The Surprising Truth About Sleep Forensics
Though it remains too-little understood, sleep violence is a real danger.
Posted May 31, 2018
One of my guilty pleasures is CSI. I like them all, but NCIS (the military one with Mark Harmon) is my favorite. I always like to see how they use science to solve the mystery. To be 100 percent honest, I feel like a science-detective sometimes myself. It really can be a bit of a mystery trying to determine what is going on with my patients, and how to treat it. I was asked once to be an expert witness, but it’s not something I’ve done. I am fascinated by all aspects of sleep and sleep science—and one really fascinating, and relatively little-known, area of interest for me is sleep forensics.
What is sleep forensics? It’s the use of sleep medicine, science, and expertise in the investigation of violent, strange, and irrational behavior related to sleep—and crimes that may stem from these behaviors. Yep, there’s room for a sleep specialist character on your (or my) favorite crime procedural show.
Experts who work in the field of sleep forensic medicine make contributions to investigations and legal cases in a number of different ways. They perform medical examinations and sleep studies, and make diagnoses for sleep and sleep-related disorders. They work with law enforcement and legal professionals on cases where sleep may be a factor. They provide expert testimony for criminal and civil trials. The also research and study the latest in sleep science, and other physical and psychological conditions that might contribute to violent and dangerous behavior.
When Sleep is Violent
What could lead a sleeping person to enact dangerous, violent behavior while in some stage of sleep? The answer to that question is deeply complicated. You’ll often hear the term "parasomnia" in connection with sleep-related violence. I’ll talk briefly about what that term means.
Parasomnias are a broad category of disorders and conditions that disrupt sleep and lead to unwanted behaviors, psychological states, and experiences related to sleep. There are many types of parasomnias, and collectively, parasomnias occur in an estimated 10 percent of general population. The range of parasomnias is wide. Sleep talking is a parasomnia. So is sleep eating. Sleep terrors in children are a form of parasomnia.
Several parasomnias carry risks for sleep-related accidents and injury, to the sleeper and to other people the sleeper comes in contact with. Parasomnias can be caused by sleep disorders, medical conditions — both physical and psychological — and interactions with medications, drugs, and alcohol, or for reasons sleep physicians can’t identify. There appears to be strong genetic connection to some parasomnias, including sleepwalking.
Sleep-related conditions that can result in disturbing, dangerous, and violent behavior include:
• Sleep driving
• Sleep terrors
• Dissociative disorders related to sleep
• Medication interactions that affect sleep and dreaming
• Drug and alcohol use
• Nightmare disorder
• Confusional arousals, sometimes called “sleep drunkenness”
• REM Sleep Behavior Disorder
You might think criminal cases that require an expert in sleep happen once in a blue moon. Not so. While not common, sleep-related crimes happen more often than you may think. Breakthroughs in sleep science have deepened our understanding of the intricacies of sleep, and the complex, porous lines between sleeping and waking. Forensic experts point out that what we now can identify as sleep-related violence can be mistaken for intentional violence against oneself or others.
The earliest criminal case in the U.S. involving the so-called “sleepwalking defense” came in 1846. A man named Albert Tirrell was found not guilty of killing his mistress and setting fire to a brothel in Boston. Tirrell’s defense claimed he was a sleepwalker, with a history of agitated and violent behavior during sleepwalking episodes that began when he was a young child.
One of the most famous cases of sleep-related crime—and a case that in some ways echoes Albert Tirrell—is that of Kenneth Parks. In 1987, Parks rose one night from bed, drove roughly 14 miles to his in-laws’ house, and assaulted them. He bludgeoned his mother-in-law to death and attacked his father-in-law, who survived. Parks then drove to a local police station and confessed to the killings. Parks said he’d been sleepwalking the entire time, through the drive, the attack, and even at the police station. He said he hadn’t been aware of what he was doing and had only trace memories of the events.
Parks had a long history, dating back to his childhood, of complex and extended sleepwalking episodes triggered by stress. Around the time of the killings, Parks was under significant stress: he had a serious gambling problem, he’d been fired from his job, and was facing embezzling charges. Parks underwent sleep testing that showed irregular brain activity during his sleep, which were consistent with some types of parasomnia. Also, when he arrived at the police station, Parks had serious wounds to both his hands—but police said he did not appear to be experiencing pain. This suggested a dissociative state that can be part of sleepwalking. Parks was acquitted of all charges.
In 2000, Scott Falater was convicted of first-degree murder in the slaying of his wife, Yarmila Falater. Falater admitted to killing his wife, “stabbing [her], stashing the knife and some bloody clothes in the back of his Volvo, then dragging her to the pool at their Phoenix home and holding her head under water,” as reported in the Los Angeles Times.
But Falater said he’d been sleepwalking when he committed these acts, and had no memory of any of the events. Sleep experts who testified at Falater’s trial said he had been sleep deprived and under stress at the time of the killing, and that he had a family history of sleepwalking. Falater was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
In 2008, Christine Thomas was strangled to death by her husband, Brian, while the British couple were vacationing in a camper in Wales. Brian Thomas was charged with murder. He said he’d been having an intense nightmare in which he was fighting off an intruder, when he awakened and realized he’d strangled his wife. Sleep experts said Thomas had experienced night terrors. Night terrors are a very intense and frightening type of sleep episode, which can be accompanied by screaming as well as sudden, violent movement or fighting. Forensic sleep evidence led to the prosecution asking for the case to be dropped and Thomas to be found not guilty.
There are at least two currently ongoing murder cases in the U.S. that involve sleep as part of the defense:
• In Atlanta, Georgia, there’s the case of 74-year-old Claud McIver, an attorney charged with murder in the shooting death of his wife Diane McIver in 2016. McIver has said the shooting, which took place in the couple’s SUV, was an accident. Falling asleep in the backseat with a gun in his lap, McIver has said, he woke up abruptly and his hand jerked to pull the trigger inadvertently. According to his attorney, McIver has been diagnosed with parasomnia. The judge in the case recently granted a request from McIver’s defense attorney to have McIver examined by a sleep expert.
• A North Carolina case involves a man who says he woke from sleep one night this September to find his wife stabbed and himself covered in blood. Twenty-eight-year-old Matthew Phelps called 911 at about 1 a.m. on September 1, and told the dispatcher he’d awakened from sleep to find his wife, Lauren Hugelmaier Phelps, stabbed in their bedroom—and that he thought he’d killed her. On the 911 call, Phelps said he remembered having a dream before he woke to see his wife’s body on the bedroom floor, blood on his own body, and a knife lying on the bed. Phelps told the dispatcher he’d taken cold medication before going to bed and he thought he’d taken more of the medicine than he should have. According to news reports, he said he took the medicine “because I know it can make you feel good and sometimes I can’t sleep at night.”
Though it remains too-little understood, sleep violence is a real danger—one the legal world is still just waking up to. Sleep forensic specialists are at the forefront of bridging the gaps between the science of sleep violence and the legal ramifications for sleep-related crimes.
Next, I’ll talk more in depth about the different conditions that can give rise to sleep-related violence, and how they’re being diagnosed and treated. Make sure you check back next week for part two!
Michael J. Breus, PhD, DABSM
The Sleep Doctor™