Aetna Therapists in Shelby County, IN

Photo of Bonnie Spallinger, Counselor in Shelby County, IN
Bonnie Spallinger
Counselor, MA, LMHC
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
Shelbyville, IN 46176
Bonnie Spallinger is a Licensed Mental Health Counselor in the state of Indiana. She completed her graduate program from Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia in 2015. Bonnie has served in community health for 4.5 years and has experience working with families, women, men, adolescents, and children. Her expertise is working with adolescents and emerging adults struggling with trauma, decision making, life issues, and behavioral issues. She enjoys assisting parents in finding helpful methods to parent their children.
Bonnie Spallinger is a Licensed Mental Health Counselor in the state of Indiana. She completed her graduate program from Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia in 2015. Bonnie has served in community health for 4.5 years and has experience working with families, women, men, adolescents, and children. Her expertise is working with adolescents and emerging adults struggling with trauma, decision making, life issues, and behavioral issues. She enjoys assisting parents in finding helpful methods to parent their children.
(260) 296-2060 View (260) 296-2060
Photo of Kimberly Hage, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in Shelby County, IN
Kimberly Hage
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW
Verified Verified
6 Endorsed
Shelbyville, IN 46176
One of my first goals in therapy is to provide an atmosphere of privacy, safety and confidentiality. Have you ever felt overwhelmed, struggling with images of a traumatic event, never told someone about sexual abuse that still haunts you? Are you trying to get clean from alcohol and or drugs? Plagued by panic attacks or hopelessness? I would love to work with you so you can achieve your goals. I have a blended family of 7 children am a grandmother of 8 beautiful grandchildren. I love camping, hiking, fishing, gardening, puzzles and spending time with my cats.
One of my first goals in therapy is to provide an atmosphere of privacy, safety and confidentiality. Have you ever felt overwhelmed, struggling with images of a traumatic event, never told someone about sexual abuse that still haunts you? Are you trying to get clean from alcohol and or drugs? Plagued by panic attacks or hopelessness? I would love to work with you so you can achieve your goals. I have a blended family of 7 children am a grandmother of 8 beautiful grandchildren. I love camping, hiking, fishing, gardening, puzzles and spending time with my cats.
(317) 973-3023 View (317) 973-3023
Photo of Katie Stafford, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in Shelby County, IN
Katie Stafford
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, LISW, QS
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
Shelbyville, IN 46176  (Online Only)
Welcome to a world of self-discovery and healing! If you're feeling stuck in life, overwhelmed by anxiety and depression, or struggling to navigate strained family relationships, you've come to the right place. As a compassionate and experienced therapist, I am here to help you find your way forward and create a life filled with purpose and joy. I believe that everyone has the power to create positive change in their lives, and I'm committed to helping you tap into your own inner strength and resilience. Whether you're dealing with past traumas or current challenges, I am here to support you every step of the way.
Welcome to a world of self-discovery and healing! If you're feeling stuck in life, overwhelmed by anxiety and depression, or struggling to navigate strained family relationships, you've come to the right place. As a compassionate and experienced therapist, I am here to help you find your way forward and create a life filled with purpose and joy. I believe that everyone has the power to create positive change in their lives, and I'm committed to helping you tap into your own inner strength and resilience. Whether you're dealing with past traumas or current challenges, I am here to support you every step of the way.
(561) 468-3507 View (561) 468-3507

