Therapists in New York, NY

View neighborhoods in New York
Photo of Aashlesha Patel, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in New York, NY
Aashlesha Patel
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
New York, NY 10001
Hi, are you new to therapy or just haven’t really had a good experience with therapy? Maybe you’re feeling “stuck” in some aspect of your life be it relationships, career or unhealthy coping behaviors. Life is hectic and demanding, leaving us feeling disconnected from ourselves and others, which can cause anxiety and feelings of inadequacy.
Hi, are you new to therapy or just haven’t really had a good experience with therapy? Maybe you’re feeling “stuck” in some aspect of your life be it relationships, career or unhealthy coping behaviors. Life is hectic and demanding, leaving us feeling disconnected from ourselves and others, which can cause anxiety and feelings of inadequacy.
(646) 580-8087 View (646) 580-8087
Photo of Joseph S Zucker, Psychologist in New York, NY
Joseph S Zucker
Psychologist, PhD
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10128
For 30 years, I have helped the patients in my private practice to live more fulfilling lives. By reducing stress and creating an atmosphere of security and openness, I gently guide patients to explore the defining issues and experiences that are important to them. Nothing is more rewarding than to watch my patients develop a greater understanding of their emotions and thoughts, and gain the confidence they need to move forward in their lives.
For 30 years, I have helped the patients in my private practice to live more fulfilling lives. By reducing stress and creating an atmosphere of security and openness, I gently guide patients to explore the defining issues and experiences that are important to them. Nothing is more rewarding than to watch my patients develop a greater understanding of their emotions and thoughts, and gain the confidence they need to move forward in their lives.
(646) 736-7708 View (646) 736-7708
Photo of Simone Bloch, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in New York, NY
Simone Bloch
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MFA, LCSW
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10025
You may need help coping with anxiety because the world itself feels out of control. Under abnormal circumstances, what is normal? Let's address your issues in light of the uncertainties of the present day and create a measured sense of urgency. Therapy can help you sift through beliefs that you may already know you must outgrow. Together we work to identify what it is that hinders you. The goal is to strengthen your capacities in professional and personal relationships and make a transition to a more satisfying life.
You may need help coping with anxiety because the world itself feels out of control. Under abnormal circumstances, what is normal? Let's address your issues in light of the uncertainties of the present day and create a measured sense of urgency. Therapy can help you sift through beliefs that you may already know you must outgrow. Together we work to identify what it is that hinders you. The goal is to strengthen your capacities in professional and personal relationships and make a transition to a more satisfying life.
(917) 826-8447 View (917) 826-8447
Photo of Tarynn Dier in New York, NY
Tarynn Dier
LMSW, Coach
Verified Verified
2 Endorsed
New York, NY 10013  (Online Only)
I'm a proud queer/pan/poly human, and I absolutely love being a therapist. As a straight-passing queer person, I have a lived understanding of what it’s like to have multiple marginalized identities that are misread both in and outside my communities. As a single parent who was raised in a very religious environment, I have done a lot of my own introspection and exploration to become the sex positive and body positive person I am today. I am a compassionate, non-judgmental, and empowerment-focused therapist. I aim to support you in living freely and authentically, as you thrive in your relationships with yourself and others.
I'm a proud queer/pan/poly human, and I absolutely love being a therapist. As a straight-passing queer person, I have a lived understanding of what it’s like to have multiple marginalized identities that are misread both in and outside my communities. As a single parent who was raised in a very religious environment, I have done a lot of my own introspection and exploration to become the sex positive and body positive person I am today. I am a compassionate, non-judgmental, and empowerment-focused therapist. I aim to support you in living freely and authentically, as you thrive in your relationships with yourself and others.
View
Photo of Dr. Silvia Birklein, SYNC Psychological Services™, Psychologist in New York, NY
Dr. Silvia Birklein, SYNC Psychological Services™
Psychologist, PhD, MA, LCAT, BC-DMT, CMA
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10010
