Therapists in Shelbyville, IN
Melissa Russell-Plunkett
Counselor, MS, NCC, LMHC
Verified Verified
3 Endorsed
Shelbyville, IN 46176
Sometimes life gets crazy--but that doesn't mean you are! You feel different, defeated, and depressed. No one understands you. You're overwhelmed and can't imagine how life will ever get any better, so why try? Yet here you are searching for an escape from the numbness creeping up on you. Maybe you are tired of faking your way through each day and want to experience authentic happiness. Let's embark on a journey to help you become who you want to be instead of merely enduring who you are. You can be confident, courageous, and content in life.
Sometimes life gets crazy--but that doesn't mean you are! You feel different, defeated, and depressed. No one understands you. You're overwhelmed and can't imagine how life will ever get any better, so why try? Yet here you are searching for an escape from the numbness creeping up on you. Maybe you are tired of faking your way through each day and want to experience authentic happiness. Let's embark on a journey to help you become who you want to be instead of merely enduring who you are. You can be confident, courageous, and content in life.
Positive Focus Mental Health Services
Psychologist, LMFT, PsyD, HSPP
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
Shelbyville, IN 46176
When most people are seeking a therapist, they are looking for someone they “click” with. I get it. Reaching out for help, whether it's walking in to a therapists office, over the phone or online is a big step and takes courage. Everyone needs to feel when they do so that the person they have chosen to help them fits with them and their needs well. I couldn’t agree more. Therapy is a relationship. When life is hard, you want someone you're comfortable with to help address the struggles and challenges you face everyday. You want someone who gets you, that is relateable and you feel is qualified to help get you there!
When most people are seeking a therapist, they are looking for someone they “click” with. I get it. Reaching out for help, whether it's walking in to a therapists office, over the phone or online is a big step and takes courage. Everyone needs to feel when they do so that the person they have chosen to help them fits with them and their needs well. I couldn’t agree more. Therapy is a relationship. When life is hard, you want someone you're comfortable with to help address the struggles and challenges you face everyday. You want someone who gets you, that is relateable and you feel is qualified to help get you there!
Do you feel constantly overwhelmed by the stress of everyday life? Does the pain you see at work, at school, or in your personal relationships threaten to steal your capacity for joy and peace? Have you experienced profound loss or trauma that makes it difficult to believe in any good in the world? Amanda Gorman wrote, "When day comes we step out of the shade, aflame and unafraid, the new dawn blooms as we free it. For there is always light, if only we're brave enough to see it. If only we're brave enough to be it." Can I help you in finding this light within yourself?
Do you feel constantly overwhelmed by the stress of everyday life? Does the pain you see at work, at school, or in your personal relationships threaten to steal your capacity for joy and peace? Have you experienced profound loss or trauma that makes it difficult to believe in any good in the world? Amanda Gorman wrote, "When day comes we step out of the shade, aflame and unafraid, the new dawn blooms as we free it. For there is always light, if only we're brave enough to see it. If only we're brave enough to be it." Can I help you in finding this light within yourself?
Tracy resonates and empathizes with imperfection, uncertainties, and the unfixed. Hope from personal healing led her to walk alongside others through life's struggles. She transitioned from nursing to counseling at Concordia University Irvine with the Townsend Institute and holds a Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate in Indiana. Her nursing experience adds physical and neurological perspectives to support growth and wellbeing. She has served in community mental health, the Boys and Girls Club, daycares, hospitals, and church settings.
Tracy resonates and empathizes with imperfection, uncertainties, and the unfixed. Hope from personal healing led her to walk alongside others through life's struggles. She transitioned from nursing to counseling at Concordia University Irvine with the Townsend Institute and holds a Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate in Indiana. Her nursing experience adds physical and neurological perspectives to support growth and wellbeing. She has served in community mental health, the Boys and Girls Club, daycares, hospitals, and church settings.
Victoria A Harris
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW, LCAC, CTRTC, NCGC-
Verified Verified
Shelbyville, IN 46176
The mission at ER Counseling LLC is dedicated to providing counseling services to empower individuals, couples, and families to improve their overall quality of life. Counseling is available for individuals, couples and families in a comfortable setting. Therapy focuses on the present not the past, on solutions not the problem utilizing a Client Centered and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy approach. Certified as a Reality Therapy and Choice Theory therapist practical and effective approaches in helping people change are used. Clients learn skills and gain information they can use immediately.
