BlueCross BlueShield Therapists in Indianapolis, IN

Photo of Carmen Johnson, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Carmen Johnson
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Online Only
Welcome! My name is Carmen, and I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW). Prior to opening my private practice, Abiding Connections LLC, I spent much of my career specializing in hospice and palliative care as a medical social worker. This work has deeply shaped both my professional path and my personal understanding of life, connection, and meaning. Through these experiences, I have been honored to walk alongside individuals and families during some of life’s most tender moments—learning invaluable lessons about resilience, community, and the importance of compassionate presence.
Welcome! My name is Carmen, and I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW). Prior to opening my private practice, Abiding Connections LLC, I spent much of my career specializing in hospice and palliative care as a medical social worker. This work has deeply shaped both my professional path and my personal understanding of life, connection, and meaning. Through these experiences, I have been honored to walk alongside individuals and families during some of life’s most tender moments—learning invaluable lessons about resilience, community, and the importance of compassionate presence.
(463) 282-3582 View (463) 282-3582
Photo of Sarah Wagner, Marriage & Family Therapist, LMFT
Sarah Wagner
Marriage & Family Therapist, LMFT
Online Only
Parenting a neurodivergent child can feel overwhelming, isolating, and confusing — especially when you’re trying to break patterns from your own childhood at the same time. You don’t have to navigate that alone. My approach blends attachment, trauma-informed care, and practical tools so change feels doable and not just talked about. Therapy with me is collaborative, honest, and focused on helping your family function with more clarity and compassion.
Parenting a neurodivergent child can feel overwhelming, isolating, and confusing — especially when you’re trying to break patterns from your own childhood at the same time. You don’t have to navigate that alone. My approach blends attachment, trauma-informed care, and practical tools so change feels doable and not just talked about. Therapy with me is collaborative, honest, and focused on helping your family function with more clarity and compassion.
(463) 583-3048 View (463) 583-3048
Photo of Jennifer Singer, Marriage & Family Therapist, MA, LMFT
Jennifer Singer
Marriage & Family Therapist, MA, LMFT
Indianapolis, IN 46227
Jennifer brings a thoughtful and relational approach to therapy, with a focus on anxiety, depression, and trauma-related concerns. She also has extensive experience supporting couples who are working through communication challenges, life transitions, and relationship stressors. Her work is grounded in understanding each person’s unique experiences while helping clients develop coping strategies that support long-term emotional well-being. In addition to these primary areas, Jennifer offers support for a wide range of additional mental health concerns.Jennifer brings a thoughtful and relational approach to therapy, with a focus on a
Jennifer brings a thoughtful and relational approach to therapy, with a focus on anxiety, depression, and trauma-related concerns. She also has extensive experience supporting couples who are working through communication challenges, life transitions, and relationship stressors. Her work is grounded in understanding each person’s unique experiences while helping clients develop coping strategies that support long-term emotional well-being. In addition to these primary areas, Jennifer offers support for a wide range of additional mental health concerns.Jennifer brings a thoughtful and relational approach to therapy, with a focus on a
(317) 834-7766 View (317) 834-7766
Photo of Lamar Sykes, Marriage & Family Therapist, LMFT
Lamar Sykes
Marriage & Family Therapist, LMFT
Indianapolis, IN 46260
Welcome—I'm so glad you're here. Seeking support is a courageous first step, and I’m honored to walk alongside you in that journey. Whether you're navigating anxiety, life transitions, relationship challenges, or just feeling a bit stuck, you're not alone. I offer a safe, compassionate, and judgment-free space where we can work together to understand your story and help you move toward healing and growth. My approach is rooted in empathy, respect, and collaboration. We'll explore the patterns that shape your experiences and gently uncover the strengths that can guide you forward. This is your space to be heard, to feel understood.