Online Therapists

Photo of Anthony Motsinger, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in Shelby County, IN
Anthony Motsinger
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Verified Verified
I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker licensed to practice in Indiana, Ohio, and Connecticut. I provide an eclectic therapeutic approach individualized to a patient's unique situation. I enjoy working with a variety of populations including teenagers and adults. I have specific experience and training in working with the LGBQT+ population, military/veterans, and first responders. I provide a nurturing, optimistic, and energetic therapeutic environment. I want you to look forward to seeing me!
I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker licensed to practice in Indiana, Ohio, and Connecticut. I provide an eclectic therapeutic approach individualized to a patient's unique situation. I enjoy working with a variety of populations including teenagers and adults. I have specific experience and training in working with the LGBQT+ population, military/veterans, and first responders. I provide a nurturing, optimistic, and energetic therapeutic environment. I want you to look forward to seeing me!
(765) 302-2115 View (765) 302-2115
Photo of Paige Bemiller, Counselor in Shelby County, IN
Paige Bemiller
Counselor, MA, LMHC
Verified Verified
Indianapolis, IN 46240
My ideal client is someone who wants to actively pursue new paths to find their true, healthy self. Ideally, ready to do the work. I am here to challenge cognitive distortions. I will be a partner in brainstorming issues and goals. Hard work from the client and support from an intuitive counselor will clear the path to the answers within.
My ideal client is someone who wants to actively pursue new paths to find their true, healthy self. Ideally, ready to do the work. I am here to challenge cognitive distortions. I will be a partner in brainstorming issues and goals. Hard work from the client and support from an intuitive counselor will clear the path to the answers within.
(463) 219-2812 View (463) 219-2812
Photo of Miranda K Linville, Counselor in Shelby County, IN
Miranda K Linville
Counselor, MA, LMHC
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
Indianapolis, IN 46259  (Online Only)
Hello, my name is Miranda. My goal as a therapist is to help you work through your your issues, address your inner needs and achieve your goals. I help you focus on what is most important to you by providing you a safe space to explore, express and examine the areas of your life that have been causing you stress or discomfort. Once you find a therapist that works for you and you feel comfortable, being able to open up is the easy part. My approach to counseling is rooted in a person centered approach, along with feministic and empowerment focused support to help you be the best you can be every day.
Hello, my name is Miranda. My goal as a therapist is to help you work through your your issues, address your inner needs and achieve your goals. I help you focus on what is most important to you by providing you a safe space to explore, express and examine the areas of your life that have been causing you stress or discomfort. Once you find a therapist that works for you and you feel comfortable, being able to open up is the easy part. My approach to counseling is rooted in a person centered approach, along with feministic and empowerment focused support to help you be the best you can be every day.
(317) 934-2730 View (317) 934-2730
Photo of Supportive Community Innovations, Psychologist in Shelby County, IN
Supportive Community Innovations
Psychologist
Verified Verified
Bloomington, IN 47403
Supportive Community Innovations is a local business that offers a wide range of therapies to a wide range of individuals and families! Our director is Dr. Julie Chapin–a Licensed Psychologist who oversees our Mental Health Counselors. We have many openings right now for adults and children due to new hires. Please check out our therapists below for more information by clicking on the pics.
Supportive Community Innovations is a local business that offers a wide range of therapies to a wide range of individuals and families! Our director is Dr. Julie Chapin–a Licensed Psychologist who oversees our Mental Health Counselors. We have many openings right now for adults and children due to new hires. Please check out our therapists below for more information by clicking on the pics.
(812) 389-0593 View (812) 389-0593
Photo of Ashlyn Eades, Counselor in Shelby County, IN
Ashlyn Eades
Counselor, LMHC, LPC
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
Indianapolis, IN 46202
I offer a therapeutic approach that is warm, non-judgmental, and engages the client. I provide short and long- term therapy to Children, Adolescents, Adults, Couples and Families. I am a compassionate therapist who has treated clients with a range of clinical issues. My approach provides a safe way to deal with major life changes. I strive to create a positive and calm atmosphere of acceptance for you as we work to achieve your goals. I will offer you insight and provide you with thoughtful feedback. I want to be able to support my clients through any issues or situations they need.
