Skip to main content
Sex

How Ordinary Things Become Sexual Fetishes

Pavlov’s dogs, a pair of boots, and three surprising first experiences.

Key points

  • In classical conditioning, a neutral stimulus becomes linked with a bodily response through repeated pairing.
  • Classical conditioning is an essential component of how fetishes develop.
  • One stimulating experience during a critical stage in sexual development can be enough to create a fetish.

One day in the 1890s, the Russian scientist Ivan Pavlov rang a bell to call his dogs for dinner—I like to imagine that this was standard for 19th-century dog owners, those classy rascals—and noticed that they had drenched themselves in their own slobber. He was about to roll his eyes with playful indignation when he realized that he hadn’t even brought the food out yet! If not the smell of the food, what were they slobbering over? He ran some tests. Turns out, it was the bell. More tests, and he found out that they would slobber over anything at all that fell into one of two categories: (a) food and (b) once-random things that they had come to associate with food. This doesn’t sound mind-blowing at first, but it is. Pats on the head, flicks to the ear, a song, a “Woop Woop Time to Eat”—repeatedly pair anything with food, and that thing will eventually be able to make dogs slobber, no food needed.

How Classical Conditioning Works

As you may have already gathered, this phenomenon also applies to people in a big way. In fact, this pervasive psychological principle explains why the smell of coffee wakes you up, why the Netflix “duh-DUN” sound triggers instant relaxation, and why you can’t hang around with guys named Jim no more. Classical conditioning works like this: A neutral stimulus (like a sound, smell, or sight) becomes associated with a bodily response through repeated pairing with a significant event. After enough pairings, your brain starts reacting to the neutral stimulus as though it were the significant event.

So, for example, your phone ding triggers excitement because in the past it has been paired with sexy texts from cute boys or loving texts from your friends. Your body has a positive emotional reaction based on what has come after that sound in the past. For those overworked souls who use their phones primarily for professional purposes, that same neutral ding might precipitate abject dread. The ding is neither your boss nor that hot dude; it’s just a ding. Your brain, though, associates them so closely that your body reacts in the same way to the ding that it would to the real message from that potent person.

Classical conditioning is an essential component of how fetishes develop. In the 1960s, a few inspired researchers paired classical conditioning with sexiness. In one experiment, heterosexual male participants were first shown an image of boots, which—I’m here to report—are not very sexy for most people.¹ Immediately after seeing the boots, they were shown images of naked women, which, naturally, perked them right up. After enough pairings, the boots alone began to elicit sexual arousal. The participants’ brains had linked the sight of boots with the feeling of arousal that accompanied the naked women. After enough pairings, the boots elicited a similar level of sexual response to the naked women! A nice pair of boobs—boots—was all these fine gentlemen now needed to get excited. Even weeks later, the boot-boob pairing had lessened but had not disappeared. Another study found the same results with pennies, showing that almost anything can become sexualized when it’s paired with breasts—even something as mundane and unsexy as pennies. (Dollar bills, this researcher acknowledges, are a different story.)²

Fetish Development

Many of the wonderful humans who are my clients talk about their fetishes as having sprung from a childhood experience that paired intense sexuality with something random. We refer to this phenomenon as sexual conditioning. Although sexual conditioning often develops after several pairings, if someone has a particularly stimulating experience during a critical stage in sexual development, one incident can be enough to create a fetish.

For example, a survey respondent with a foot fetish shared, “There was a girl who lived down the road from me—she was a bit older—and she would always walk around barefoot when we hung out. One day while we were hanging out at her house, she started rubbing her feet on my penis under the covers. It was then I knew I loved women’s feet.” Nothing like a good rubdown to forever link feet with pleasure.

Coincidences are the lifeblood of sexual conditioning, as unexpected encounters coming at just the right moment can forever fuse just about anything with sexual arousal. One woman, let’s call her Katie, who filled out my fetish survey said, “I think it was just a coincidence that my first exposure to anything related to a penis was a video of a guy peeing, and that made me associate the two and develop a fetish for it.” Another classic example of sexual conditioning came from a respondent, let’s call him Matt, with a fulsome and satisfying latex fetish: “I remember being a teenager and seeing a condom machine in a gas station bathroom. They were fifty cents at the time. I got one, thinking if I wore it, then I would know what sex felt like. That was not exactly the case, but I did develop a massive fetish for latex.” Classical conditioning lends the weight of science to the old adage that we all know to be true: You never forget your first time.

advertisement
More from Niki Davis-Fainbloom MA
More from Psychology Today