Welcome—I'm so glad you're here. Seeking support is a courageous first step, and I’m honored to walk alongside you in that journey. Whether you're navigating anxiety, life transitions, relationship challenges, or just feeling a bit stuck, you're not alone. I offer a safe, compassionate, and judgment-free space where we can work together to understand your story and help you move toward healing and growth. My approach is rooted in empathy, respect, and collaboration. We'll explore the patterns that shape your experiences and gently uncover the strengths that can guide you forward. This is your space to be heard, to feel understood.
(317) 516-0102 View (317) 516-0102
Photo of Amy Amico, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, CAGCS
Amy Amico
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, CAGCS
2 Endorsed
Indianapolis, IN 46227
I am in-network with Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield and Medicare Part B.
Have negative self-talk, grief, anxiety, and depression become a struggle? Are personal and social factors affecting health and wellness? Whether it is caring for a loved one, a life change, grief or loss, mental health symptoms, trauma or an unexpected circumstance you would never choose, you are not alone. I am here to support and promote resilience, growth, and an improved sense of self. Entering the office, you will find a safe space to courageously unpack your story, and freely explore thoughts, emotions, and challenges to gain clarity and reach goals. I approach each client with empathy, respect, and genuine commitment.
I am in-network with Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield and Medicare Part B.
Have negative self-talk, grief, anxiety, and depression become a struggle? Are personal and social factors affecting health and wellness? Whether it is caring for a loved one, a life change, grief or loss, mental health symptoms, trauma or an unexpected circumstance you would never choose, you are not alone. I am here to support and promote resilience, growth, and an improved sense of self. Entering the office, you will find a safe space to courageously unpack your story, and freely explore thoughts, emotions, and challenges to gain clarity and reach goals. I approach each client with empathy, respect, and genuine commitment.
(463) 222-0858 View (463) 222-0858
Photo of Hayley Spangler, Counselor, LMHC, NCC, MA
Hayley Spangler
Counselor, LMHC, NCC, MA
Online Only
Do you struggle to say "no?" Do find yourself feeling guilty when choosing your own wants and needs over someone else's? Does it feel like everyone comes to you for support but aren't there for you in return? Is it hard to feel emotions such as sadness, anger, and disappointment? Have you found success in your career and hobbies but struggle in relationships? If any of these statements ring true for you then we may be a good fit! Click the link to my website and schedule an appointment with me.
Do you struggle to say "no?" Do find yourself feeling guilty when choosing your own wants and needs over someone else's? Does it feel like everyone comes to you for support but aren't there for you in return? Is it hard to feel emotions such as sadness, anger, and disappointment? Have you found success in your career and hobbies but struggle in relationships? If any of these statements ring true for you then we may be a good fit! Click the link to my website and schedule an appointment with me.
(765) 302-4861 View (765) 302-4861
Photo of Jasmine Litton, Pre-Licensed Professional, LMHCA, Intern
Jasmine Litton
Pre-Licensed Professional, LMHCA, Intern
Indianapolis, IN 46202
Jasmine is dedicated to creating a safe, present-focused space where clients can explore their strengths and navigate personal and interpersonal challenges. She specializes in neuroaffirming, culturally sensitive care, with a commitment to supporting marginalized communities (e.g. LGBTQIA+, POC, etc).
Jasmine is dedicated to creating a safe, present-focused space where clients can explore their strengths and navigate personal and interpersonal challenges. She specializes in neuroaffirming, culturally sensitive care, with a commitment to supporting marginalized communities (e.g. LGBTQIA+, POC, etc).
(317) 597-1663 View (317) 597-1663
Photo of Deandra Finnell, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
Deandra Finnell
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
Indianapolis, IN 46260
Waitlist for new clients
Take a deep breath in. Now exhale. You’ve taken the first step in addressing the issues you’ve been struggling with. Are you so flooded with anxiety that you can’t sleep at night? Is depression robbing you of the motivation to manage the smallest of tasks? Do you feel overwhelmed due to a major life transition, parenting issues, work-related concerns, or relationship difficulties? Or might you be suffering because of distressing and painful experiences you have had throughout your life? No matter the concerns, I’ll work in partnership with you to help you navigate your next steps toward achieving your goals.
