The Impact of Athletic Success: Navigating the Long Game

Performance under pressure is front and center in the life of an athlete. Competitive drive, intrinsic motivation, and a goal-oriented focus are considered positive attributes for athletic success. Much has been written about the manifestations of performance pressures on athletes in individual and team sports. Research shows that long-term exposure to perceived stressors interferes with the ability to cope and psychological well-being (Andersson et al., 2025). A comprehensive review and meta-analysis from 2024 revealed that the prevalence of depressive symptoms and anxiety in athletes is twice that of the general population (Khan et al., 2026). While these findings are not surprising, it’s deeply concerning as athletes continue to grapple with this dilemma in the elite sports environment.

Perfectionistic tendencies in athletes are tied to high performance expectations and intense levels of self-criticism. While striving for perfection may have a positive influence on goal-setting and performance, excessive worries about making mistakes or a fear of failure can negatively impact performance and create goal avoidance. This can lead to competitive anxiety, overtraining, and psychological fatigue (Dai et al., 2026). Elite athletes are trained to prioritize their performance over other aspects of their lives, including their health. This remains a conundrum as athletes are expected to simultaneously safeguard and risk their health to attain optimal performance outcomes (Nuetzel, 2025). When athletes reach the top of their game, the stressors continue to mount from performance-related demands, coaches, sponsors, the media, and the general sports community.

Source: Jakub Klucký / Unsplash

The level of scrutiny is extreme with the increasing visibility of athletes, and this is exacerbated by hateful or threatening comments on social media. The International Skating Union (ISU) recognizes that online abuse is one of the most pervasive problems confronting professional athletes today. This prompted them to make digital safety a critical area of focus to promote the well-being of athletes in their Vision 2030 initiative (International Skating Union, 2026). Social media platforms may also increase vulnerability to stress, anxiety, and body image dissatisfaction (Tooth et al., 2026), constituting an additional challenge to athletes who are already dealing with heightened pressures to perform at their peak potential.

A delicate balance exists between attaining and maintaining the standards of elite athletic status. From this perspective, there’s no guarantee that an athlete’s inherent traits, talents, or work ethic will sustain their degree of success over time. The glitz and glamour of achievement is intoxicating for athletes when they win Olympic medals, elite competitions, Grand Slams, World Series, Super Bowls, etc. The rewards of fulfilling their lifelong dreams are indescribable and immeasurable. Along with this, however, comes the tremendous responsibility of upholding their ranking and stature over the long haul. Trying to remain the front-runner can be a heavy burden that elevates competition and expectations. The ability to sustain this type of chronic stress inevitably takes its toll in the form of physical injury, emotional exhaustion, disordered eating, burnout, and/or loss of passion for their sport. In the current climate, many athletes are pushing themselves to the limit to remain in their sport as long as possible. This involves even more wear and tear on the body and a powerful mindset. Navigating the highs and lows of competitive athletics necessitates extraordinary strength, perseverance, and mental fortitude. We may take these daily challenges for granted and expect flawlessness from the athletes we work with or admire as role models.

Developing an identity outside of being an athlete is optimal for mitigating some of the constant stressors. A well-rounded perspective is essential for managing setbacks and cultivating interests and relationships outside of athletics. The assistance of sport psychologists, mental performance coaches, trainers, and other qualified professionals is recommended for elite athletes. In the setting of wellness coaching, there are numerous strategies designed to enhance performance, including meditation, goal-setting, breathing techniques, grounding exercises, visualization, and self-talk reframing. These interventions are beneficial for many athletes, but often require trial and error to find what works best for each individual. Nonetheless, this may not resolve all the underlying issues that athletes face.

Source: Renith R / Unsplash

It’s not always easy to discern whether a struggle with a specific skill or technique is predominantly mental or physical, since the mind and body are so closely connected. What starts out as a mechanical issue may become a mental block that further hinders proper execution. Performance anxiety and self-doubt may surface at any time, even for seasoned professionals. It’s imperative to treat athletes as human beings first and acknowledge the courage it takes to persist on the long journey. As I’m watching the Wimbledon championships, I’m reminded of Billie Jean King’s famous quote: “Pressure is a privilege, and champions adjust.” This rings true to some extent, but at what cost are athletes expected to internalize this message?