I offer a therapeutic approach that is warm, non-judgmental, and engages the client. I provide short and long- term therapy to Children, Adolescents, Adults, Couples and Families. I am a compassionate therapist who has treated clients with a range of clinical issues. My approach provides a safe way to deal with major life changes. I strive to create a positive and calm atmosphere of acceptance for you as we work to achieve your goals. I will offer you insight and provide you with thoughtful feedback. I want to be able to support my clients through any issues or situations they need.
(317) 961-3001 View (317) 961-3001
Photo of Sara Chambers, Counselor in Shelby County, IN
Sara Chambers
Counselor, LMHC
Verified Verified
Indianapolis, IN 46227
Ms. Chambers has 18 years experience in mental health, with 10 years working as a therapist, primarily in outpatient settings. She has her Master's degree in Mental Health Counseling, and her Bachelor's degree in Psychology. She has training in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), CBT, Rational Emotive Behavior Therapist (REBT), Motivational Interviewing (MI), and uses a trauma informed care approach.
Ms. Chambers has 18 years experience in mental health, with 10 years working as a therapist, primarily in outpatient settings. She has her Master's degree in Mental Health Counseling, and her Bachelor's degree in Psychology. She has training in Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT), CBT, Rational Emotive Behavior Therapist (REBT), Motivational Interviewing (MI), and uses a trauma informed care approach.
(463) 263-4702 View (463) 263-4702
Photo of Michael McCully, Marriage & Family Therapist in Shelby County, IN
Michael McCully
Marriage & Family Therapist, MA, LMFT
Verified Verified
3 Endorsed
Indianapolis, IN 46256  (Online Only)
I work with adult clients who feel stuck but still want to build more confidence, more inner peace, and harmonious relationships. I enjoy empowering people to trust in themselves and in their partners. I collaborate best with folks who are smart and creative, spiritual but not necessarily religious. Some have been minorities (e.g., immigrants, LGBTQ+, etc.). Many have been feminists and progressives. Most have struggled with anxiety and depression. All have proven themselves resilient!
I work with adult clients who feel stuck but still want to build more confidence, more inner peace, and harmonious relationships. I enjoy empowering people to trust in themselves and in their partners. I collaborate best with folks who are smart and creative, spiritual but not necessarily religious. Some have been minorities (e.g., immigrants, LGBTQ+, etc.). Many have been feminists and progressives. Most have struggled with anxiety and depression. All have proven themselves resilient!
(317) 676-2881 View (317) 676-2881
Photo of Cassie Alexander, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in Shelby County, IN
Cassie Alexander
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Verified Verified
Indianapolis, IN 46204  (Online Only)
Hello! I am Cassie and am an LCSW and LCAC in Indiana. I feel it is an honor to work with individuals to find what they are seeking in coming to therapy. I find that therapy is intimidating to a lot of people and strive to make people feel comfortable in their therapy journey. I have been practicing for approximately 15 years and continue to love serving others whom I have the pleasure to work with.
Hello! I am Cassie and am an LCSW and LCAC in Indiana. I feel it is an honor to work with individuals to find what they are seeking in coming to therapy. I find that therapy is intimidating to a lot of people and strive to make people feel comfortable in their therapy journey. I have been practicing for approximately 15 years and continue to love serving others whom I have the pleasure to work with.
(317) 733-5737 View (317) 733-5737
Photo of Teri Cardwell, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in Shelby County, IN
Teri Cardwell
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, ACSW
Verified Verified
Westfield, IN 46074
As a therapist, I am most excited to see clients motivated to explore their unknown strengths, widen their horizons, increase their abilities to make informed decisions and lead a life of meaning as they define it. Everyone I have worked with brings to therapy a foundation upon which to grow. Regardless of the problem, an enhanced sense of self is possible. Instilling hope of something better in life is one of my greatest motivations, and assisting others in achieving their goals drew me to this profession.
As a therapist, I am most excited to see clients motivated to explore their unknown strengths, widen their horizons, increase their abilities to make informed decisions and lead a life of meaning as they define it. Everyone I have worked with brings to therapy a foundation upon which to grow. Regardless of the problem, an enhanced sense of self is possible. Instilling hope of something better in life is one of my greatest motivations, and assisting others in achieving their goals drew me to this profession.
(463) 583-1682 View (463) 583-1682
Photo of Ewa Barnaby, Counselor in Shelby County, IN
Ewa Barnaby
Counselor, MA, LMHCA, RYT
Verified Verified
2 Endorsed
Avon, IN 46123