I am a licensed psychologist/psychoanalyst with over 20 years of practice in psychotherapy and body/mind approaches. If you experience trauma, anxiety, depression, or relationship problems, I am dedicated to helping you. I'll work with you on becoming aware of unresolved issues that limit your choices and freedom in life by attending carefully to your narrative and experience. Emphasis is on an exploration of your issues, and on the therapeutic relationship. In addition, our group has a team of experts/clinicians who are trained in a variety of approaches and issues. Please see the website for more info: WWW.SYNCPSYCH.COM
I am a licensed psychologist/psychoanalyst with over 20 years of practice in psychotherapy and body/mind approaches. If you experience trauma, anxiety, depression, or relationship problems, I am dedicated to helping you. I'll work with you on becoming aware of unresolved issues that limit your choices and freedom in life by attending carefully to your narrative and experience. Emphasis is on an exploration of your issues, and on the therapeutic relationship. In addition, our group has a team of experts/clinicians who are trained in a variety of approaches and issues. Please see the website for more info: WWW.SYNCPSYCH.COM
View
Photo of Julie Marcus, Psychologist in New York, NY
Julie Marcus
Psychologist, PhD
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10025  (Online Only)
A clinical psychologist for over thirty years, I am devoted to helping people of all ages resolve the problems that stand in the way of a satisfying life. Difficulty forming and maintaining close, interpersonal relationships and/or anxieties related to school or work are typical reasons for seeking treatment. I create a warm, non-judgmental atmosphere that allows for the open and honest expression of any and all thoughts and feelings Using the "talking cure”, together, we attempt to get to the bottom of the problem and work it through so that life can get back on track and personal goals can be met.
A clinical psychologist for over thirty years, I am devoted to helping people of all ages resolve the problems that stand in the way of a satisfying life. Difficulty forming and maintaining close, interpersonal relationships and/or anxieties related to school or work are typical reasons for seeking treatment. I create a warm, non-judgmental atmosphere that allows for the open and honest expression of any and all thoughts and feelings Using the "talking cure”, together, we attempt to get to the bottom of the problem and work it through so that life can get back on track and personal goals can be met.
(646) 604-2479 View (646) 604-2479
Photo of Lauren Kunik, Psychologist in New York, NY
Lauren Kunik
Psychologist, PhD
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10016
Reaching out to a new therapist can be anxiety provoking for both new and seasoned patients alike. It is my goal to facilitate the process of starting therapy by providing an inviting environment and having an approach that is empathic and active. After identifying and discussing your therapeutic goals and needs, together we'll decide if we make a good team to tackle them collaboratively, which I strongly believe is a key element to a successful treatment.
Reaching out to a new therapist can be anxiety provoking for both new and seasoned patients alike. It is my goal to facilitate the process of starting therapy by providing an inviting environment and having an approach that is empathic and active. After identifying and discussing your therapeutic goals and needs, together we'll decide if we make a good team to tackle them collaboratively, which I strongly believe is a key element to a successful treatment.
(347) 934-4069 View (347) 934-4069
Photo of Charlotte Elkin, LCSW P.C., Clinical Social Work/Therapist in New York, NY
Charlotte Elkin, LCSW P.C.
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW-R
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10026  (Online Only)
Sometimes life's challenges, transitions, or conditions are more than we can handle. Feelings of sadness or fear overwhelm. We realize that the way we are living is not how we want to live but are unable to make changes on our own. Unhealthy relationships, dealing with disappointment or loss, feeling alone, or struggling with an inner critic, are a few examples of what leads people to reach out to me. In my practice I largely employ the Internal Family Systems (IFS) model as my framework but also draw techniques from CBT, EMDR, DBT, mindfulness, somatic experiencing, and psychodynamic psychotherapy, when needed.
Sometimes life's challenges, transitions, or conditions are more than we can handle. Feelings of sadness or fear overwhelm. We realize that the way we are living is not how we want to live but are unable to make changes on our own. Unhealthy relationships, dealing with disappointment or loss, feeling alone, or struggling with an inner critic, are a few examples of what leads people to reach out to me. In my practice I largely employ the Internal Family Systems (IFS) model as my framework but also draw techniques from CBT, EMDR, DBT, mindfulness, somatic experiencing, and psychodynamic psychotherapy, when needed.
