The Art of Refusal

The transition into a new year often comes with pressure to radiate optimism and new year, new you energy. Social feeds and cultural narratives often suggest that our future success depends on our current enthusiasm and positive thinking.

Yet for many of us, this season feels anything but light. Reflecting on a year marked by personal struggles, societal divisions, and vast uncertainties, anxiety and despair might rise to the surface. These emotions often reveal a deep concern for our communities and futures.

But in a culture that equates progress with positivity, the pressure to suppress such emotions and perform a cheery outlook can not only diminish our humanity but keep us from reaching our goals.

Contrary to popular belief, our challenging emotions are not obstacles to envisioning new futures or creating change. They may be the key to unlocking them.

Creativity Is Rooted in Refusal

Over years of researching creativity and health, I’ve come to refer to challenging emotions as evidence or sites of refusal—the first step in the creative process.

Research shows that emotions serve important adaptive functions. They act as messengers: alerting us to problems, motivating us to act, and helping us recognize when change is needed. Challenging emotions often signal our refusal to leave circumstances as they are or to accept them as fated or fixed.

Though refusal often emerges in moments of difficulty and vulnerability, it’s a crucial step in healing and transformation—and it lies at the heart of creativity and innovation. If we want to create a bold vision and honor our well-being, we must reframe our assumptions. Creativity and change may draw upon hustle and optimism—but they are rooted in refusal.

The Role of Refusal

This may feel counterintuitive. After all, we’re regularly encouraged to “think positive” and accept our circumstances as part of healing. As writer and civil rights activist James Baldwin reminds us: "Not everything that is faced can be changed, but nothing can be changed until it is faced."

But Baldwin also said, “The world is before you, and you need not take it or leave it as it was when you came in.” Facing reality doesn’t mean approving of it. It means recognizing it for what it is, so we can decide how to respond. The seeds of creative change lie in that decision.

Once we’ve seen reality clearly, we can refuse to leave it as it is. In this sense, refusal is what ignites healing and change. It’s what generates creativity.

Put simply, creativity begins with refusal.

The Role of Refusal in Art and Creativity

Artists have long demonstrated this. At the most basic level, to play a song is to refuse the silence or sound that would have existed without it. To paint, to dance, to compose, to perform: These are acts of creation, but they are also acts of refusal.

The artist refuses to believe that everything is fine as it is. They refuse to believe that a change wouldn’t be better. They refuse to believe they can’t be part of initiating that change. As a result, they create. They change what is into something else.

In short, every creative act begins with a refusal to leave the world as it is. Creativity begins with saying "no" to how things are so that we can imagine something else. Far from being an end, this emphatic “no” is a vital first step toward change.

Notably, refusal is not just for artists. We all encounter moments when we recognize something that isn't clear, right, or as it “should” be, and we refuse to leave it as it is.

These moments of refusal may be on the lighter side, such as the hope we might feel in turning a plain wall into a vibrant mural, or a stale idea into a scalable product.

But refusal can also be heavy. It may show up as grief when a relationship ends, or despair when a job offer falls through. It can surface as discomfort at a colleague’s inappropriate comment, or rage at systemic injustices.

There are innumerable forms and causes of refusal, each revealing a gap between what is and what should be. This gap is what compels us to imagine and create something new.

Why It Matters

Why does this matter? To be clear, noticing refusal’s role in healing isn’t about finding a silver lining in suffering. The fact that challenge and uncertainty can lead to creative change doesn’t make them any less difficult, nor should it make suffering seem welcome. It certainly doesn’t justify harm or excuse our failure to prevent it. So what does it do?

By framing challenging emotions as evidence of refusal, we locate ourselves at the beginning of a creative process. This perspective doesn’t change our situations or erase our emotions, but it shifts the context in which we experience and process them.

It's a form of cognitive reappraisal that positions us as agents who can create and move forward. Research suggests that reframing challenges while recognizing our capacity to influence outcomes can reduce emotional distress and foster resilience.

Recognizing refusal’s role in the creative process isn’t about avoiding reality; it’s about confronting it more fully. It helps us see a critical truth: difficulty is not always or inevitably an end. Challenging emotions can function as a beginning: illuminating gaps and stimulating change.

When we can hold our present pain with compassion, and when we can see it as evidence of our ability to imagine and enact change, we find new ways to metabolize and contextualize our struggle.

Embracing Refusal: A 5-Step Process for Change

Reframing challenging situations as sites of refusal is a deeply personal and individual process. This perspective shift won’t look the same for everyone, but the 5 steps below offer a practical framework for exploring and embracing refusal:

1. Honor and investigate your emotions. Begin by acknowledging your feelings without pressuring yourself to “move past” them. Then get curious about what your emotions might be telling you, from obvious to nuanced “messages.” Consider:

• What am I feeling? Why?
• What am I refusing to accept?
• What do I wish were different—not just about my feelings but about the root causes behind them?
• What vision of the world are my emotions pointing to?

Remember: What we refuse often reveals what we value.

2. Imagine alternatives. Brainstorm alternatives to your current reality. What could or should exist instead? Be descriptive, creative, and uncensored. This step isn’t about being reasonable or polished—it’s about exploring the aims or visions your emotions are pointing toward.

3. Find actionable ideas. Review your imagined alternatives and identify any concrete steps or ideas they suggest. Even “unreasonable” imaginings hint at real-world needs, actions, or possibilities. List as many as you can, whether they involve personal or collective effort. Reflect on questions like:

• What surprises me about these ideas?
• How do they connect with my other values and goals?
• Has this process shifted my emotions or perspective?

4. Share. Share your reflections with others—friends, colleagues, or interest groups. Finding people who share your values can help sustain both your refusal and your vision of what could be instead. The sharing process can also support social connection, which has its own well-being benefits.

5. Take action. Start with small, manageable steps. Even small actions can build confidence and creativity, and move the needle of change.

Wrapping Up

In this season of transition, there may be many reasons to grieve, worry, rage, fear, and fight. To refuse reality as it currently is. And while this refusal may feel heavy, it’s not a block to positive change. It’s a core component of hope and imagination.

When we reframe challenging emotions as refusal, we recognize them as adaptive responses—signaling not just what we resist, but what we value and envision. This reframe doesn’t erase suffering; instead, it places us at the beginning of a creative process that clarifies our vision and, in time, helps us move forward.

The world needs our refusal: our resistance to what Is, and our collective vision for what could be instead. Creative change begins with a refusal to “take or leave the world as it was when [we] came in.” Far from hindering our goals, refusal helps us shape and enact them. From works of art to collective growth to personal transformation, refusal has always been at the (broken) heart of leadership, of change, and of hope.

Facebook image: DC Studio/Shutterstock

LinkedIn image: PeopleImages.com - Yuri A/Shutterstock