The mission at ER Counseling LLC is dedicated to providing counseling services to empower individuals, couples, and families to improve their overall quality of life. Counseling is available for individuals, couples and families in a comfortable setting. Therapy focuses on the present not the past, on solutions not the problem utilizing a Client Centered and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy approach. Certified as a Reality Therapy and Choice Theory therapist practical and effective approaches in helping people change are used. Clients learn skills and gain information they can use immediately.
Bonnie Spallinger is a Licensed Mental Health Counselor in the state of Indiana. She completed her graduate program from Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia in 2015. Bonnie has served in community health for 4.5 years and has experience working with families, women, men, adolescents, and children. Her expertise is working with adolescents and emerging adults struggling with trauma, decision making, life issues, and behavioral issues. She enjoys assisting parents in finding helpful methods to parent their children.
Bonnie Spallinger is a Licensed Mental Health Counselor in the state of Indiana. She completed her graduate program from Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia in 2015. Bonnie has served in community health for 4.5 years and has experience working with families, women, men, adolescents, and children. Her expertise is working with adolescents and emerging adults struggling with trauma, decision making, life issues, and behavioral issues. She enjoys assisting parents in finding helpful methods to parent their children.
I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker in the state of Indiana. I earned my Bachelor’s of Social Work from Anderson University in 2019, and earned my Master’s of Social Work from Indiana University in 2020. I have multiple years of experience working in both hospital and school settings.
I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker in the state of Indiana. I earned my Bachelor’s of Social Work from Anderson University in 2019, and earned my Master’s of Social Work from Indiana University in 2020. I have multiple years of experience working in both hospital and school settings.
Making the decision to begin therapy is a healthy and courageous act that brings with it the potential for growth and healing. As a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist I will work with you to provide confidential and caring services. I have a passion to help individuals, couples and families overcome challenges, grow in their relationships and find meaning and purpose in life. I feel it is important to "meet each client where they are" in their journey.
Making the decision to begin therapy is a healthy and courageous act that brings with it the potential for growth and healing. As a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist I will work with you to provide confidential and caring services. I have a passion to help individuals, couples and families overcome challenges, grow in their relationships and find meaning and purpose in life. I feel it is important to "meet each client where they are" in their journey.
Therapy's Peace Within Recovery Counseling
Drug & Alcohol Counselor, MPsych, LAC, CADACII, MS
Verified Verified
Shelbyville, IN 46176
You Can Change Your Life and I can help! If you are looking for counseling to meet you where you are, a person who will listen without judgment in a confidential environment, I am your person. I can help you gain knowledge, understanding, and recovery abilities to build a sober life, achieve inner peace, and grow.
You Can Change Your Life and I can help! If you are looking for counseling to meet you where you are, a person who will listen without judgment in a confidential environment, I am your person. I can help you gain knowledge, understanding, and recovery abilities to build a sober life, achieve inner peace, and grow.
Kimberly Hage
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
Verified Verified
5 Endorsed
Shelbyville, IN 46176
Not accepting new clients
Not Taking New Clients. One of my first goals in therapy is to provide an atmosphere of privacy, safety and confidentiality. Have you ever felt overwhelmed, struggling with images of a traumatic event, never told someone about sexual abuse that still haunts you? Are you trying to get clean from alcohol and or drugs? Plagued by panic attacks or hopelessness? I would love to work with you so you can achieve your goals. I have a blended family of 7 children am a grandmother of 8 beautiful grandchildren. I love camping, hiking, fishing, gardening, puzzles and spending time with my cats.
Not Taking New Clients. One of my first goals in therapy is to provide an atmosphere of privacy, safety and confidentiality. Have you ever felt overwhelmed, struggling with images of a traumatic event, never told someone about sexual abuse that still haunts you? Are you trying to get clean from alcohol and or drugs? Plagued by panic attacks or hopelessness? I would love to work with you so you can achieve your goals. I have a blended family of 7 children am a grandmother of 8 beautiful grandchildren. I love camping, hiking, fishing, gardening, puzzles and spending time with my cats.
Overwhelmed? Stretched thin? You’re not alone, even if it feels that way. Many moms juggle self-doubt, feeling overstimulated, or battling mom rage (yes, it’s real, and we’re breaking the stigma!). From constantly re-evaluating choices to feeling crushed under society’s endless demands, you may find yourself longing for relief, validation, and a chance to simply breathe. Moms like you want clarity, calm, and a real sense of connection with themselves and their families. And you deserve that. It’s okay to admit the struggle—because it’s very real, and you don’t have to go through it alone.