(914) 357-7898 View (914) 357-7898
Photo of Elliot Kaminetzky, Psychologist in New York, NY
Elliot Kaminetzky
Psychologist, PhD
Verified Verified
4 Endorsed
New York, NY 10004
Having OCD or anxiety can make make every day tasks seem nearly impossible. It can sap you of your energy and ability to enjoy the things you love. On top of that, you likely have harsh judgements about having anxiety, leading to frustration and sadness. Maybe you've tried therapy in the past but nothing seems to stick. Having worked with so many people who have suffered with these conditions, I hear and feel what you are going through. I have dedicated my career to helping you understand your anxiety and build the skills to address it.
Having OCD or anxiety can make make every day tasks seem nearly impossible. It can sap you of your energy and ability to enjoy the things you love. On top of that, you likely have harsh judgements about having anxiety, leading to frustration and sadness. Maybe you've tried therapy in the past but nothing seems to stick. Having worked with so many people who have suffered with these conditions, I hear and feel what you are going through. I have dedicated my career to helping you understand your anxiety and build the skills to address it.
(646) 832-2499 View (646) 832-2499
Photo of Helen Johnston Gant, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in New York, NY
Helen Johnston Gant
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10019
Through psychodynamic work, I am deeply committed to helping my patients find ways of understanding themselves, and the worlds they live in, with ever greater clarity and insight. I have extensive experience working with people who are struggling with symptoms of depression and/or anxiety, as well as mood disorders, insomnia, and interpersonal struggles. I have a particular interest in working with couples, people facing the struggles surrounding starting a family (including infertility, loss, perinatal and postpartum depression and anxiety).
Through psychodynamic work, I am deeply committed to helping my patients find ways of understanding themselves, and the worlds they live in, with ever greater clarity and insight. I have extensive experience working with people who are struggling with symptoms of depression and/or anxiety, as well as mood disorders, insomnia, and interpersonal struggles. I have a particular interest in working with couples, people facing the struggles surrounding starting a family (including infertility, loss, perinatal and postpartum depression and anxiety).
(914) 228-6142 View (914) 228-6142
Photo of David Gottesfeld, Psychologist in New York, NY
David Gottesfeld
Psychologist, PsyD
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10023
David Gottesfeld (www.davidgottesfeld.com) is a Licensed Psychologist in private practice since 1991, with offices in Manhattan and White Plains, New York. Dr. Gottesfeld is also an Adjunct Professor at the Ferkauf Graduate School of Psychology teaching the Practicum in Child Assessment. He specializes in comprehensive Psycho-Educational Testing and Neuropsychological Testing, as well as child, adolescent, and adult psychotherapy. He is recognized as an expert in the assessment and treatment of children, adolescents, and adults and is skilled in the process of securing extended time and other test accommodations on the ISEE, PSAT, SAT, SAT2, or ACT.
David Gottesfeld (www.davidgottesfeld.com) is a Licensed Psychologist in private practice since 1991, with offices in Manhattan and White Plains, New York. Dr. Gottesfeld is also an Adjunct Professor at the Ferkauf Graduate School of Psychology teaching the Practicum in Child Assessment. He specializes in comprehensive Psycho-Educational Testing and Neuropsychological Testing, as well as child, adolescent, and adult psychotherapy. He is recognized as an expert in the assessment and treatment of children, adolescents, and adults and is skilled in the process of securing extended time and other test accommodations on the ISEE, PSAT, SAT, SAT2, or ACT.
(866) 693-9993 View (866) 693-9993
Photo of Reggie Parker in New York, NY
Reggie Parker
LMSW
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10003
I excel in empowering individuals to reach their true potential. I counsel individuals and families in several areas including depression, anxiety, trauma and life challenges such as relationships, loss, and self-esteem issues. I utilize different forms of communication as a therapeutic tool such as talking, writing, journaling, art, and music. My experience has also focused on homelessness, domestic violence and formerly incarcerated individuals. It truly opened my eyes to the deep struggles that people are dealing with in life.