Take a deep breath in. Now exhale. You’ve taken the first step in addressing the issues you’ve been struggling with. Are you so flooded with anxiety that you can’t sleep at night? Is depression robbing you of the motivation to manage the smallest of tasks? Do you feel overwhelmed due to a major life transition, parenting issues, work-related concerns, or relationship difficulties? Or might you be suffering because of distressing and painful experiences you have had throughout your life? No matter the concerns, I’ll work in partnership with you to help you navigate your next steps toward achieving your goals.
(463) 259-7898 View (463) 259-7898
Photo of Tiari Contreras, Marriage & Family Therapist, LMFT
Tiari Contreras
Marriage & Family Therapist, LMFT
Online Only
If you come from a family that can't give you the emotional support you need; are in your relationship questioning whether to leave or stay, or just need someone who will listen without judging you, I am here for you.
If you come from a family that can't give you the emotional support you need; are in your relationship questioning whether to leave or stay, or just need someone who will listen without judging you, I am here for you.
(463) 298-9941 View (463) 298-9941
Photo of Matthew Hawker, Licensed Mental Health Counselor, LMHC
Matthew Hawker
Licensed Mental Health Counselor, LMHC
1 Endorsed
Indianapolis, IN 46227
I am in network for Anthem BCBS, Aetna, United, UMR, SIHO, Sana Benefits, and Lyra.
Life doesn't always work out the way we plan, and sometimes help is needed. It takes a lot of courage to seek out and ask for help, and doing so is the first step on the journey of growth and support. I have personally sought out a variety of therapy approaches to help as many people as possible through a variety of methods. I have worked with a broad range of client issues from depression, anxiety, addiction, trauma, grief, guilt, shame, and many other areas.
I am in network for Anthem BCBS, Aetna, United, UMR, SIHO, Sana Benefits, and Lyra.
Life doesn't always work out the way we plan, and sometimes help is needed. It takes a lot of courage to seek out and ask for help, and doing so is the first step on the journey of growth and support. I have personally sought out a variety of therapy approaches to help as many people as possible through a variety of methods. I have worked with a broad range of client issues from depression, anxiety, addiction, trauma, grief, guilt, shame, and many other areas.
(317) 659-8324 View (317) 659-8324
Photo of Robert Harris, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, MSW
Robert Harris
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, MSW
Online Only
You might be someone who has lived an intense life, shaped by service, responsibility, or long periods of being the one others depended on. On the outside, you function. You show up, you handle things. On the inside, it’s harder to slow down, relax, or feel truly at ease. You may struggle with loneliness or difficulty trusting others. You stay guarded or may question your own judgment. Your goals may include rebuilding trust in yourself, forming deeper, healthier connections, and finding meaning in this stage of life. You may want clarity, steadiness, and a way to move forward that honors everything you’ve been through.
You might be someone who has lived an intense life, shaped by service, responsibility, or long periods of being the one others depended on. On the outside, you function. You show up, you handle things. On the inside, it’s harder to slow down, relax, or feel truly at ease. You may struggle with loneliness or difficulty trusting others. You stay guarded or may question your own judgment. Your goals may include rebuilding trust in yourself, forming deeper, healthier connections, and finding meaning in this stage of life. You may want clarity, steadiness, and a way to move forward that honors everything you’ve been through.
(463) 403-0965 View (463) 403-0965
Photo of Jo Anna Bement, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
Jo Anna Bement
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
Indianapolis, IN 46260
I have been providing counseling for twenty-eight years with a specialty in treating all types of anxiety disorders from chronic worrying and panic attacks to PTSD and OCD. I find that utilizing a combination of cognitive-behavioral and mindfulness strategies has been extremely effective at reducing and resolving most symptoms of anxiety. Although I have specialized in treating anxiety related issues, I also enjoy, and am skilled at treating depression, grief, and transitional life issues. I am dedicated to the well-being of my clients and believe a holistic approach is necessary for complete healing.
