Community: The Missing Piece of Well-Being

I was recently listening to The Mel Robbins Podcast when former Harvard professor and researcher Todd Rose shared something that stopped me mid-listen: “Across every demographic, one of the top 10 priorities for a meaningful life is being more engaged in your community—yet it is also the one people achieve the least.”

I believe this sentence captures a paradox of the world we live in. Many of us crave a sense of connection and purpose. We want to belong to something meaningful, to give back, and to make a difference in the places where we live. However, despite being constantly plugged in, the kind of community that nourishes us can still feel distant and hard to reach. We scroll through updates, share our opinions, and stay digitally visible, but the kind of closeness that once grounded us in conversation, collaboration, and care has become harder to find.

Rose, co-founder of the think tank Populace, has analyzed one of the most extensive datasets ever collected on what people truly value—not what they post publicly, but what they admit privately, when they are telling the truth. His findings are both humbling and hopeful: We are far more alike than we think. Most of us crave purpose, contribution, growth, and authentic relationships.

Those are not individualistic goals; they are relational ones. They reveal a shared yearning for mattering—the feeling that others value us and that we add value in return (Prilleltensky, 2020).

The Everyday Spaces We Have Lost

Rose mentions that we have lost the “civic layer”—the everyday spaces where people once connected, collaborated, and cared for one another. Over time, that layer has thinned.

The decline of local clubs, places of worship, and neighborhood groups has left many people isolated and unsure where they fit. What we lost was not just social infrastructure, but also psychological nourishment—the sense of purpose that comes from contribution.

The erosion of civic life not only affects our social ties; it shapes our psychological landscape. When people lose the chance to participate in meaningful community roles, they also lose daily opportunities to feel that they matter. This gap between connection and contribution can quietly erode motivation, hope, and mental health.

Research supports this. In a 2021 study at Wilfrid Laurier University, E. Weatherhead found that students who participated in Community Service Learning (hands-on community placements integrated into coursework) experienced lower stress, stronger mental health, and a more profound sense of mattering than their peers who did not. Service learning did not just teach; it actually helped heal.

How Helping Others Helps Us

The same pattern appears across different age groups. A study by Daniels & Perkins (2007) examined how youth volunteers in community health programs developed confidence, purpose, and a sense of belonging. By being treated not just as helpers but as partners in community change, these young people gained what the researchers called intentional environments for mattering—spaces that let them practice leadership and feel competent in their contributions.

For adults, the benefits are equally profound. Zachary Silverman’s 2024 research at Bowling Green State University found that people involved in community-based organizations, as either volunteers or employees, reported higher life satisfaction, stronger well-being, and a higher sense of mattering than those who were not engaged in these organizations. Interestingly, the more responsibility they held, and the closer their contact with others, the greater the benefits became.

Across all three studies, one truth stands out: Helping others helps us. We thrive when we feel useful.

The Power of Micro-Mattering

During their discussion, Robbins and Rose reflected on how genuine change often begins with small, everyday actions. They are simple steps that reconnect us with our values and the people around us. They described how small acts—whether speaking up in a meeting, participating in a community event, or choosing reflection over distraction—can create ripples that shift culture over time.

Relationships Essential Reads

Feeling Unheard? Here's How to  Bridge Gaps in Everyday Chats

2 Ways to Start Expressing Your Needs in Your Relationship

These small acts are what I think of as micro-mattering moments—everyday decisions that remind us of who we are and signal to others that they matter.

Research supports this idea. Mattering functions as a reciprocal loop: When we contribute, our sense of purpose grows; when we feel valued, we are more likely to keep giving (Prilleltensky, 2019). Every small gesture, whether it involves mentoring a student, checking in on a neighbor, helping new immigrants settle into their new home, or joining a local cleanup, helps rebuild that loop one interaction at a time. These actions may appear minor, yet they serve as the true building blocks of collective renewal.

From Self-Improvement to Collective Well-Being

Much of the messaging we hear now has trained us to focus inward on self-care, self-esteem, and self-optimization. However, as Rose’s data show, what truly fulfills us lies in the space between us. We do not need to fix ourselves before we can contribute; often, contributing helps us feel whole.

Community engagement is not charity; it is chemistry. When we participate in something larger than ourselves, we activate a feedback loop of well-being that self-improvement may not replicate. Research by Flett and colleagues (2019) shows that mattering protects against depression, loneliness, and burnout precisely because it anchors our identity in connection.

Five Ways to Rebuild the Civic Layer

If the civic layer is thinning, we can begin to rebuild it through intentional, everyday acts that strengthen belonging, purpose, and shared care. Psychologists often call these prosocial behaviors—actions that benefit others and, in turn, nourish our own sense of meaning.

Here are five evidence-informed ways to help restore community connection and collective well-being:

1. Volunteer where your strengths meet a need. Research on strengths-based volunteering shows that when people use their natural skills to help others, their engagement and satisfaction rise. Matching what you do well with what your community needs makes service sustainable.

2. Foster intergenerational connections. Many of our civic spaces are age-segregated. However, studies show that when youth and older adults collaborate, both groups experience increased empathy, purpose, and emotional well-being. Teaching, mentoring, or storytelling across generations keeps wisdom and energy circulating.

3. Practice micro-mattering. Notice the small openings for connection: a neighbor carrying groceries, a newcomer finding their way, a colleague working quietly in the background. Simple gestures of acknowledgment build invisible threads of trust.

4. Participate in shared decision-making. Community thrives when people feel they have a voice. Attending town halls, joining parent advisory committees, or contributing ideas to local initiatives restores agency and civic confidence.

5. Redefine success through contribution. Instead of measuring life by individual achievement, we can ask, Whose day was better because of my actions? This simple shift reorients well-being around shared impact rather than solitary accomplishment.

From Data to Hope

At the heart of Rose’s research is an optimistic truth: We are more alike than different.

Beneath the noise of division and distraction, most people want the same simple things: to love, to grow, to contribute, and to belong. Rebuilding the civic layer will not happen through grand gestures but through countless small ones. Each time we show up, volunteer, listen, or lead, we remind others—and ourselves—that we matter.