Skip to main content
Bullying

The Limited and Lopsided Vision of Bullying

Neuroscientists strive to see with a more balanced and holistic perspective.

Key points

  • Bullies harness the brain's left hemisphere that lacks care or empathy for others.
  • The narrow focus of the brain's left hemisphere cuts us off from a sense of connection to Others.
  • Using a two-eyed, dual brain-hemisphere approach expands our vision and insight.

Bullying done from one person to another parallels bullying done from one populace to another. Person-to-person abuse is the microcosm. Populace-to-populace bullying, as we see in colonialism where the settlers abused the Indigenous population, acts as a macrocosm. Settlers oppressing and harming Indigenous populations occurs in colonialism. All of these forms of bullying require a pronounced lack of empathy.

Bullying puts on blinders to Others' knowledge, experience, humanity, and personhood. It does not walk in the Other’s shoes, does not feel their pain, and does not see through their eyes. It is biased in favour of its own tunnel vision. In recent years, neuroscientists have begun to see the limits of this approach.

When we examine the bullying mindset while keeping brain science in mind, we can see that bullying—both micro and macro—compares to experiencing the world through only one brain hemisphere while ignoring data from the brain’s other hemisphere. It produces a lopsided, unbalanced, and limiting point of view, which is exactly what scientific studies strive to avoid.

Our left and right brain hemispheres are different

Psychiatrist Iain McGilchrist researches brain lateralization—the different ways in which our left and right brain hemispheres see and connect with Others and the world itself. As he describes it, our brains construct reality “from two incompatible world views.” The left is defined by narrow self-focus, whereas the right experiences profound connection with Others. The left is like an opportunist, while the right compares to an altruist.

In his book The Master and His Emissary, McGilchrist expresses concern with the normalizing of abuse culture where the left hemisphere dominates, creating an unhealthy, unsustainable world of callous exploitation. He explains that harmful behaviours may originate in damaged right-brain function:

"There is also a direct correlation between sadness and empathy, on the one hand, and feelings of guilt, shame and responsibility, on the other. Psychopaths who have no sense of guilt, shame or responsibility, have deficits in the right frontal lobe, particularly the right ventromedial and orbitofrontal cortex."

In contrast to the empathic and emotional deficits of the opportunist left hemisphere, McGilchrist characterizes the altruist right side of the brain as paying “attention to the Other, whatever it is that exists apart from ourselves, with which it sees itself in profound relation. It is deeply attracted to, and given life by, the relationship, the betweenness, that exists with this Other.” The single-minded focus of the bully gives way to a brain hemisphere that privileges connectivity with Otherness.

McGilchrist identifies the left brain’s “need to influence and manipulate,” which is an apt description of what bullies strive to accomplish. McGilchrist says the left’s focus is on “individual self-belief,” which forms a sharp contrast to the expansive bonding and empathy that occur via the right hemisphere. The left objectifies and exploits while the right connects and bonds.

Accessing the altruistic right hemisphere through Indigenous knowledge

Another way to characterize the division of the human brain is as the left hemisphere being correlated with a Western perspective, while the right hemisphere is correlated with an Indigenous viewpoint. The settlers escaped from scarcity, suffering, and trauma. Not to excuse it, but they appear to have harnessed the left-brain opportunist approach that McGilchrist sees as focused on “grasping, getting, and feeding.”

In contrast, the Indigenous peoples existed with abundance and experienced their world with a sense of deep connection. Their mindset, grounded in empathy and bonding for all living things—imbued with spirit—parallels the right hemisphere’s approach. The settlers were desperately focused on needs, while the Indigenous impacted by them were imbued with a sense of self as part of a rich natural whole. It was a tragic clash.

Neuroscientists are engaging with Indigenous knowledge

Melissa Perreault, a Métis professor in neuroscience, acknowledges that limiting brain research to left-sided Western methods “to the exclusion of others is a failure.” She is part of a group formed by the Canadian Brain Research Strategy that engages with Indigenous Knowledge holders who have research interests in the brain and mental health.

As outlined recently in an article in the Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences, when neuroscientists factor in Indigenous ways of experiencing reality, it sounds like they want to balance the left hemisphere’s Western view with the Indigenous right hemisphere’s connection to the world:

"Connectivity, which has emerged as an important theme in systems level neuroscience, actually builds upon Indigenous knowledge that everything in the universe is connected, whether it is the connection between ancestral spirits and the mortal world; the connection between the water, the land, and the animals that live there; and the connections between individuals and the environment."

Bullying, abusing, exploiting—whether from person to person or populace to populace—are the opposites of this right-brain connectivity that informs Indigenous culture. As McGilchrist states, “the left hemisphere view is designed to aid you in grabbing stuff. Its purpose is utility and its evolutionary adaptation lies in the service of grasping and massing ‘things.’” He associates this kind of impulse with the “decline of civilization.”

Replacing bullying’s cyclops with Two-Eyed Seeing

In Homer’s Odyssey, the cyclops is a one-eyed bully who traps Odysseus and his men with the goal of destroying and consuming them. It is a terrifying but accurate depiction of much colonialist harm done to Indigenous peoples. It is a mythical version of McGilchrist’s left-brain descriptor focused on “getting, grasping, and feeding.”

While McGilchrist worries about our Western, colonialist, bullying ways that he sees as the “unopposed action of a dysfunctional left hemisphere,” an international team of neuroscientists is opening up and listening to the right brain’s perspective as conveyed through Indigenous peoples and culture. It’s a hopeful antidote to today’s toxicity.

In the Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences, the new path forward is described as “Two-Eyed Seeing,” which is “a guiding principle that was conceived by Mi'kmaw Elder Albert Marshall in 2004.” Seeing with both eyes, like seeing via both brain hemispheres, is the opposite of the one-eyed cyclops’ bullying view. Its goal is an integration of “Indigenous and Western perspectives represented without domination or assimilation.”

References

Perreault, M., King, M., Gabel, C., et al. (2021). "An Indigenous Lens on Priorities for the Canadian Brain Research Strategy." Canadian Journal of Neurological Sciences.

McGilchrist, I. (2009). The Master and His Emissary. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

advertisement
More from Jennifer Fraser Ph.D.
More from Psychology Today