I have been providing counseling for twenty-eight years with a specialty in treating all types of anxiety disorders from chronic worrying and panic attacks to PTSD and OCD. I find that utilizing a combination of cognitive-behavioral and mindfulness strategies has been extremely effective at reducing and resolving most symptoms of anxiety. Although I have specialized in treating anxiety related issues, I also enjoy, and am skilled at treating depression, grief, and transitional life issues. I am dedicated to the well-being of my clients and believe a holistic approach is necessary for complete healing.
(850) 801-5101 View (850) 801-5101
Photo of Allison Pater, Counselor, LMHCA
Allison Pater
Counselor, LMHCA
1 Endorsed
Online Only
Your brain doesn't need to be "fixed"-it needs a strategy that actually fits. If you are a parent navigating the complexities of an ADHD diagnosis, a young person feeling misunderstood by traditional systems, or an individual seeking to harness your unique neurodivergent strengths, you deserve a space where your energy is celebrated, not suppressed. Healing happens when we stop trying to force a square peg into a round hole and start designing a life that works for your specific wiring. My approach is grounded in cultural humility and respect for neurodiversity, ensuring your identity and lived experience guide our steps together.
Your brain doesn't need to be "fixed"-it needs a strategy that actually fits. If you are a parent navigating the complexities of an ADHD diagnosis, a young person feeling misunderstood by traditional systems, or an individual seeking to harness your unique neurodivergent strengths, you deserve a space where your energy is celebrated, not suppressed. Healing happens when we stop trying to force a square peg into a round hole and start designing a life that works for your specific wiring. My approach is grounded in cultural humility and respect for neurodiversity, ensuring your identity and lived experience guide our steps together.
(765) 560-7875 View (765) 560-7875
Judy Penick
Counselor
Online Only
As a solution focused therapist, my goal is to help you uncover your true potential and lead a life that is worth celebrating. While we can’t change difficult situations of the past, we can work together to better understand and resolve the challenges in your life. By applying complementary therapy approaches and techniques we will unearth long standing behavior patterns or negative perceptions that may be holding you back from experiencing a more fulfilling and meaningful life.
As a solution focused therapist, my goal is to help you uncover your true potential and lead a life that is worth celebrating. While we can’t change difficult situations of the past, we can work together to better understand and resolve the challenges in your life. By applying complementary therapy approaches and techniques we will unearth long standing behavior patterns or negative perceptions that may be holding you back from experiencing a more fulfilling and meaningful life.
(765) 275-1321 View (765) 275-1321
Photo of Robin J Montgomery, Drug & Alcohol Counselor, PhD, LCAC, LICDC-C
Robin J Montgomery
Drug & Alcohol Counselor, PhD, LCAC, LICDC-C
Indianapolis, IN 46220
Recovery is possible, and you do not have to go through it alone. I specialize in helping individuals struggling with substance use, addiction, and related mental health challenges reclaim stability, purpose, and hope in their lives. My approach to addiction therapy recognizes that recovery is not just about stopping substance use—it is about rebuilding the whole person. Together, we focus on strengthening recovery capital, developing healthy coping skills, restoring relationships, and creating a sustainable lifestyle that supports long-term recovery.
Recovery is possible, and you do not have to go through it alone. I specialize in helping individuals struggling with substance use, addiction, and related mental health challenges reclaim stability, purpose, and hope in their lives. My approach to addiction therapy recognizes that recovery is not just about stopping substance use—it is about rebuilding the whole person. Together, we focus on strengthening recovery capital, developing healthy coping skills, restoring relationships, and creating a sustainable lifestyle that supports long-term recovery.
(317) 983-5918 View (317) 983-5918
Photo of Jessica Hibbitt, Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, MA, LMHCA
Jessica Hibbitt
Licensed Mental Health Counselor Associate, MA, LMHCA
2 Endorsed
Online Only
Waitlist for new clients
Whether you are facing challenges in your personal life, seeking to improve your mental well-being, or navigating complexities, I am here to empower you on your journey toward growth and healing.
Whether you are facing challenges in your personal life, seeking to improve your mental well-being, or navigating complexities, I am here to empower you on your journey toward growth and healing.
(765) 548-3372 View (765) 548-3372
