (UMR)
UnitedHealthcare UHC | UBH
WellCare
Wellfleet
Out of Network

With all insurances I accept Out of Network benefits and I can supply you with a superbill where insurance often can reimburse up to 80 percent of your session costs.

Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (845) 205-7670

With all insurances I accept Out of Network benefits and I can supply you with a superbill where insurance often can reimburse up to 80 percent of your session costs.

Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (845) 205-7670

Qualifications

Verified by Psychology Today Licensed by State of New York / 009533 Lindsay McGarril

Education and Years In Practice

In Practice for 11 years

Attended John Jay College of Criminal Justice, Graduated 2016

Additional Credentials

Certificate from Certified EMDRIA therapist 2025

I am licensed in NY, CT, VT and FL and have a decade of experience supporting teens and adults with mental health struggles across all settings. I am also an EMDR consultation in training (CIT) and work to mentor other clinicians in EMDR therapy.

Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (845) 205-7670

Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (845) 205-7670

Specialties and Expertise

Top Specialties

Depression
Eating Disorders
Anxiety

Expertise

Addiction
ADHD
Alcohol Use
Anger Management
Behavioral Issues
Bipolar Disorder
Body Image
Career Counseling
Chronic Impulsivity
Codependency
Coping Skills
Divorce
Drug Abuse
Dual Diagnosis
Emotional Disturbance
Family Conflict
Grief
Life Coaching
Life Transitions
Marital and Premarital
Obsessive-Compulsive (OCD)
Parenting
Peer Relationships
Relationship Issues
School Issues
Self Esteem
Sleep or Insomnia
Spirituality
Stress
Substance Use
Trauma and PTSD
Weight Loss
Women's Issues

I work with clients who may be battling anxiety or trauma related to their interpersonal relationships. During our initial sessions, we will explore these issues and collaborate to create a plan to ease them to be able to move forward. Many of my clients see a reduction of their issues within the first month or two and then continued improvement long-term for months and years after.

Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (845) 205-7670

Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (845) 205-7670

12 Endorsements

Lindsay Snow Hayden

Counselor, LMHC

Kate Feiner Lorenzoni

Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW

Elisa Gizzo

Marriage & Family Therapist, LMFT

Alexa Ferst

Pre-Licensed Professional, MHC-LP

Lindsay is a kind and compassionate clinician with extensive experience in the field.

Olivia Clavie

MA, MHC-LP

Lindsay is amazing to work with professionally and has a strong passion for their work with clients. I highly recommend them as a counselor.

Rebecca W Heller

Mental Health Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, PMH-C

Lindsay is an incredible supervisor and I have learned/I am continuing to learn so much from her! I can tell she is passionate about the work she does and her clients are lucky to have her.

Olivia Clavie

Mental Health Counselor, MA, MHC-LP

I love working with Lindsay! They are a pleasure to work with professionally, and it's clear that they truly care about their clients.

Alexa Ferst

MA, MHC-LP

Lindsay is an experienced clinician who devotes her time and energy to facilitating a wonderful environment for her clients!

Jaylen Herchenroder

Pre-Licensed Professional, MHC-LP

Lindsay has been an incredible supervisor and I am learning so much from her! She is a passionate, skilled and dedicated professional.

Valeriya Shipulya

Pre-Licensed Professional, MA, MHC-LP

Lindsay is incredibly knowledgeable, driven, and passionate about her work. She is wonderful to work with and an amazing therapist who truly cares about the people she works with!

May Steinberg

Pre-Licensed Professional, MHC-LP

Lindsay is an incredible supervisor. She challenges me in a way that feels attainable, and I am a better clinician for it.

Rachel Molly Moses

Counselor, MA, LMHC, NCC

Lindsay's genuine care for her clients comes through in everything she does and she brings that same thoughtfulness and kindness to her work with colleagues and supervisees. It is an honor to work with her! She excels in many areas, particularly in EMDR.

Part of McGarril Mental Health Counseling

View Practice

Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR

Pre-Licensed Professional, MHC-LP

Valeriya Shipulya

Pre-Licensed Professional, MA, MHC-LP

Rebecca W Heller

Mental Health Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, PMH-C

Nuna Eboe

Pre-Licensed Professional, MHC-LP

Client Focus

Age

Teen ,

Adults ,

Elders (65+)

Participants

Individuals ,

Couples ,

Family

Communities

Bisexual Allied ,

Gay Allied ,

Queer Allied

Religion

Other Spiritual or Religious Affiliations

Age

Teen ,

Adults ,

Elders (65+)

Participants

Individuals ,

Couples ,

Family

Communities

Bisexual Allied ,

Gay Allied ,

Queer Allied

Religion

Other Spiritual or Religious Affiliations

Treatment Approach

Types of Therapy

Acceptance and Commitment (ACT)
Cognitive Behavioral (CBT)
Dialectical Behavior (DBT)
EMDR
Emotionally Focused
Family / Marital
Integrative
Internal Family Systems (IFS)
Interpersonal
Mindfulness-Based (MBCT)
Motivational Interviewing
Psychodynamic
Somatic
Strength-Based
Trauma Focused

I often like to use a combination of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) with more trauma-informed approaches like Internal Family Systems (IFS) and Eye Movement Desensitization Reprocessing (EMDR) as I feel these techniques are able to go deeper with clients' experiences and therefore be more effective with treatment outcomes. I am an EMDRIA certified therapist.

Lindsay McGarril

Counselor, LMHC-D, LPC, EMDR