I excel in empowering individuals to reach their true potential. I counsel individuals and families in several areas including depression, anxiety, trauma and life challenges such as relationships, loss, and self-esteem issues. I utilize different forms of communication as a therapeutic tool such as talking, writing, journaling, art, and music. My experience has also focused on homelessness, domestic violence and formerly incarcerated individuals. It truly opened my eyes to the deep struggles that people are dealing with in life.
(646) 798-9789 View (646) 798-9789
Photo of Cristina Spataro in New York, NY
Cristina Spataro
MSEd, LMHC
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
New York, NY 10005
Cristina Spataro has worked with children and families in crisis for the past 17 years. If there is one thing she has learned, it is that everyone has the capacity for change if they truly want it. Life is hard, and the “right” choices are not always so apparent. Our decisions and their consequences leave us questioning ourselves.
Cristina Spataro has worked with children and families in crisis for the past 17 years. If there is one thing she has learned, it is that everyone has the capacity for change if they truly want it. Life is hard, and the “right” choices are not always so apparent. Our decisions and their consequences leave us questioning ourselves.
(917) 473-9583 View (917) 473-9583
Photo of Michael Morrison, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in New York, NY
Michael Morrison
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10003  (Online Only)
The ideal client for me is a young, mature, or elder adult who is motivated by their suffering or by their character to learn something new about themselves, to resolve some issue which is causing them anguish or anxiety, or both. Therapy is as much an educational process as a healing process. Both learning and healing are key elements of successful therapeutic collaboration. I am suited to treat any of the specialties designated in my profile. I have network of colleagues through which I make referrals for issues that require specialists' attention such as severe addictive issues or veterans' PTSD.
The ideal client for me is a young, mature, or elder adult who is motivated by their suffering or by their character to learn something new about themselves, to resolve some issue which is causing them anguish or anxiety, or both. Therapy is as much an educational process as a healing process. Both learning and healing are key elements of successful therapeutic collaboration. I am suited to treat any of the specialties designated in my profile. I have network of colleagues through which I make referrals for issues that require specialists' attention such as severe addictive issues or veterans' PTSD.
(646) 760-1389 View (646) 760-1389
Photo of Clorinda Bulfamante, Psychologist in New York, NY
Clorinda Bulfamante
Psychologist, PsyD
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10017
I am a clinical psychologist providing therapy and assessment services in Scarsdale and Greenwich. I treat various conditions, such as depression, anxiety, behavioral problems, social anxiety, and school/work issues. I also focus on life transitions, whether that be a recent move, transition from college, changes in family dynamics, or changes in significant relationships. Furthermore, I have extensive experience in conducting psychological assessments. Therapeutically, I focus on developing teens and adults, where as I provide assessments for all ages.
I am a clinical psychologist providing therapy and assessment services in Scarsdale and Greenwich. I treat various conditions, such as depression, anxiety, behavioral problems, social anxiety, and school/work issues. I also focus on life transitions, whether that be a recent move, transition from college, changes in family dynamics, or changes in significant relationships. Furthermore, I have extensive experience in conducting psychological assessments. Therapeutically, I focus on developing teens and adults, where as I provide assessments for all ages.
View
Photo of Fengtao Huang, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in New York, NY
Fengtao Huang
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, CASAC
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10011  (Online Only)
Waitlist for new clients
Hello, it's great to meet you! Are you feeling overwhelmed or anxious about transitioning to parenthood? Do you have chronic stress, sadness, anger, or fear related to parenting and relationship challenges? Is your child having social, behavioral, and emotional difficulties? Being a parent can be the most amazing yet challenging experience. I am here to support you through the process. I recognize clients are the experts that they are, and I hope to make you feel heard, supported, and empowered during our collaborations.