Overwhelmed? Stretched thin? You’re not alone, even if it feels that way. Many moms juggle self-doubt, feeling overstimulated, or battling mom rage (yes, it’s real, and we’re breaking the stigma!). From constantly re-evaluating choices to feeling crushed under society’s endless demands, you may find yourself longing for relief, validation, and a chance to simply breathe. Moms like you want clarity, calm, and a real sense of connection with themselves and their families. And you deserve that. It’s okay to admit the struggle—because it’s very real, and you don’t have to go through it alone.
15 Second Videos
Melissa Russell-Plunkett
Therapy's Peace Within Recovery Counseling
Katie Stafford
Elizabeth Duffy
Mental Health Counselor, LMHC, MDiv
Verified Verified
3 Endorsed
Shelbyville, IN 46176
Anxiety? Depression? Trauma? Attempts to cope that are spinning out of control? I can help! I work with women and men across the lifespan, pastors, therapists, artists and professionals. Specialties include: coercive control and abuse, divorce discernment/recovery, mid-life concerns, parenting, and developing space for creativity. I provide a confidential, non-judgmental space to explore anything on your mind, ask hard questions, and say the quiet part loud.
Anxiety? Depression? Trauma? Attempts to cope that are spinning out of control? I can help! I work with women and men across the lifespan, pastors, therapists, artists and professionals. Specialties include: coercive control and abuse, divorce discernment/recovery, mid-life concerns, parenting, and developing space for creativity. I provide a confidential, non-judgmental space to explore anything on your mind, ask hard questions, and say the quiet part loud.
Danelle King, LCSW
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
Online Only
My ideal client would be someone who would benefit from my inner gifts of nurturing and supportive sensitivity. My most successful clients are those who are open to exploring a variety of treatment models until we find the one that works best. I also offer professional supervision to emerging social workers who are seeking oversight toward clinical hours for their LCSW candidacy!
My ideal client would be someone who would benefit from my inner gifts of nurturing and supportive sensitivity. My most successful clients are those who are open to exploring a variety of treatment models until we find the one that works best. I also offer professional supervision to emerging social workers who are seeking oversight toward clinical hours for their LCSW candidacy!
Do you struggle with using substances as a way to cope, and it is impacting your life in a negative way? Or is your teenager having trouble managing the anxiety and pressure of school and life? Are their grades lacking due to difficulty focusing, staying organized and on task? I often see adults and teens struggling with regulating emotions, navigating relationships, and managing the stressors of daily life? These struggles can wreck self-esteem, leave you feeling stuck, and feel so overwhelming to face alone. If this sounds like you or your teen, I am here to help you in finding balance, motivation, and change in your life.
Do you struggle with using substances as a way to cope, and it is impacting your life in a negative way? Or is your teenager having trouble managing the anxiety and pressure of school and life? Are their grades lacking due to difficulty focusing, staying organized and on task? I often see adults and teens struggling with regulating emotions, navigating relationships, and managing the stressors of daily life? These struggles can wreck self-esteem, leave you feeling stuck, and feel so overwhelming to face alone. If this sounds like you or your teen, I am here to help you in finding balance, motivation, and change in your life.
I am a 2nd year Master’s-level Art Therapy Intern from IU-Indianapolis under the supervision of Melissa McFall, LMHC, ATR-BC. I offer a unique therapeutic experience by combining art and psychotherapy in sessions. Art Therapy is an alternative ways of communication and processing internal and external experiences through a hands on creative approach. The approach utilizing a combination of verbal processing and nonverbal communication styles to enhance emotional well-being, social and coping skills, trauma, and self-awareness.
I am a 2nd year Master’s-level Art Therapy Intern from IU-Indianapolis under the supervision of Melissa McFall, LMHC, ATR-BC. I offer a unique therapeutic experience by combining art and psychotherapy in sessions. Art Therapy is an alternative ways of communication and processing internal and external experiences through a hands on creative approach. The approach utilizing a combination of verbal processing and nonverbal communication styles to enhance emotional well-being, social and coping skills, trauma, and self-awareness.
Like a treasured friend, I'll be your trusted source of support and a treasured confidant. As your therapist, I'll sift through the "tea" to find the barriers that are keeping you and peace at odds with one another! Together we will work through personal dilemmas, past traumas, and flawed thinking patterns. Challenges can feel like mountains, but you and I (with the help of evidenced based practice methods that are proven),will scale them all!
