Why Self-Compassion May Be the Antidote to Narcissism
Research finds major benefits to treating yourself kindly, in good times or bad.
Posted June 26, 2011
The great angst of modern life is this: No matter how hard we try, no matter how successful we are, no matter how good a parent, worker, or spouse—it's never enough. There is always someone richer, thinner, smarter, or more powerful; someone that makes us feel small in comparison. Failure of any kind, large or small, is unacceptable to us. The result: Therapist's offices, pharmaceutical companies, and the self-help aisles of bookstores are besieged by people who feel they're not okay as they are.
What to do?
One response has come from the self-esteem movement. Over the years, there have been literally thousands of books and magazine articles promoting self-esteem—how to get it, raise it, and keep it. The pursuit of higher self-esteem has become a virtual religion, but research indicates this has also come with some serious downsides. Our culture has become so competitive that we need to feel special and above average to just to feel okay about ourselves—being called "average" is now an insult.
Many of us, therefore, feel compelled to create what psychologists call a "self-enhancement bias"—puffing ourselves up and putting others down so that we can feel superior. However, this constant need to feel better than our fellow human beings leads to a sense of isolation and separation. And once you've achieved high self-esteem, how do you keep it? It's an emotional roller-coaster ride: Our sense of self-worth bounces around like a Ping-Pong ball, rising and falling in lockstep with our latest success or failure.
One of the most insidious consequences of the self-esteem movement of the last couple of decades is the narcissism epidemic. Jean Twenge, author of Generation Me, examined the narcissism levels of more than 15,000 U.S. college students between 1987 and 2006. During that 20-year period, narcissism scores went through the roof, with 65 percent of modern-day students scoring higher in narcissism than previous generations. Not coincidentally, students' average self-esteem levels rose by an even greater margin over the same period. Self-esteem has also been linked to aggression, prejudice, and anger towards those who threaten our sense of self-worth. For example, some kids build up their egos by beating up other kids in the playground.
It's hardly healthy.
Of course, we don't want to suffer from low self-esteem either, so what's the alternative? There is another way to feel good about ourselves—self-compassion. Self-compassion involves being kind to ourselves when life goes awry or we notice something about ourselves we don't like, rather than being cold or harshly self-critical. It recognizes that the human condition is imperfect, so that we feel connected to others when we fail or suffer rather than feeling separate or isolated. It also involves mindfulness—the recognition and non-judgmental acceptance of painful emotions as they arise in the moment. Rather than suppressing our pain or making it into a personal soap opera, we see our situation, and ourselves, clearly.
It's important to distinguish self-compassion from self-esteem: Self-esteem refers to the degree to which we evaluate ourselves positively. It represents how much we like or value ourselves, and is often based on comparisons with others. In contrast, self-compassion is not based on positive judgments or evaluations; it is a way of relating to ourselves. People feel self-compassion because they are human, not because they are special or above average. It emphasizes interconnection rather than separateness. With self-compassion, you don't have to feel better than others to feel good about yourself. It also offers more emotional stability than self-esteem because it is always there for you—when you're on top of the world, and when you fall flat on your face.
Research indicates that self-compassion offers the same benefits as self-esteem—less depression, greater happiness, etc.—without the downsides. In a large survey conducted with more than 3,000 people from various walks of life, researchers found that self-compassion was associated with more stable feelings of self-worth (assessed 12 different times over an eight-month period) than self-esteem. This may be related to the fact that they also found self-compassion to be less contingent on things like physical attractiveness or successful performances than self-esteem. Also, self-esteem had a strong association with narcissism while self-compassion had no association with narcissism.
Another study asked people to recall a previous failure, rejection, or loss that made them feel badly about themselves. Researchers asked one group of participants to think about the event in ways that increased their self-compassion, and another group to think about the situation in ways that protected or bolstered their self-esteem. People who received the self-compassion instruction reported less negative emotions when thinking about the past event than those in the self-esteem condition. Moreover, those in the self-compassion condition took more personal responsibility for the event than those in the self-esteem condition. This suggests that—unlike self-esteem—self-compassion does not lead to blaming others in order to feel good about oneself.
Instead of endlessly chasing self-esteem like a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow, I would argue that we should encourage the development of self-compassion. That way, whether we're on top of the world or at the bottom of the heap, we can embrace ourselves with kindness, connectedness, and emotional balance. We can provide the emotional safety needed to see ourselves clearly and make whatever changes are necessary to address our suffering. We can learn to feel good about ourselves, not because we're special and above average, but because we're human beings intrinsically worthy of respect.
To test your own self-compassion level, read more about self-esteem, find videos, guided meditations, and exercises, go to self-compassion.org. You can also read more in my book Self-Compassion: Stop Beating Yourself Up and Leave Insecurity Behind.