Weighing the Evidence

Memory and the mind in the criminal justice system

Neil Brewer Ph.D.

How Evidence Can Be Trumped by a Suspect's Atypical Behavior

Individuals who sometimes behave atypically—such as those with autism—can be treated harshly by the criminal justice system.

How to Conduct Police Lineups

Sadly, police lineups often produce errors, most of which have disastrous consequences. A recent policy paper provides guidelines from experts on minimizing those errors.

Being Innocent Is Not Always Enough

Why autistic adults may become prime suspects in police investigations.

Let’s Get Rid of Police Lineups

The problems with police lineups have been well documented. Let’s accept that they are not fit for purpose and try something else that is.

Autistic Adults' Interactions with the Justice System

Deficits in perspective-taking—or theory of mind—are considered to be hallmarks of Autism Spectrum Disorder. Could they lead to an elevated risk of criminal behavior?

Can We Tell If a Witness Picks an Innocent Suspect?

When people witness a crime, they might be asked by the police to view a lineup. If they pick someone, how do we know if it’s the culprit or an innocent suspect?