Skip to main content
Sam Louie MA, LMHC
Sam Louie MA, LMHC, CSAT
Trauma

Are We Talking Too Much in Therapy?

Personal Perspective: Getting to the bottom of "bottom-up therapy."

Sam Louie
Source: Sam Louie

It’s taken me a long time to arrive at this point of healing. I started therapy more than twenty years ago while going through a divorce. Over the years, I worked with individual and group therapists, attended a 12-Step program, church, and men’s groups, participated in workshops and trainings, and read hundreds of books on trauma, addiction, and healing. I understood my trauma “by chapter and verse.” Yet I was often cut off from the emotions. Much of my change remained intellectual.

I knew I had abandonment and rejection issues, addictions to address, feelings of inadequacy, cultural and language barriers in relating to my first-generation Chinese immigrant parents, and a sharp tongue that had once protected me from racist taunts and mockery. Eventually, I resigned myself to being “traumatized,” and felt my growth was as good as it gets.

Things began shifting when I experimented with my “right brain.” I used poetry, photography, drawing, and even childhood TV theme songs to access emotions. Sometimes I cried without knowing why. I began to recognize what art therapists have known for decades: We sometimes need to give the intellectual, explaining side of ourselves a break from reflexively talking:

“Words alone are not enough to make it happen. Recovery requires creative expression in symbol and metaphor.” —Cohen, Barnes, and Rankin, 1995

As I put images to words, my need to explain my past diminished. My longings, hurts, and fears began spilling onto the page through pictures. Hamel (2021) explains, “Traumatic memories stored as images in the right brain become accessible through drawing and painting.”

Sam Louie
Source: Sam Louie

I also discovered sandplay therapy, which encouraged me to create scenes using miniature figures and objects rather than simply explaining my concerns. It helped me slow down my logical brain and experience what I had previously only been able to describe.

This distinction between “top-down” and “bottom-up” processing became increasingly meaningful. Bottom-up approaches intentionally bring attention to what is happening inside the body—sensations, images, emotions, impulses, gestures, and other experiences that may exist outside conscious awareness.

Around the time of COVID, I read No Bad Parts, which transformed how I understood myself. Internal Family Systems (IFS) helped me view my reactivity, anger, addictions, and compulsions not as “bad,” but as parts of me that had developed for protective reasons.

I began experimenting with this approach with my lifelong nail-biting habit. Instead of shaming the behavior, I became curious about its positive intention. As I listened internally, memories surfaced of being scared and home alone with my younger brothers while our parents worked. The nail-biting part had taken over to help me feel safe.

I was stunned. I had talked extensively about the fear growing up but had compartmentalized it as “a thing from my past.” I felt I had moved beyond it because I had no emotion around it. Little did I know, I was simply disconnected from the fear.

As Morgan (2015) explains, “Body signals are usually missed when attention is in outer, task-focused mode or sufficient time is not given.”

This helped me realize that simply talking about the past isn't always enough. We can know our history without fully experiencing or integrating it. In therapy today, I often slow down when clients tell their stories. Rather than immediately asking another question, I might ask, “As you’re talking about this, can you tell me what you’re noticing happening inside?”

The answer might be a physical sensation, image, sound, memory, symbol, emotion, or words. By slowing down, clients may access experiences that were previously outside their awareness.

The goal isn't simply to revisit painful memories. These approaches can create a new experience in the present—a corrective emotional experience that provides something the person needed but didn't receive.

As van der Kolk (2014) writes, “Trauma is primarily remembered not as a story, a narrative with a beginning, middle, and end, but as isolated sensory imprints.”

I initially believed therapy would “cure” my anxiety and addictions. I wanted freedom from rejection, inadequacy, and compulsive behaviors. What I’ve learned is that I’m really seeking integration. I’m still a work in progress, but I’m beginning to experience healing not just intellectually, but from the inside out.

Ironically, this inward focus was reiterated not only in therapy books but also in books about martial arts: “Most people live at a comfortable distance from their bodies since they pay hardly any attention to them… As humans, we spend so much time inside our heads that we often forget the way out.” —Bolelli, 2008

After all these years, my head and heart are finally beginning to connect. I'm learning healing in therapy isn't so much about talking more as it is about slowing down enough to notice what is happening within as I talk and share my stories,

References

Cohen, Barry, Barnes, Mary-Michola, Rankin, Anita. 1995. Managing Traumatic Stress Through Art.

Hamel, Johanne. 2021. Somatic Art Therapy: Alleviating Pain and Trauma Through Art.

Schwartz, R. C. (2021). No Bad Parts: Healing Trauma and Restoring Wholeness with the Internal Family Systems Model. Sounds True.

Morgan, Marilyn. (2015). The Central Role of the Body in Hakomi Psychotherapy. In H. Weiss, G. Johanson, & L. Monda, Hakomi Mindfulness-Centered Somatic Psychotherapy: A Comprehensive Guide to Theory and Practice.

Van Der Kolk, Bessel. 2014. The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma.

Bolelli, Daniele. 2008. On the Warrior’s Path: Philosophy, Fighting, and Martial Arts Mythology.

advertisement
About the Author
Sam Louie MA, LMHC

Sam Louie is a therapist in Seattle who specializes in multicultural issues and sexual compulsivity.

More from Sam Louie MA, LMHC, CSAT
More from Psychology Today
More from Sam Louie MA, LMHC, CSAT
More from Psychology Today