Like a treasured friend, I'll be your trusted source of support and a treasured confidant. As your therapist, I'll sift through the "tea" to find the barriers that are keeping you and peace at odds with one another! Together we will work through personal dilemmas, past traumas, and flawed thinking patterns. Challenges can feel like mountains, but you and I (with the help of evidenced based practice methods that are proven),will scale them all!
Katie Stafford
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, LISW, QS
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
Online Only
If you "don't know where to start", feel stuck in life or overwhelmed by anxiety and depression you've come to the right place. As a compassionate and experienced therapist, I am here to help you find your way forward and create a life filled with purpose and joy. I believe that everyone has the power to create positive change in their lives, and I'm committed to helping you tap into your own inner strength and resilience. Whether you're dealing with past traumas or current challenges, I am here to support you every step of the way.
If you "don't know where to start", feel stuck in life or overwhelmed by anxiety and depression you've come to the right place. As a compassionate and experienced therapist, I am here to help you find your way forward and create a life filled with purpose and joy. I believe that everyone has the power to create positive change in their lives, and I'm committed to helping you tap into your own inner strength and resilience. Whether you're dealing with past traumas or current challenges, I am here to support you every step of the way.
My name is Chloe Shaffer, and I am an (LPC) in Illinois and (LMHCA) in Indiana. I provide virtual counseling to adults residing only in Indiana at this time. I do accept Medicaid insurance, contact me to check eligibility.
My name is Chloe Shaffer, and I am an (LPC) in Illinois and (LMHCA) in Indiana. I provide virtual counseling to adults residing only in Indiana at this time. I do accept Medicaid insurance, contact me to check eligibility.
More Therapists Nearby
Liz is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker with a passion for helping others at work, in their personal lives, and fresh out of graduate school. Liz is dedicated to mentoring and coaching others, and focuses on personal and professional strengths. Liz graduated from IU Bloomington and completed her MSW from the School of Social Work in 2009. An exciting accomplishment was receiving the award for Social Worker of the Year in 2020. In 2024, Liz created her consulting company, Guided Vision Consulting, LLC. Guided Vision Consulting is your destination where we offer personalized 1:1 consultation and mentorship to unlock your potential.
Liz is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker with a passion for helping others at work, in their personal lives, and fresh out of graduate school. Liz is dedicated to mentoring and coaching others, and focuses on personal and professional strengths. Liz graduated from IU Bloomington and completed her MSW from the School of Social Work in 2009. An exciting accomplishment was receiving the award for Social Worker of the Year in 2020. In 2024, Liz created her consulting company, Guided Vision Consulting, LLC. Guided Vision Consulting is your destination where we offer personalized 1:1 consultation and mentorship to unlock your potential.
The ideal client is anyone brave enough to put themselves first and ask for help. The ideal client is receptive to the therapeutic process and is direct, open, and vulnerable. They also understand that the therapeutic process takes time, and one does not get there overnight. The ideal client is patient with themselves and can give themselves grace and permission to grow. The client will have the goal of personal self-development and is ready to do the work. The ideal client does not expect me to "fix" them but understands that a clinician is a form of support on their journey and that we will accomplish any goals together.
The ideal client is anyone brave enough to put themselves first and ask for help. The ideal client is receptive to the therapeutic process and is direct, open, and vulnerable. They also understand that the therapeutic process takes time, and one does not get there overnight. The ideal client is patient with themselves and can give themselves grace and permission to grow. The client will have the goal of personal self-development and is ready to do the work. The ideal client does not expect me to "fix" them but understands that a clinician is a form of support on their journey and that we will accomplish any goals together.
See more therapy options for Shelbyville
How does your Therapist compare?
Number of Therapists in Shelbyville, IN
10+
Average cost per session
$130
Therapists in Shelbyville, IN who prioritize treating:
94% | Anxiety |
83% | Coping Skills |
83% | Self Esteem |
72% | Depression |
72% | Family Conflict |
67% | Trauma and PTSD |
67% | Stress |
Average years in practice
10 Years
Top 3 insurances accepted
64% | BlueCross and BlueShield |
64% | Cigna and Evernorth |
64% | UnitedHealthcare UHC | UBH |
How Therapists in Shelbyville, IN see their clients
73% | In Person and Online | |
27% | Online Only |
Gender breakdown
94% | Female | |
6% | Male |
FAQs - About Therapy and Counseling
How can I find a therapist in Shelbyville?
