Feeling All the Feels

Source: Alexas_Fotos / Unsplash

“How are you?”

We hear it every day, but few of us answer it accurately. We’re conditioned to give the classic terse replies, such as “I’m good” or “Not great,” choosing a single emotion, as if our inner world fits neatly into either/or. Maybe we do this because we’re increasingly disconnected from ourselves. Or maybe it’s because our culture prizes efficiency, and taking the time to reflect before answering feels indulgent. There’s also the fear that someone might not really want to know how we actually are, and that a true response could lead to a long, awkward conversation. Meanwhile, a more complicated emotional reality simmers beneath the surface.

Human emotions don’t show up one at a time; rather, they overlap, compete, and coexist. You can feel grateful and exhausted, angry and loving, proud and hurt. We even say to our kids, “I love you, but I don’t like your behavior.” The challenge isn’t that these emotions conflict; it’s that we’ve been taught they shouldn’t be felt at the same time.

I recently saw this in a patient named Olivia, a mother of two who came in for intermittent palpitations. Her tests were normal, but her symptoms weren’t imaginary. They tended to flare after tense conversations with her teenage daughter. “My heart races when she shuts me out,” Olivia told me. “I feel proud of her independence, but also heartbroken that she no longer confides in me.” As we spoke, her furrowed forehead softened and her eyes brightened. Simply naming both emotions, without trying to choose between them, brought her a visible sense of relief. Psychologists call this skill emotional granularity, the ability to identify and describe emotions with nuance. A 2021 study in Psychophysiology found that individuals with higher emotional granularity had improved cardiorespiratory function in daily life. In other words, learning to name what we feel, even when it’s messy, can make us healthier.

This is where equanimity begins. Equanimity means staying grounded while multiple truths move through us, and not being emotionally detached or neutral. It’s the ability to witness our internal experience without being overwhelmed by it. That kind of steadiness comes from expanding our capacity to hold more than one feeling at a time rather than keeping a narrow field of view. This skill starts with building an emotional vocabulary: Are you angry, frustrated, irritated, or enraged? Are you content, peaceful, excited, or all of the above? The more words we have for what we feel, the more choice we gain in how we respond.

As a cardiac electrophysiologist and guitarist, I often think in terms of rhythm. The heart isn’t a rigid metronome. It’s a living system, constantly adapting to its environment. A healthy heartbeat includes subtle variation: speeding up, slowing down, responding to breath, emotion, and context. This variation, known as heart rate variability (HRV), is a marker of resilience: physically, cognitively, and emotionally. Just as the heart adjusts to the body’s changing needs, we function best when we allow emotional flexibility in our daily lives. Suppressing complexity flattens our inner rhythm and disconnects us from the present moment. You don’t have to be emotionally certain to be emotionally steady. You just have to listen honestly.

So, the next time someone asks, “How are you?” consider pausing. At first, it might feel awkward, but with time, it becomes a space for awareness. You don’t need to explain your entire inner life, but you can be more mindful of what’s really present. Often, just naming that you’re feeling more than one thing allows your nervous system to settle, which can lead to clarity and calm.

Reflection

Think of a recent moment when two emotions showed up at once. How did your body respond? Where did you feel each emotion — in your neck, chest, gut, or elsewhere? What changed, physically or mentally, when you gave both emotions space to be named and heard?