Hello, it's great to meet you! Are you feeling overwhelmed or anxious about transitioning to parenthood? Do you have chronic stress, sadness, anger, or fear related to parenting and relationship challenges? Is your child having social, behavioral, and emotional difficulties? Being a parent can be the most amazing yet challenging experience. I am here to support you through the process. I recognize clients are the experts that they are, and I hope to make you feel heard, supported, and empowered during our collaborations.
(646) 663-5597 View (646) 663-5597
Photo of Iesha Whitaker, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in New York, NY
Iesha Whitaker
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10022
Iesha Whitaker, LCSW, She/Her Biography I am an LCSW, and I have been practicing in New York city since 2012. I graduated from Hunter College School of social work in 2011. My areas of focus are Anxiety Disorders, Depression, PTSD, ADHD, Anger Management, daily life stressors, emotional dysregulation and clients dealing with life transitions. I work with clients that have experienced issues with substance abuse, chronic homelessness and Domestic Violence.
Iesha Whitaker, LCSW, She/Her Biography I am an LCSW, and I have been practicing in New York city since 2012. I graduated from Hunter College School of social work in 2011. My areas of focus are Anxiety Disorders, Depression, PTSD, ADHD, Anger Management, daily life stressors, emotional dysregulation and clients dealing with life transitions. I work with clients that have experienced issues with substance abuse, chronic homelessness and Domestic Violence.
(929) 499-2148 View (929) 499-2148
Photo of Brooke English, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in New York, NY
Brooke English
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW, RYT
Verified Verified
1 Endorsed
New York, NY 10025  (Online Only)
Are you feeling overwhelmed with emotions and unsure of how to manage all of the feelings coming up? Perhaps you have lived through a traumatic childhood, relationship, or experience and feel burdened or confused by the past. Maybe you've been told by people that you’re ‘too sensitive’ or ‘need to get over it’. You have been juggling everything on your own, in the best way you know how, and now are looking for more support. Together, we can walk through life’s difficulties and take actionable steps to leading a more enjoyable and fulfilling life.
Are you feeling overwhelmed with emotions and unsure of how to manage all of the feelings coming up? Perhaps you have lived through a traumatic childhood, relationship, or experience and feel burdened or confused by the past. Maybe you've been told by people that you’re ‘too sensitive’ or ‘need to get over it’. You have been juggling everything on your own, in the best way you know how, and now are looking for more support. Together, we can walk through life’s difficulties and take actionable steps to leading a more enjoyable and fulfilling life.
(347) 848-1614 View (347) 848-1614
Photo of Alon Andrews, Pre-Licensed Professional in New York, NY
Alon Andrews
Pre-Licensed Professional, MSEd, MHC, LP
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10013
Are you searching for a compassionate and dedicated psychotherapist who can help guide you through life's challenges? Look no further. I am currently accepting new clients and would be honored to accompany you on your journey towards healing and personal growth. Are there specific issues, concerns, or questions weighing on your mind? Together, we can explore and address them in a safe and non-judgmental environment. Whether you seek support in navigating relationships, managing stress, or coping with trauma, I am here to provide the guidance and tools you need to thrive.
Are you searching for a compassionate and dedicated psychotherapist who can help guide you through life's challenges? Look no further. I am currently accepting new clients and would be honored to accompany you on your journey towards healing and personal growth. Are there specific issues, concerns, or questions weighing on your mind? Together, we can explore and address them in a safe and non-judgmental environment. Whether you seek support in navigating relationships, managing stress, or coping with trauma, I am here to provide the guidance and tools you need to thrive.
(516) 518-6805 View (516) 518-6805
Photo of Erin Larsen, Clinical Social Work/Therapist in New York, NY
Erin Larsen
Clinical Social Work/Therapist, LCSW
Verified Verified
New York, NY 10011
Times of transition in both relationships and careers often yield feelings of anxiety and depression. A better understanding of our emotions and motivations can result in the ability to manage difficult times and move to a place of satisfaction and happiness. This is the goal I have for my patients.
Times of transition in both relationships and careers often yield feelings of anxiety and depression. A better understanding of our emotions and motivations can result in the ability to manage difficult times and move to a place of satisfaction and happiness. This is the goal I have for my patients.
(917) 809-6856 View (917) 809-6856

