Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Email Me

(973) 975-4352 Call Me

Email Me

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Verified by Psychology Today Verified by Psychology Today

3 Endorsed

28 Valley Road, Montclair, NJ 07042

Call Me

Available both in-person and online

28 Valley Road Montclair, NJ 07042

My website

Let's Connect (973) 975-4352

Does this sound familiar? You’re a high-performing professional, yet relentless anxiety and a harsh inner critic leave you feeling like an imposter. Or you’re the smart, creative type—told you have endless potential—yet unfinished projects and spiraling shame keep you stuck. Or maybe you’re a young adult trying to find your place in an unpredictable world, with your phone as your main source of comfort. TikTok says you have ADHD—maybe even autism—but deep down, you’re still not sure what fits.

I’m Dr. Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja, MD, a board-certified psychiatrist & psychotherapist with 10 years’ experience helping adults and older teens untangle anxiety, depression, ADHD, and autistic-spectrum challenges. Together, we'll build an individualized plan that may include medication, talk therapy, lifestyle coaching, and evidence-based complementary tools.

Life may feel overwhelming now, but change is possible. If you’re ready to quiet the critic, lift the fog, and move forward with confidence, let’s talk. Email me today to schedule a free 15-minute consultation and see if we’re a good fit.

Call or Email Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja now for a free 15 minute consultation - (973) 975-4352

My Practice at a Glance

Available both in-person and online

Integrative Psychiatric Services

28 Valley Road

Montclair, NJ 07042 map

(973) 975-4352

My website

Accepting new patients throughout New Jersey and Pennsylvania for tele-health visits. In person visits available in Montclair, NJ.

I specialize in Anxiety, Depression and ADHD

Initial Session Fee $650, Standard Visit $350

Individual one-on-one therapy

I understand your desire to feel better fast and I'm here to help.

Let's Connect (973) 975-4352

My Practice at a Glance

Available both in-person and online

Integrative Psychiatric Services

28 Valley Road

Montclair, NJ 07042 map

(973) 975-4352

My website

Accepting new patients throughout New Jersey and Pennsylvania for tele-health visits. In person visits available in Montclair, NJ.

I specialize in Anxiety, Depression and ADHD

Initial Session Fee $650, Standard Visit $350

Individual one-on-one therapy

I understand your desire to feel better fast and I'm here to help.

Finances

Fees

Initial Session Fee $650
Standard Visit $350

Payment Methods

American Express, Discover, Health Savings Account, Mastercard, Visa

Insurance

Out of Network

I'm out-of-network in order to provide you with the highest quality care.

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (973) 975-4352

I'm out-of-network in order to provide you with the highest quality care.

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (973) 975-4352

Qualifications

Verified by Psychology Today License: New Jersey / 25MA09835100 Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Education and Years In Practice

In Practice for 11 years

Additional Credentials

Board Certification by American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology

Degree/Diploma from SUNY Downstate Psychiatry Residency / 2015

A psychiatrist is a trained medical doctor and a skilled therapist who can offer you the full range of tools to make deep, lasting changes.

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (973) 975-4352

A psychiatrist is a trained medical doctor and a skilled therapist who can offer you the full range of tools to make deep, lasting changes.

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (973) 975-4352

Specialties and Expertise

Top Specialties

Anxiety
Depression
ADHD

Expertise

Asperger's Syndrome
Autism
Bipolar Disorder
Borderline Personality (BPD)
Integrative Psychiatry
Medication Management
Mood Disorders
Obsessive-Compulsive (OCD)
Screening for frequently missed diagnoses
Sleep or Insomnia
Testing and Evaluation
Trauma and PTSD

Our first meeting will be a free 15 minute consultation via tele-health. We can usually set this up within a week. Tell me your concerns and I'll let you know how I can help. If we're a good fit, we'll schedule your intake and get you on the path to feeling better as soon as possible.

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (973) 975-4352

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (973) 975-4352

3 Endorsements

Terri DiMatteo

Licensed Professional Counselor, MA, LPC

Sarah is a kind, knowledgeable, and experienced psychiatrist who helps her patients achieve confidence, competence, and success. She does this through personalized treatment plans, modern medicine and talk therapy.

Jyothsna Karlapalem

Psychiatrist, MD, CCTP II, NCTTP

Dr. Fajgenbaum is a wonderful psychiatrist who has a great skillset for medication management & psychotherapy. She is warm, compassionate and has a practical no nonsense approach that helps her clients get all the way better. I recommend her highly!

Amy Rae Johnson

Clinical Social Work/Therapist, MSW, LCSW

Sarah is a heart centered provider who is understanding, compassionate, and willing to take time and listen to client concerns. Sarah's expertise in how women present with ADHD as well as her gentle approach is what sets her apart from other psychiatrists.

Client Focus

Age

Teen ,

Adults

Participants

Individuals

Age

Teen ,

Adults

Participants

Individuals

Treatment Approach

Types of Therapy

Integrative
Lifestyle Coaching
Psychodynamic
Supportive Psychotherapy
Trauma Focused

Our second meeting will consist of an intake. We'll explore your unique genetics, health history and lifestyle as well as your life experiences, and thinking patterns to provide complete and accurate diagnoses and formulate an individualized treatment plan that works for you. Your treatment plan may include a combination of medication, talk therapy & lifestyle coaching.

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (973) 975-4352

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call or Email me for a free 15 minute consultation now - (973) 975-4352

Location

Primary Location

Integrative Psychiatric Services

28 Valley Road

Montclair, NJ 07042

(973) 975-4352

Email Me

My website

Nearby Areas

Cities

Counties

Zips

Accepting new patients throughout New Jersey and Pennsylvania for tele-health visits. In person visits available in Montclair, NJ.

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call for a free consultation now - (973) 975-4352

Accepting new patients throughout New Jersey and Pennsylvania for tele-health visits. In person visits available in Montclair, NJ.

Sarah Fajgenbaum-Teslja

Psychiatrist, MD

Call for a free consultation now - (973) 975-4352

Report an issue