Hi, I'm Ewa (eh-vuh). I honor all human experience just as it is and recognize that life is rarely linear. At times life may bring challenges that impact and even overwhelm our ability to access and utilize our capacity to heal. Through counseling it is possible to be curious, alongside one another, about the questions your life is asking you. I have confidence that we can co-create a space in which the authentic part of you can be seen and heard in ways that honor your truth. I aim to help you process your complex emotional experiences so that you could live with greater ease and comfort in your relationship with self and others.
Hi, I'm Ewa (eh-vuh). I honor all human experience just as it is and recognize that life is rarely linear. At times life may bring challenges that impact and even overwhelm our ability to access and utilize our capacity to heal. Through counseling it is possible to be curious, alongside one another, about the questions your life is asking you. I have confidence that we can co-create a space in which the authentic part of you can be seen and heard in ways that honor your truth. I aim to help you process your complex emotional experiences so that you could live with greater ease and comfort in your relationship with self and others.
(463) 583-3052 View (463) 583-3052
Photo of Elisabeth Montgomery, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in Shelby County, IN
Elisabeth Montgomery
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Verified Verified
Zionsville, IN 46077
Waitlist for new clients
Welcome! I'm really glad you are here. My goal is to create a soft place to land, grow, feel challenged and supported. I specialize in treating anxiety, depression, adhd, stress, relationships, life transitions, and trauma. My practice is based on the belief that when our experiences are met with compassion and curiosity we can grow and create more fullness in our lives and relationships. My approach to therapy is primarily rooted in modalities from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and Dialectical Behavior Therapy, with a strong emphasis on body-based therapies (including Brainspotting), mindfulness and self-compassion.
Welcome! I'm really glad you are here. My goal is to create a soft place to land, grow, feel challenged and supported. I specialize in treating anxiety, depression, adhd, stress, relationships, life transitions, and trauma. My practice is based on the belief that when our experiences are met with compassion and curiosity we can grow and create more fullness in our lives and relationships. My approach to therapy is primarily rooted in modalities from Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and Dialectical Behavior Therapy, with a strong emphasis on body-based therapies (including Brainspotting), mindfulness and self-compassion.
(720) 613-6672 View (720) 613-6672
Photo of Jamarra M Smith-Massey, Pre-Licensed Professional in Shelby County, IN
Jamarra M Smith-Massey
Pre-Licensed Professional, MA
Verified Verified
Indianapolis, IN 46203
Hi, I am Jamarra! Are you struggling with maintaining the relationships in your life? Are you seeking to find peace? Striving to enter an era of healing in your life? Looking to improve your self-esteem, self-confidence, and self-awareness? Are you feeling overwhelmed, stressed, anxious, and/or sad? Struggling to make it through the day, and feeling as if there are not enough hours in a day? I would love to work with you!
Hi, I am Jamarra! Are you struggling with maintaining the relationships in your life? Are you seeking to find peace? Striving to enter an era of healing in your life? Looking to improve your self-esteem, self-confidence, and self-awareness? Are you feeling overwhelmed, stressed, anxious, and/or sad? Struggling to make it through the day, and feeling as if there are not enough hours in a day? I would love to work with you!
(463) 666-2564 View (463) 666-2564
Photo of Kirsten Donaldson, Counselor in Shelby County, IN
Kirsten Donaldson
Counselor, MA, LMHC
Verified Verified
3 Endorsed
Greenwood, IN 46143
If you are looking for an EMDR therapist who has immediate openings, you have found one! Do you ever think "I'm not good enough", "I'm a failure", "I did something wrong", or any other negative belief about yourself? EMDR will help you process events in your life that lead you to have these negative thoughts. I also work with individuals experiencing anxiety, depression, and relationship issues. I use a cognitive and dialectical focus to link thoughts, feelings, and behaviors and integrate coping skills such as mindfulness, interpersonal effectiveness, emotion regulation, and distress tolerance.
If you are looking for an EMDR therapist who has immediate openings, you have found one! Do you ever think "I'm not good enough", "I'm a failure", "I did something wrong", or any other negative belief about yourself? EMDR will help you process events in your life that lead you to have these negative thoughts. I also work with individuals experiencing anxiety, depression, and relationship issues. I use a cognitive and dialectical focus to link thoughts, feelings, and behaviors and integrate coping skills such as mindfulness, interpersonal effectiveness, emotion regulation, and distress tolerance.
(317) 827-7101 View (317) 827-7101
