Skip to main content
Aging

Taking My Own Advice About Hobbies

A psychiatrist tries painting and salsa, and learns when to persist or let go.

Key points

  • Hobbies are linked to better mood, life satisfaction, and brain health, even when we are not good at them.
  • Early awkwardness often reflects being a beginner, not a poor fit.
  • Connection, curiosity, and pleasure are all valid reasons to keep going.
  • A time-limited trial with a review date can make the decision to continue or quit more deliberate.

As mental health professionals, we all know the value of hobbies. We recommend them to patients who are stressed, isolated, depressed, or overcoming addiction, and more. Yet until recently, I explored very few, despite giving that advice to others for years. As a workaholic, I often filled my free time with more work and then added volunteer work. I found it extremely rewarding and never felt like I was missing out on anything.

But now, as my friends are starting to retire and are excited to lean into their many hobbies, I decided I'd better find some additional interests. It is a work in progress, and I hope that by sharing a few personal observations, we can learn together. I do enjoy writing. Could that be called a hobby instead of work?

Two Hobbies, Two Very Different Experiences

I have been painting for two years, and I still do not like my work. That is an unfortunate admission. I love art. I have discovered that admiring a beautiful painting and creating one are very different experiences. Two years in, I find myself asking: Why am I doing this? Should I keep going? How long should I give something before being able to create something I love? Are the benefits worth the effort? I really don’t know. I do feel the lessons have improved my writing skills. I enjoy the time I am doing it, and I appreciate the connection with my teacher. My visual skills have heightened but I am tired of giving away/throwing away canvases.

So I decided to try a new hobby and joined a neighbor at a group salsa class. Dancing began even more awkwardly than my attempts at painting. I attended a weekly group class, and for the first few lessons, I felt overwhelmed with anxiety. Then I started taking private lessons and the whole experience changed. Within a month, something shifted: It became fun.

The contrast has made me think about a question many of us face, and one our patients bring to us too: How do we decide which extracurricular pursuits deserve our time, attention, and money?

As a physician, I try to stick with things and strive for mastery. But time and energy are finite. If we stay with everything we start, we leave little room to discover something we might enjoy more. On the other hand, if we leave at the earliest signs of difficulty, we may be missing the opportunity for substantial growth.

Know What You Want From It

Before judging a hobby, it helps to explore your motivation. Are we seeking mastery, relaxation, exercise, connection, or a finished project?

Each goal calls for a different measure of success. A painting can disappoint while the afternoon spent creating it still has value. A dance lesson can be enjoyable long before we have become skilled.

Why Hobbies Matter

There are many good reasons to keep a hobby, and skill is only one of them.

  • Mood and well-being. A 2023 study in Nature Medicine examined data from 93,263 adults aged 65 and older across 16 countries. Having a hobby was associated with fewer depressive symptoms and greater happiness and life satisfaction.[1] Because the study was observational, it cannot prove that hobbies caused these benefits, and nothing in it suggested that becoming accomplished was necessary to experience them.

  • Brain health. Learning something new asks the brain to work in unfamiliar ways: attending, remembering, coordinating, and adjusting. In a study of older adults in the Bronx, Joe Verghese and colleagues found that frequent participation in cognitively engaging leisure activities, such as reading, playing board games, and playing a musical instrument, was associated with a lower risk of dementia. Among the physical activities studied, dancing was the one linked to reduced risk.[2] The 2024 Lancet Commission on dementia also counts physical inactivity and social isolation among the modifiable risk factors for dementia.[3] These are associations, not guarantees, but they suggest that the effort of being a beginner may itself be part of the benefit.

  • Connection. Many hobbies bring us into regular contact with other people. My dance classes have given me something painting has not: a room full of people learning alongside me and laughing at the same missteps. The group usually goes to dinner after class. Social connection matters for health. A meta-analysis of 148 studies found that people with stronger social relationships had a 50 percent greater likelihood of survival over the study periods.[4] A hobby that adds friendly, regular contact to our week may be worth continuing even when progress is slow.

Being a Beginner Is Not the Same as Being a Poor Fit

My experience with dancing reminds me that our first attempts may tell us more about being a beginner than about whether an activity suits us.

Still, time alone does not guarantee progress. Practice needs to offer chances to learn, receive feedback, and try again. A 2014 meta-analysis found that deliberate practice explained 21 percent of the differences in musical performance and 18 percent in sports performance.[5] Those figures describe variation among people, not how much any one person will improve. Practice matters, but much about performance remains unexplained.

The practical lesson is to examine how we are learning before concluding that we lack ability. Would a different teacher help? Are we attempting tasks beyond our current level? Would a smaller, specific goal make progress easier to see? For me, that might mean practicing color mixing or composition, rather than expecting every canvas to be something I want to hang.

