Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC

Dr. Tonya Butler

Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC (she, her)

Verified by Psychology Today Verified by Psychology Today
2 Endorsed
223 Jersey St., Westfield, IN 46074
Let's Connect (463) 283-5487
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
You may be feeling anxious, stuck, or weighed down—and maybe you’ve already tried therapy or medication, only to leave feeling unheard, dismissed, or rushed. That experience can make it hard to trust the process or believe things could feel different. But you’re not asking for too much. You deserve care that takes time, listens closely, and treats you as a whole person. What you want is care that feels thoughtful, human, and genuinely invested in your well-being.
I provide medication management and strengths-based therapy for adults carrying anxiety, depression, trauma, or other mental health challenges. My goal is to offer care that slows down, listens fully, and helps you find steadiness and clarity. Together, we’ll create a supportive plan that feels human, compassionate, and truly connected to your life.
Reaching out for help isn’t easy, especially if past care left you feeling unseen. At Butler Behavioral, you’ll find respect, compassion, and strategies to restore steadiness and clarity. If you’re ready for care that feels more human, schedule today at my website listed to the right. I look forward to working together!
Take the first step to help. Call or Dr. Tonya Butler now - (463) 283-5487

My Practice at a Glance

Available both in-person and online

Butler Behavioral

223 Jersey St.

Westfield, IN 46074 map

(463) 283-5487

Zionsville, IN 46077

See me in person in Westfield, IN or meet online through telehealth. I offer sessions Monday through Friday with flexible scheduling.
I specialize in Veterans, Mood Disorders and LGBTQ+ 
Initial Session Fee $275, Standard Visit $150, I accept insurance 
Individual one-on-one therapy 
Let's Connect (463) 283-5487
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC

My Practice at a Glance

Available both in-person and online

Butler Behavioral

223 Jersey St.

Westfield, IN 46074 map

(463) 283-5487

Zionsville, IN 46077

See me in person in Westfield, IN or meet online through telehealth. I offer sessions Monday through Friday with flexible scheduling.
I specialize in Veterans, Mood Disorders and LGBTQ+ 
Initial Session Fee $275, Standard Visit $150, I accept insurance 
Individual one-on-one therapy 

Finances

Fees

  • Initial Session Fee $275
  • Standard Visit $150

Payment Methods

American Express, Discover, Health Savings Account, Mastercard, Visa

Insurance

  • Anthem
  • BlueCross and BlueShield
  • TRICARE
  • Out of Network
"
I am in network with Anthem BCBS of Indiana and Tricare. I can provide superbills and assist with out-of-network reimbursement. Please reach out with any questions; we're happy to work with you to keep access to psychiatric medications affordable.
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
or call with questions - (463) 283-5487
"
I am in network with Anthem BCBS of Indiana and Tricare. I can provide superbills and assist with out-of-network reimbursement. Please reach out with any questions; we're happy to work with you to keep access to psychiatric medications affordable.
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
or call with questions - (463) 283-5487

Qualifications

  • Verified by Psychology Today License: Indiana / 71009150A Tonya Butler
  • Education and Years In Practice

  • In Practice for 7 years
  • University of Utah, Doctor of Nursing Practice, Psychiatric/MH, Graduated 2019
  • Additional Credentials

  • Membership with American Psychiatric Nurses Association 2019
  • Certificate from American Nurses Credentialing Center 2024
"
Feel free to ask questions about my qualifications and training experience. Email or call (317) 207-6387.
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
or call with questions - (463) 283-5487
"
Feel free to ask questions about my qualifications and training experience. Email or call (317) 207-6387.
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
or call with questions - (463) 283-5487

Specialties and Expertise

Top Specialties

  • Veterans
  • Mood Disorders
  • LGBTQ+

Expertise

  • Anger Management
  • Anxiety
  • Bipolar Disorder
  • Coping Skills
  • Depression
  • Eating Disorders
  • Grief
  • Medication Management
  • Obsessive-Compulsive (OCD)
  • Psychosis
  • Self Esteem
  • Self-Harming
  • Sleep or Insomnia
  • Stress
  • Suicidal Ideation
  • Transgender
  • Trauma and PTSD
  • Veterans
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Do these issues align with your needs? or (463) 283-5487
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Do these issues align with your needs? or (463) 283-5487

2 Endorsements

Andrew Walker
Andrew Walker
Psychiatric Nurse PractitionerDNPAPRNPMHNP
When I think about Tonya, the first thing that comes to mind is, "Tonya really cares." She cares deeply about her patients and their wellbeing, and she cares about staying up to date on the most current research and treatments. You can trust her.
Veronica Malia Counseling
Veronica Malia Counseling
Licensed Mental Health CounselorMALMHC
Dr. Tonya Butler is as knowledgeable as she is compassionate. It is evident she cares for each of her client's holistic well-being and brings her expertise to help them reach their goals.

Client Focus

Age

Teen
Adults

Participants

Individuals

Communities

Gay Allied
Non-Binary Allied
Queer Allied
Sex Worker Allied
Transgender Allied

Age

Teen
Adults

Participants

Individuals

Communities

Gay Allied
Non-Binary Allied
Queer Allied
Sex Worker Allied
Transgender Allied

Treatment Approach

Types of Therapy

  • Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I)
  • Motivational Interviewing
  • Solution Focused Brief (SFBT)
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Ask about what different forms of therapy will be like. or (463) 283-5487
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Ask about what different forms of therapy will be like. or (463) 283-5487

Location

Primary Location

Butler Behavioral

223 Jersey St.

Westfield, IN 46074

(463) 283-5487

Additional Location

Zionsville, IN 46077

(463) 283-5487
"
See me in person in Westfield, IN or meet online through telehealth. I offer sessions Monday through Friday with flexible scheduling.
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Take the first step to help. Call now - (463) 283-5487
"
See me in person in Westfield, IN or meet online through telehealth. I offer sessions Monday through Friday with flexible scheduling.
Photo of Dr. Tonya Butler, Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Dr. Tonya Butler
Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner, DNP, PMHNP, -BC
Take the first step to help. Call now - (463) 283-5487