Photo of Ellyn Vogel, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in Shelby County, IN
Ellyn Vogel
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Verified Verified
Indianapolis, IN 46241  (Online Only)
Hello! I am currently offering Telehealth and phone sessions. Are you interested in personal growth and healing? I believe one of the greatest gifts you can give yourself is having the courage to look inward, while being compassionate with yourself so you can begin to move forward. I have been working with people for over 20 years towards (re)gaining mental and physical health through lifestyle approaches to wellness. I offer a research-based holistic approach, which looks at the whole person, while also integrating various therapeutic techniques to help you reach the deepest healing possible.
Hello! I am currently offering Telehealth and phone sessions. Are you interested in personal growth and healing? I believe one of the greatest gifts you can give yourself is having the courage to look inward, while being compassionate with yourself so you can begin to move forward. I have been working with people for over 20 years towards (re)gaining mental and physical health through lifestyle approaches to wellness. I offer a research-based holistic approach, which looks at the whole person, while also integrating various therapeutic techniques to help you reach the deepest healing possible.
(708) 726-5407 View (708) 726-5407
Photo of Ex Nihilo, Marriage & Family Therapist in Shelby County, IN
Ex Nihilo
Marriage & Family Therapist, LMFT, MA
Verified Verified
Kokomo, IN 46901
Creation Desautels is a Licensed Marriage & Family Therapist As a clinician, Creation works from a spiritually integrated family systems and psychoanalytic perspective. She is seeking to live, and guide others toward relational health and wholeness.. She seeks to live and work, in other words to do-relationship with self and other, in ways that reflect these integrated principals. To best align with these principal Creation sees a limited number of clients and centers her practice around long-format and intensive treatment formats. Though virtual appointments are available, Creation focuses on face-to-face in person care.
Creation Desautels is a Licensed Marriage & Family Therapist As a clinician, Creation works from a spiritually integrated family systems and psychoanalytic perspective. She is seeking to live, and guide others toward relational health and wholeness.. She seeks to live and work, in other words to do-relationship with self and other, in ways that reflect these integrated principals. To best align with these principal Creation sees a limited number of clients and centers her practice around long-format and intensive treatment formats. Though virtual appointments are available, Creation focuses on face-to-face in person care.
(765) 764-9608 View (765) 764-9608
Photo of Kristy Steiner, Counselor in Shelby County, IN
Kristy Steiner
Counselor, MS, Ed, LMHC
Verified Verified
West Lafayette, IN 47907  (Online Only)
Hello! I’m Kristy and I’m excited to help you work towards living your best life. My ideal client is someone who is looking for help in their time of need. Knowing that seeking counseling can be overwhelming in itself, I work to meet you where you are on your journey, and towards the goals you want to achieve. I work with adults and teens on adjustment issues, life stressors, anxiety, depression, trauma, and other issues. I also have experience working with body positivity and self-esteem.
Hello! I’m Kristy and I’m excited to help you work towards living your best life. My ideal client is someone who is looking for help in their time of need. Knowing that seeking counseling can be overwhelming in itself, I work to meet you where you are on your journey, and towards the goals you want to achieve. I work with adults and teens on adjustment issues, life stressors, anxiety, depression, trauma, and other issues. I also have experience working with body positivity and self-esteem.
(765) 232-3240 View (765) 232-3240
Photo of Lisa L. Coston, M.S., LMHC, Counselor in Shelby County, IN
Lisa L. Coston, M.S., LMHC
Counselor, MS, LMHC
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
Carmel, IN 46032
As a practicing therapist for over 20s years, I pride myself on helping those who need guidance and a listening ear in times of difficulty. Acknowledging that it takes courage to reach for help and begin therapy, I hope to lessen the intimidating and overwhelming process as an experienced therapist. I work primarily with adolescents and adults on issues ranging from depression and anxiety to more specific trauma related concerns. I will work also to hear your needs as we walk alongside each other through the counseling process.
As a practicing therapist for over 20s years, I pride myself on helping those who need guidance and a listening ear in times of difficulty. Acknowledging that it takes courage to reach for help and begin therapy, I hope to lessen the intimidating and overwhelming process as an experienced therapist. I work primarily with adolescents and adults on issues ranging from depression and anxiety to more specific trauma related concerns. I will work also to hear your needs as we walk alongside each other through the counseling process.
(765) 598-5149 View (765) 598-5149