Try a Time-Limited Experiment

Research offers no universal deadline for deciding whether to quit a hobby. The activity, our goals, the instruction, and the time available all matter.

One practical approach is a manageable trial: perhaps six to eight weeks of regular participation, with a review date and a budget. This is a suggested experiment, not a scientifically validated cutoff. A complex skill may need much longer; an expensive or physically demanding activity may call for an earlier check-in.

Choose a schedule you can sustain. Twice-weekly private dance lessons work for me right now, but may not be sustainable over the long run. Once I feel some mastery, I look forward to enjoying the group with the added benefit of social connection.

After each session, reflect on the following: Did I enjoy any part of it? Did I learn something? How did I feel afterward? Do I want to return? Then look for a pattern across several sessions. One discouraging afternoon should not decide the future of an interest.

Signs It May Be Worth Continuing

Consider continuing when curiosity survives frustration, when you notice small gains, or when the activity brings connection, satisfaction, or relief from daily demands.

Notice how you feel afterward. You may dread looking awkward beforehand but leave glad you went.

Ask yourself: If no one ever saw the result, would I still want the experience? If the answer is yes, you may need lower expectations rather than a new hobby. We are allowed to be ordinary at something we enjoy.

Signs It May Be Time to Let Go

Consider stopping when repeated participation brings little interest or satisfaction, when the costs outweigh the benefits, or when you continue mainly because you would feel ashamed to quit.

The sunk-cost effect can keep us invested because we have already spent money, effort, or time, or maybe even formed a relationship with a teacher or group.[6] But yesterday's investment does not determine whether next month's lessons are worthwhile. A better question is: Knowing what I know now, would I choose to spend the next few weeks on this?

Research by Carsten Wrosch and colleagues found that the ability to disengage from unattainable goals and commit to new ones was associated with better well-being.[7] That research does not tell us which hobby to leave, but it does challenge the idea that persistence is always the healthiest response.

There are also options between carrying on unchanged and quitting altogether: change teachers, simplify the goal, reduce the frequency, or take a break.

A Note for Clinicians

When a patient wants to stop an activity, it matters why. Someone who fears embarrassment may benefit from smaller steps and support. Someone whose priorities have changed may benefit from permission to move on.

Depression adds another consideration. Reduced pleasure across many activities may reflect anhedonia rather than a poor choice of hobby. Behavioral activation, a structured treatment that helps people re-engage with meaningful activities, has evidence supporting its use for depression; a 2020 Cochrane review included 53 studies with 5,495 participants, though confidence in the findings varied.[8] This is evidence for a broader treatment, but not proof that any particular hobby will help.

We can ask about pleasure, meaning, connection, and accomplishment, while also considering symptoms, practical barriers, and the patient's own values. The goal is to help people make an informed choice about where to put their energy.

Where I Am, for Now

I am still deciding what place painting will have in my life. Dancing has become fun, and it has brought me new people and a new kind of challenge, which makes it easy to return. Neither experience requires a verdict on my talent or character.

We can give ourselves and our patients permission to try something new. To keep going or to let go. The list of possible hobbies is long and the key to success is to find something you love doing.

My best advice: Try something. I am sorry it took me so long to branch out and am grateful for all the new experiences.

References

1. Mak, H. W., et al. (2023). Hobby engagement and mental wellbeing among people aged 65 years and older in 16 countries. Nature Medicine, 29, 2233–2240.

2. Verghese, J., Lipton, R. B., Katz, M. J., et al. (2003). Leisure activities and the risk of dementia in the elderly. New England Journal of Medicine, 348, 2508–2516.

3. Livingston, G., et al. (2024). Dementia prevention, intervention, and care: 2024 report of the Lancet standing Commission. The Lancet, 404, 572–628.

4. Holt-Lunstad, J., Smith, T. B., & Layton, J. B. (2010). Social relationships and mortality risk: A meta-analytic review. PLoS Medicine, 7(7), e1000316.

5. Macnamara, B. N., Hambrick, D. Z., & Oswald, F. L. (2014). Deliberate practice and performance in music, games, sports, education, and professions: A meta-analysis. Psychological Science, 25, 1608–1618.

6. Arkes, H. R., & Blumer, C. (1985). The psychology of sunk cost. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 35, 124–140.

7. Wrosch, C., et al. (2003). Adaptive self-regulation of unattainable goals: Goal disengagement, goal reengagement, and subjective well-being. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 29, 1494–1508.

8. Uphoff, E., et al. (2020). Behavioural activation therapy for depression in adults. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, CD013305.

advertisement
More from Eva Ritvo M.D.
More from Psychology Today