Is It Disordered Eating or OCD?

A young woman meticulously arranges the food on her plate, ensuring that each bite is symmetrical before she allows herself to eat. Another counts calories obsessively, unable to deviate from her strict daily allotment. To an observer, both behaviors could appear to be signals of an eating disorder, motivated by a desire to control one's body. Both are also examples of rituals driven by an intrusive fear of something catastrophic happening by eating “incorrectly.”

Being able to identify this distinction is key to understanding the overlap and difference between obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and eating disorders, particularly those that present as primarily restrictive.

A large body of evidence indicates that OCD and eating disorders frequently co-occur. Recent research demonstrates that up to 40 percent of individuals with anorexia nervosa also exhibit symptoms of OCD, and approximately 20 percent of people with OCD develop disordered eating behaviors. While these disorders have distinct diagnostic criteria, they can share many core features including rigid rules, compulsive behaviors, and an intense need for control. Individuals with anorexia may fixate on food intake and body weight, leading to pervasive, intrusive thoughts that dominate daily life. Similarly, those with OCD experience uncontrollable intrusive thoughts, often resulting in compulsive actions.

In both disorders, these compulsions—self-weighing, strict food restrictions, or eating rituals—serve to alleviate the anxiety provoked by obsessive thoughts. However, the relief obtained is often fleeting, perpetuating a relentless cycle of obsession and compulsion.

Despite their overlap, there are important ways in which these diagnoses differ. One of the most critical distinctions between eating disorders and OCD lies in how the individual perceives their thoughts and behaviors.

Restrictive behaviors or food rituals that are driven by an eating disorder, are often ego-syntonic, meaning an individual sees their actions as rational, justified, or even desirable. These behaviors may lead to a sense of pride or accomplishment in one’s ability to control their food intake and weight. This is one of the reasons why accepting one’s eating disorder as problematic or harmful can be particularly challenging.

The experiences associated with OCD, on the other hand, generally feel ego-dystonic. In this case, the intrusive thoughts and compulsions are distressing, unwanted, and misaligned with the person’s values or desires. A person with OCD who engages in food-related rituals, such as needing to eat in a specific order or avoiding certain foods due to irrational fears, often wants to stop but feels powerless against their compulsions. The behaviors may not be related to weight loss or body control, but an attempt to prevent anxiety or imagined harm.

Given these distinctions, what makes it hard to distinguish OCD and anorexia? One critical factor is the cultural reinforcement of disordered eating behaviors. While OCD compulsions—such as excessive hand-washing—are generally recognized as unfounded, behaviors like calorie counting, restriction of food groups, and exercise routines are often praised, making it easier for undiagnosed OCD to be mistaken for an eating disorder.

Moreover, when OCD and anorexia co-exist, the lines between them blur. A person with anorexia may develop OCD-like rituals around food preparation or eating, while someone with OCD may develop food-related compulsions that mimic restrictive eating. This overlap can lead to misdiagnosis and ineffective treatment. While traditional eating disorder treatments focus on normalizing eating patterns and challenging fears about weight gain, individuals with OCD-related food fears often need exposure and response prevention therapy (ERP), the gold-standard treatment for OCD, to address their compulsions effectively.

Recognizing the difference between food-related compulsions in OCD and restrictive behaviors in anorexia is essential for routing individuals to the right treatment. A misdiagnosis can lead to interventions that fail to address the core problem, leaving individuals stuck in a cycle of ineffective care. Clinicians must carefully assess whether food-related behaviors stem from a distorted body image (as seen in anorexia) or from intrusive, anxiety-driven fears (as seen in OCD).

By distinguishing between ego-syntonic and ego-dystonic symptoms, clinicians, patients, and families can better understand the underlying motivations behind these behaviors—leading to more accurate diagnoses and, ultimately, more effective recovery paths.

To find a therapist near you, visit the Psychology Today Therapy Directory.