See more therapy options for Shelby County


Aetna Therapists

Does insurance cover therapy, prescriptions and other behavioral health services?

In general, yes. Laws in the U.S. require insurers to cover essential behavioral health care at the same level as other health care services. Most health plans require a medical diagnosis and treatments that are evidence based and medically essential. This means that life coaching and alternative therapies are not covered, nor is therapy without a diagnosis. Call the number on the back or your insurance card or visit your insurance company's website to review your Summary of Benefits. If you have insurance through your employer, your Human Resources department may also be able to answer questions.

How much does therapy cost with insurance?

The cost of therapy depends on your region, how much training and experience your therapist has, and the type of treatment. The rate for talk therapy generally falls between $100 and $250. For a client seeing an in-network provider, the cost of therapy is often similar to the cost of other health care services. Clients pay co-pays and may need to satisfy a plan’s deductible before benefits kick in.

What is the difference between In-Network and Out-of-Network insurance coverage?

An in-network provider has contracted with an insurer to get paid directly for services, and to accept the insurer’s rate of compensation. Clients are responsible for deductibles and copays. If a therapist is out of network, that means that the client pays the therapist directly for services at the therapist’s regular fee. Out-of-Network providers often give clients a receipt so that they can file for partial reimbursement with their insurance company.

Is it difficult to find an In-Network therapist?

It is not unusual for therapists to limit the number of insurance patients in their practice, so it’s important to check in-network availability when you schedule your first appointment. In regions and times where therapy is in high demand it may take longer to get scheduled with an in-network therapist.

What is the difference between HMO and PPO insurance plans?

HMO health plans only cover in-network services, there is no reimbursement for out-of-network providers. PPO plans often cover both in- and out-of-network services, though the client may pay more for out-of-network services.

What is a Superbill?

A superbill is a receipt for therapy services. It provides all the information required by insurance companies to reimburse you for out-of-network services, including the diagnostic codes for your care, the amount paid, and the dates and duration of care.

Does insurance cover Online therapy?

Many therapists who shifted their practice to online therapy during the pandemic have kept that arrangement. And most insurers continue to cover telehealth services, with a few exceptions. Preventive care (such as an annual depression screening) is often required to be in-person to be covered, and some states require prescribers of controlled substances to see those patients in person.

Does insurance cover Group therapy?

Many insurance plans provide coverage for group therapy provided there is a medical diagnosis for group members, but there are some noteworthy exceptions. For example, Medicare does not always cover group therapy. Group therapy tends to cost less than individual therapy.

Does insurance cover Couples therapy?

Most insurance companies do not cover the cost of couples therapy because there is no medical diagnosis or medically necessary treatment. However, a few plans will offer a limited benefit, so it is still worth checking with your insurance company. Sometimes therapy is covered for a couple when one person has a diagnosis and another family member joins them for joint therapy, but it is considered therapy for the medical condition that includes a family member as a listener or helper, not couples counseling. Without insurance, most clients pay between $100-300 per 60-90 min session for couples therapy. Often clients can find classes or workshops that make it more affordable to work on their relationship. And some employers offer Employee Assistance Plans that help defray the cost of couples therapy.

What is an Employee Assistance Plan (EAP)?

Employee Assistance Plans are purchased by employers for the benefit of their employees. EAPs typically assist employees with referrals and may also provide the first few sessions of therapy free of charge, with the patient's regular health insurance kicking in after those initial sessions. EAP benefits often apply to all types of therapy without the need for a medical diagnosis, making it easier to access couples therapy, therapy for life transitions, and other non-medical counseling. Just as with standard health insurance, clients should always check that a provider accepts their EAP benefits before scheduling.

Learn more about Insurance Coverage and Finding Affordable Therapy