Search for nearby therapists or counselors by inputting your city, town, or suburb; or zip code; or a provider’s name into the search bar. From there, you can filter providers by the issues they treat, cost, insurance, gender, and other factors to find providers who are well-suited to your needs. To navigate between locations within the same country, enter a new city or zip code into the search bar.
Learn more about how to find a therapist
Learn more about how to find a therapist
Is everyone in the Psychology Today Therapy Directory a licensed therapist?
The Psychology Today directory lists providers who offer legitimate mental health services to the public, including psychologists, psychiatrists, social workers, and counselors.
Many have been licensed by the country or state where they practice; providers whose license or primary credential has been verified by Psychology Today are signified by a “Verified” symbol. Some clinicians or organizations provide services for which their state or country does not offer licenses, such as pastoral counseling. They may be selectively included without the “Verified” seal.
Many have been licensed by the country or state where they practice; providers whose license or primary credential has been verified by Psychology Today are signified by a “Verified” symbol. Some clinicians or organizations provide services for which their state or country does not offer licenses, such as pastoral counseling. They may be selectively included without the “Verified” seal.
What’s the difference between a psychologist, a therapist, and a counselor?
Therapists, psychologists, and counselors are all licensed mental health professionals. In the US, psychologists have earned a doctoral degree. The terms “therapist” and “counselor” are used somewhat interchangeably, but generally therapists offer longer-term, mental health care, while counselors offer shorter-term care that may focus on one domain, such as marriage, career, or academic challenges.
Clients should consider factors such as insurance coverage and their primary reason(s) for seeking therapy to determine the type of professional best suited to their needs. Someone struggling with mental health challenges such as depression or anxiety, for example, may wish to seek out a clinical psychologist or therapist, while someone navigating career obstacles or marital upheaval may benefit from seeing a counselor who can offer short-term, targeted support.
Clients should consider factors such as insurance coverage and their primary reason(s) for seeking therapy to determine the type of professional best suited to their needs. Someone struggling with mental health challenges such as depression or anxiety, for example, may wish to seek out a clinical psychologist or therapist, while someone navigating career obstacles or marital upheaval may benefit from seeing a counselor who can offer short-term, targeted support.
What type of therapy is right for me?
The type of therapy best suited to a particular individual depends on several factors, including their primary reason for seeking therapy, their preferred timeline (some therapy types last for a set number of sessions, while others are open-ended), and their personality and preferences—some may prefer a more structured approach. For many individuals, multiple types of therapy could provide a good fit.
How much does therapy cost?
The cost of therapy depends on a number of variables, including location and the therapist’s experience and training. On average, a therapy session in the United States could cost between $100 and $200 or more. If you have insurance, the expense of mental health care is typically lower, but it varies based on your insurance plan details and whether you choose an in-network or out-of-network mental healthcare provider.
What are more affordable or low cost therapy solutions?
Many therapists offer sliding scale payments, usually on a limited number of slots, which consists in an agreement between the therapist and a client to pay a reduced rate. Therapists who provide such arrangements often consider the client's income or ability to pay, but the extent of the discount is ultimately at the therapist's discretion. Furthermore, while group therapy may have different goals and benefits compared to individual therapy, it can be a more affordable solution to address certain types of issues.
Is online therapy cheaper than in-person therapy?
Many therapists charge the same amount for online therapy as they do for in-person therapy—though clients may still find this cost-effective if it cuts down on their transportation costs. Health insurance plans often offer equivalent coverage for online and in-person therapy; indeed, in many places, they are legally required to do so. Text-based or on-demand therapy apps may be cheaper than traditional one-on-one psychotherapy; however, the practice may be less effective and is not likely to be covered by insurance.
Is online therapy a good option?
Therapy conducted online can be just as effective as in-person therapy, as long as there is a strong alliance between the client and the therapist. To find a therapist who provides telehealth services to clients in your area, click “Online Therapy” on the directory homepage and search by your city or town or your zip code.
Are therapy sessions confidential?
Confidentiality is a crucial part of the therapeutic relationship. Therapists in the United States are bound by the regulations set out by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA), which aims to protect sensitive health information. With very few exceptions, a therapist will only discuss their client with others when the client has given their written permission. The instances in which a therapist would be required to disclose personal information are: if a client poses a danger to themselves or others, if the therapist suspects the abuse of a child or an elderly or otherwise dependent adult, or if they are legally forced to by court order. These exceptions to the confidentiality agreement are usually discussed with a client before their first session.