Borderline Personality: Does a BPD Diagnosis Imply Raging?
Or does bpd indicate a highly sensitive person who reacts with strong emotions?
Posted Jun 09, 2014
Borderline Personality Disorder usually conjures up images of a raging woman or explosive man whose attacks cause great suffering for their spouse, boy/girlfriend, and/or children, marriage problems and a need for intensive counseling help.
While this image does fit for some people who suffer with this disorder, many individuals with a bpd diagnosis in fact are highly sensitive persons who experience more intense fear and depression than they do anger. Raging may NOT be the central feature of this disorder.
The video in this link explains the fear and depression that a young man suffering with a bpd diagnosis experiecd. Alas, help came too late for this likable young man who last year took his life. Thank you so much to his friend who forwarded the video link to me in a Comment in response to one of my earlier posts on bpd. The nine-minute video is well worth watching to the end.
My professional colleague H.O. suffers with a borderline personality disorder. H.O. therefore has both a professional and personal understanding of bpd diagnosis. She has corresponded with me recently to share her perspectives about bpd. I am pleased that H.O. has given me permission to share her writing with my readers.
This article is the third in the series I have been publishing of H.O.'s insights. The first explained the term borderline personality sufferer and the second addressed the stigma attached to the term bpd from its association with terms like drama queen for women and abusive for men.
Dear Dr. Heitler:
The question of the diagnostic label for people with what we usually call bpd is very complex. For a long time there have been controversies about dropping the term “borderline” as misleading and stigmatizing.
Concerns have been raised also about putting BPD in the PD (Personality Disorders) cluster. There seems to be significant biological overlap between BPD and bipolar disorder for example, which the psychiatry establishment considers to be biological as opposed to “bad”. And many of the most negative features that people often associate with bpd may actually stem from malignant narcissism (impulses to hurt people combined with hearing only one's own desires).
When I diagnose a client with the term Borderline Personality Disorder I base it on two aspects of DSM 5 diagnosis
a) the general criteria for all of the Personality Disorders, that is, impairment and its continuity in time/across situations an
b) the specific criteria for BPD
What are the specific DSM 5 criteria for borderline personality disorder?
-Significant impairments in personality functioning
-Impairments in interpersonal functioning
-Pathological “personality” traits i.e. affective negativity and which consists of: lability of affect, anxiousness, separation anxiety, depressivity.
Stigmatizing and Blame
The term pathological personality traits is especially unfortunate. This term conveys stigmatizing and blame. Now not only is the client unhappy but it is his or her fault too. That's a term that would benefit from deletion.
The DSM also unfortunately fails to clarify that affective negativity (lots of hurt, angry, depression and other negative feelings) is a function of vulnerability. Because people with bpd have high emotional sensitivity combined with low resilience (ability to bounce back from negative feelings), negative emotions tend to take up more of their time, energies and relationships.
What is a more helpful perspective for understanding ptsd?
Negative feelings are triggered more frequently for people with bpd at least in part because their amygdala, a part of the brain which controls emotional reactions, is set too sensitively. That is, their amygdala reads "Danger!" where others would see none. And their amygdala launches intense fight or flight reactions where others would calmly deal with the situation.
This mood hyper-reactivity/hyper-intensity may stem from ptsd from traumatic childhood experiences including childhood emotional and/or physical abuse, often by a borderline parent. Those traumatic incidents raise amygdala reactivity. Subsequently, a person who has been traumatized in childhood functions much like military personnel with PTSD from having experienced extremely emotionally painful negative events in war situations.
Emotional hyper-reactivity and hyper-intensity are the core issues here. All the remaining symptoms in the diagnostic list are consequences.
From this perspective, I feel the focus in our articles for psychologytoday.com on emotional hyper-reactivity/hyper-intensity, which also has been the focus of bpd expert Marsha Linehan's more recent work, has been correct.
Hyper-reactivity refers to seeing threat when there is none.