How does your Therapist compare?

Number of Therapists in New York, NY

3,000+

Average cost per session

$200

Therapists in New York, NY who prioritize treating:

94% Anxiety
89% Depression
85% Relationship Issues
78% Self Esteem
67% Trauma and PTSD
66% Stress
63% Coping Skills

Average years in practice

12 Years

Top 3 insurances accepted

78% Aetna
62% UnitedHealthcare UHC | UBH
60% Cigna and Evernorth

How Therapists in New York, NY see their clients

59% In Person and Online
41% Online Only

Gender breakdown

78% Female
21% Male
1% Non-Binary
FAQs - About Therapy and Counseling

How can I find a therapist in New York?

Search for nearby therapists or counselors by inputting your city, town, or suburb; or zip code; or a provider’s name into the search bar. From there, you can filter providers by the issues they treat, cost, insurance, gender, and other factors to find providers who are well-suited to your needs. To navigate between locations within the same country, enter a new city or zip code into the search bar.

Learn more about how to find a therapist

Is everyone in the Psychology Today Therapy Directory a licensed therapist?

The Psychology Today directory lists providers who offer legitimate mental health services to the public, including psychologists, psychiatrists, social workers, and counselors.

Many have been licensed by the country or state where they practice; providers whose license or primary credential has been verified by Psychology Today are signified by a “Verified” symbol. Some clinicians or organizations provide services for which their state or country does not offer licenses, such as pastoral counseling. They may be selectively included without the “Verified” seal.

What’s the difference between a psychologist, a therapist, and a counselor?

Therapists, psychologists, and counselors are all licensed mental health professionals. In the US, psychologists have earned a doctoral degree. The terms “therapist” and “counselor” are used somewhat interchangeably, but generally therapists offer longer-term, mental health care, while counselors offer shorter-term care that may focus on one domain, such as marriage, career, or academic challenges.

Clients should consider factors such as insurance coverage and their primary reason(s) for seeking therapy to determine the type of professional best suited to their needs. Someone struggling with mental health challenges such as depression or anxiety, for example, may wish to seek out a clinical psychologist or therapist, while someone navigating career obstacles or marital upheaval may benefit from seeing a counselor who can offer short-term, targeted support.

What type of therapy is right for me?

The type of therapy best suited to a particular individual depends on several factors, including their primary reason for seeking therapy, their preferred timeline (some therapy types last for a set number of sessions, while others are open-ended), and their personality and preferences—some may prefer a more structured approach. For many individuals, multiple types of therapy could provide a good fit.

How much does therapy cost?

The cost of therapy depends on a number of variables, including location and the therapist’s experience and training. On average, a therapy session in the United States could cost between $100 and $200 or more. If you have insurance, the expense of mental health care is typically lower, but it varies based on your insurance plan details and whether you choose an in-network or out-of-network mental healthcare provider.

What are more affordable or low cost therapy solutions?

Many therapists offer sliding scale payments, usually on a limited number of slots, which consists in an agreement between the therapist and a client to pay a reduced rate. Therapists who provide such arrangements often consider the client's income or ability to pay, but the extent of the discount is ultimately at the therapist's discretion. Furthermore, while group therapy may have different goals and benefits compared to individual therapy, it can be a more affordable solution to address certain types of issues.

Is online therapy cheaper than in-person therapy?

Many therapists charge the same amount for online therapy as they do for in-person therapy—though clients may still find this cost-effective if it cuts down on their transportation costs. Health insurance plans often offer equivalent coverage for online and in-person therapy; indeed, in many places, they are legally required to do so. Text-based or on-demand therapy apps may be cheaper than traditional one-on-one psychotherapy; however, the practice may be less effective and is not likely to be covered by insurance.

Is online therapy a good option?

Therapy conducted online can be just as effective as in-person therapy, as long as there is a strong alliance between the client and the therapist. To find a therapist who provides telehealth services to clients in your area, click “Online Therapy” on the directory homepage and search by your city or town or your zip code.

Are therapy sessions confidential?

Confidentiality is a crucial part of the therapeutic relationship. Therapists in the United States are bound by the regulations set out by the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA), which aims to protect sensitive health information. With very few exceptions, a therapist will only discuss their client with others when the client has given their written permission. The instances in which a therapist would be required to disclose personal information are: if a client poses a danger to themselves or others, if the therapist suspects the abuse of a child or an elderly or otherwise dependent adult, or if they are legally forced to by court order. These exceptions to the confidentiality agreement are usually discussed with a client before their first session.