Photo of Carl Quedenfeld, Counselor, MA LMHC, LCSW, LCSAC
Carl Quedenfeld
Counselor, MA LMHC, LCSW, LCSAC
Indianapolis, IN 46237
I provide counseling to teens (age 15 on up) ,adults and couples for a variety of issues regarding both mental health and addiction concerns. With over 46 years of experience I have a wide array of training and certifications to meet needs you may have. I practice in Indiana, Wisconsin (virtually), Arizona (virtually) and California ( virtually). I work with both mental health and substance abuse patients/ My focus is on practical, usable skills to help you get results as soon as possible.
I provide counseling to teens (age 15 on up) ,adults and couples for a variety of issues regarding both mental health and addiction concerns. With over 46 years of experience I have a wide array of training and certifications to meet needs you may have. I practice in Indiana, Wisconsin (virtually), Arizona (virtually) and California ( virtually). I work with both mental health and substance abuse patients/ My focus is on practical, usable skills to help you get results as soon as possible.
(317) 830-3071 View (317) 830-3071
Photo of David Chaddock, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, DMin, LCSW, LMFT
David Chaddock
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, DMin, LCSW, LMFT
1 Endorsed
Indianapolis, IN 46240
I am in-network with Blue Cross/ Blue Shield.
I am a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist and Clinical Social Worker with a Doctorate in Pastoral Care and Counseling. I am ordained as a Presbyterian Minister (P.C.U.S.A.), listed on the National Registry of Marriage Friendly Therapists, and certified as an Imago Relationship Therapist. I work with individuals and couples on mood-related, spiritual, and relational concerns.
I am in-network with Blue Cross/ Blue Shield.
I am a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist and Clinical Social Worker with a Doctorate in Pastoral Care and Counseling. I am ordained as a Presbyterian Minister (P.C.U.S.A.), listed on the National Registry of Marriage Friendly Therapists, and certified as an Imago Relationship Therapist. I work with individuals and couples on mood-related, spiritual, and relational concerns.
(317) 662-2195 View (317) 662-2195
Photo of Bailey Trotter, Licensed Mental Health Counselor, MA, LMHC
Bailey Trotter
Licensed Mental Health Counselor, MA, LMHC
Indianapolis, IN 46250
Bailey Trotter is a Licensed Mental Health Counselor with a focus in trauma and substance abuse in Indiana who has been practicing since 2015. She has been trained in EMDR. Bailey’s experience is widespread, but the core is often in substance use and exploring how a use disorder ripples out to affect other areas of our life and relationships. She works with individuals from adolescence into late adulthood and have training to assess and address trauma- acute and sustained.
Bailey Trotter is a Licensed Mental Health Counselor with a focus in trauma and substance abuse in Indiana who has been practicing since 2015. She has been trained in EMDR. Bailey’s experience is widespread, but the core is often in substance use and exploring how a use disorder ripples out to affect other areas of our life and relationships. She works with individuals from adolescence into late adulthood and have training to assess and address trauma- acute and sustained.
(317) 900-4457 View (317) 900-4457
Photo of Dr. Destini Ketchens, Clinical Social Work/Therapist, DSW, LCSW
Dr. Destini Ketchens
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, DSW, LCSW
Indianapolis, IN 46216
Dr. Destini Ketchens, a licensed clinical social worker, is committed to helping individuals in Indiana navigate lifes challenges and discover paths to resilience and empowerment. With a clientcentered approach, Dr. Ketchens provides a safe and supportive space for clients to process their emotions, develop effective strategies, and achieve their goals. She specializes in working with diverse populations, addressing concerns such as trauma, anxiety, depression, and severe mental illness, using evidencebased practices tailored to each individuals unique needs.Dr. Ketchens is dedicated to helping clients rebuild stability, regain thei
Dr. Destini Ketchens, a licensed clinical social worker, is committed to helping individuals in Indiana navigate lifes challenges and discover paths to resilience and empowerment. With a clientcentered approach, Dr. Ketchens provides a safe and supportive space for clients to process their emotions, develop effective strategies, and achieve their goals. She specializes in working with diverse populations, addressing concerns such as trauma, anxiety, depression, and severe mental illness, using evidencebased practices tailored to each individuals unique needs.Dr. Ketchens is dedicated to helping clients rebuild stability, regain thei
(463) 283-6829 View (463) 283-6829