Hyperintensity refers to reacting to actual threats with excessively high levels of emotional arousal, which may take the form of anger or alternatively can be of depression or anxiety.
So for instance, someone with bpd might hear a comment made by a friend as critical when it was intended to be neutral or positive. "Your hair looks lovely" might be interpreted as "Usually your hair does not look lovely." That's hyperreactivity.
And if the reaction is of strong hurt and anger rather than mild concern, that's hyperintensity.
Hyper-reactivity/hyper-intensity in experiencing the “abuses of daily life” results in “abnormal” behaviors, attitudes and impairment.
Here's another example. An ambiguous facial expression on a loved one’s face might be read by a bpd individual as sarcasm, in turn evoking either anger and a hostile outburst or intense self-oathing and dispair, which in turn impairs the continuity of relationships. That’s the chaos-making of bpd in action.
Hyper-reactivity/hyper-intensity also cause the frequent diagnostic confusion about whether a patient is bipolar vs. BPD. The therapeutic effectiveness of mood-stabilizing drugs (topiramate, lamotrigine) in both bipolar and BPD also support biological overlap/common. In both disorders, the underlying mechanism is something biological that causes mood hyper-reactivity/intensity/lability.
What causes this kind of highly sensitive emotional reactivity?
As I mentioned above, some people with bpd, men and women alike, have been emotionally reactive and hypersensitive from early on in their childhood, perhaps because of diffulties they have experienced or perhaps from other causes.
In either case, this hypersensitivity can be challenging for parents to deal with. A combination of kindly and firm parenting can make a significant difference for such children. Alas, however, all too often highly sensitive children have emotionally hyper-reactive bpd and/or narcissistic parents.
Unfortunately the spirit of biologically sensitive individuals can be broken early, and all the more so if their parent, perhaps suffering from bpd and narcissism as well, contributes abusive parenting Such individuals then spend most of their lives just trying to survive, feeling constantly torpedoed by “abuses of daily life.”
Normal people are able to shake off or deal with mild conflicts or differences or misunderstandings via cooperative talking. Such events however trigger disproportionate, overwhelming and excessively long-lasting emotional responses in BPD individuals.
In sum, all you need to “achieve” the full-blown BPD phenotype as described by DSM 5 is to start with a sensitive and vulnerable biologically hyperreactive/hyperintense/labile child. Expose him or her to emotionally painful experience that the child, being vulnerable, can’t handle or get over. Add in parents who tend toward punishment more than toward parenting with patient teaching, or who are excessively permissive instead of helpfully coaching the child in ways to manage his or her emotional storms more effectively. Voila, bpd.
Note that a highly sensitive child who exhibits emotional hyper-reactivity/hyper-intensity, has high risk for BPD in adulthood, especially in the absence of a strongly supportive/nourishing environment, even if this environment includes little adversity or trauma. Such extra-supportive environment is unfortunately uncommon, while the vulnerability is quite common. The result is the high incidence of BPD.
Of course, Dr. Heitler, I have no objections and give my permission to you to publish anything I write to you about borderline personality disorder and bpd diagnosis, causes and treatment.
For links to other articles on borderline personality disorders by Dr. Heitler and H.O., as well as a listing by topic of Dr. Heitler's PT blogposts, please see this index.
In addition, my relevant earlier posts on the issue of prevention of raging include:
Susan Heitler, Ph.D., a private practice clinical psychologist in Denver, has written From Conflict to Resolution on therapy, and The Power of Two and The Power of Two Workbook on the skills for marriage success.
Dr. Heitler's website PowerOfTwoMarriage.com offers an interactive online option for learning how to communicate collaboratively in relationships.
Most recently, Dr. Heitler has published Prescriptions Without Pills: For Relief from Depression, Anger, Anxiety and More. The free website by the same time offers videos and worksheets you can download for addressing excessive anger.
Please feel welcome to post this article on your website by copying the title, author, picture and top paragraph or two followed by a Read More link to the original. Posting PT articles in full without permission from the author is a direct violation of copyright.