Do People Think You're Pushy, or a Pushover?

Source: MaleWitch/Shutterstock

While you're likely to be able to identify “the jerk” and “the pushover” in almost any group, there's a good chance you struggle to recognize which title best suits you. Perhaps you assume you have a reputation as being “tough,” or maybe you think you're the “the nice guy,” but there’s evidence that your assumptions about what others think of you are likely wrong.

According to a study published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, most people fail to recognize whether they’re behaving too aggressively or too passively in the eyes of others. The study paired people for mock negotiations. After each deal was made, participants answered questions about their own levels of assertiveness, and their partner’s. They were also asked to judge how their partner likely perceived them.

The results revealed that 57% of people who were deemed to be under-assertive thought they had come across as appropriately assertive, or even over-assertive. Meanwhile, 56% of people who were seen as over-assertive thought they had come across as appropriately assertive or even under-assertive.

People who thought they had “crossed the line” into being too pushy often tried to repair the relationship. As a result, they eventually accepted less lucrative deals. They were unaware that they didn’t need to fix the relationship “problem” because the other person didn’t even recognize that a problem existed in the first place.

The Consequences of Limited Self-Awareness

Whether you're asking your boss for a raise, or talking to your partner about where to spend the holidays, effective negotiating skills are important. Limited self-awareness about when you're being too pushy, and when you're not speaking up enough, can wreak havoc on your relationships.

A lack of self-awareness can interfere with your ability to reach your personal and professional goals. If people perceive you as a jerk, they’ll be less interested in negotiating with you. But if you’re perceived as a pushover, others are more likely to try taking advantage of you. Ultimately, your intended message doesn't matter. What matters is how people receive it. If you thought you were being kind but others perceived you as a jerk, your message will be lost.

Increase Your Self-Awareness

Assertiveness is a skill that can be learned. But like all skills, it takes practice to master speaking up for yourself in an appropriate manner.

Keep in mind that just because you got what you want doesn't mean you were appropriately assertive. Hostile or aggressive behavior often gets people what they want in the short-term, but damages long-term relationships.

Be open to asking for feedback from others. After a negotiation, ask the other person for reactions. Friends and family, and trusted co-workers, may be willing to offer honest advice. Soliciting feedback is a good way to gain insight into how others see you.

Amy Morin is a psychotherapist, keynote speaker and author of 13 Things Mentally Strong People Don't Do, a bestselling book that is being translated into more than 20 languages. To learn more about the story behind her book, watch the book trailer below.