See more therapy options for Indianapolis

BlueCross and BlueShield Therapists
Does insurance cover therapy, prescriptions and other behavioral health services?
In general, yes. Laws in the U.S. require insurers to cover essential behavioral health care at the same level as other health care services. Most health plans require a medical diagnosis and treatments that are evidence based and medically essential. This means that life coaching and alternative therapies are not covered, nor is therapy without a diagnosis. Call the number on the back or your insurance card or visit your insurance company's website to review your Summary of Benefits. If you have insurance through your employer, your Human Resources department may also be able to answer questions.

How much does therapy cost with insurance?
The cost of therapy depends on your region, how much training and experience your therapist has, and the type of treatment. The rate for talk therapy generally falls between $100 and $250. For a client seeing an in-network provider, the cost of therapy is often similar to the cost of other health care services. Clients pay co-pays and may need to satisfy a plan’s deductible before benefits kick in.

What is the difference between In-Network and Out-of-Network insurance coverage?
An in-network provider has contracted with an insurer to get paid directly for services, and to accept the insurer’s rate of compensation. Clients are responsible for deductibles and copays. If a therapist is out of network, that means that the client pays the therapist directly for services at the therapist’s regular fee. Out-of-Network providers often give clients a receipt so that they can file for partial reimbursement with their insurance company.

Is it difficult to find an In-Network therapist?
It is not unusual for therapists to limit the number of insurance patients in their practice, so it’s important to check in-network availability when you schedule your first appointment. In regions and times where therapy is in high demand it may take longer to get scheduled with an in-network therapist.

What is the difference between HMO and PPO insurance plans?
HMO health plans only cover in-network services, there is no reimbursement for out-of-network providers. PPO plans often cover both in- and out-of-network services, though the client may pay more for out-of-network services.

What is a Superbill?
A superbill is a receipt for therapy services. It provides all the information required by insurance companies to reimburse you for out-of-network services, including the diagnostic codes for your care, the amount paid, and the dates and duration of care.

Does insurance cover Online therapy?
Many therapists who shifted their practice to online therapy during the pandemic have kept that arrangement. And most insurers continue to cover telehealth services, with a few exceptions. Preventive care (such as an annual depression screening) is often required to be in-person to be covered, and some states require prescribers of controlled substances to see those patients in person.

Does insurance cover Group therapy?
Many insurance plans provide coverage for group therapy provided there is a medical diagnosis for group members, but there are some noteworthy exceptions. For example, Medicare does not always cover group therapy. Group therapy tends to cost less than individual therapy.

Does insurance cover Couples therapy?
Most insurance companies do not cover the cost of couples therapy because there is no medical diagnosis or medically necessary treatment. However, a few plans will offer a limited benefit, so it is still worth checking with your insurance company. Sometimes therapy is covered for a couple when one person has a diagnosis and another family member joins them for joint therapy, but it is considered therapy for the medical condition that includes a family member as a listener or helper, not couples counseling. Without insurance, most clients pay between $100-300 per 60-90 min session for couples therapy. Often clients can find classes or workshops that make it more affordable to work on their relationship. And some employers offer benefit plans that help defray the cost of couples therapy. Learn more about Insurance Coverage and Finding Affordable Therapy