Skip to main content

Verified by Psychology Today


The Hobbit Journey Continues, As Do Controversies

Is this return to this fantasyland welcome, or will it leave viewers queasy?

Consider, if you will, “Star Wars: Episode V — The Empire Strikes Back,” “The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers,” “The Hunger Games: Catching Fire” . . . Middle films are the bastard children of trilogies. Their unenviable fate? To keep the plot going, to up the stakes (and swordplay) even further, but to offer no satisfying resolutions.

So it is with “The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug," which opened in time for the holiday movie season. This follow-up to last December’s “The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey” is the second stage in Peter Jackson’s quest to scale J.R.R. Tolkien’s novel up to a full-blown, no-dwarves-barred epic.

When you run out of things to talk about after Christmas, and pile your family into the horse-drawn wagon and head out of the Shire on your journey to Mordor --- aka your local cineplex --- to see this Hobbit Episode #2, there are weighty issues to consider.

In “Desolation of Smaug,” viewers are again immersed in Tolkien’s tale of elves, sorcerers, and vengeful quests — and they visit lands even farther from Bilbo’s idyllic Hobbiton. “It’s brand-new territory and a very different part of Middle-earth than we’ve visited before,” said John Howe, conceptual designer for the “Lord of the Rings” and “Hobbit” film trilogies. Places like Lake-town and Mirkwood have an “element of exoticism . . . like heading toward St. Petersburg rather than heading to Rome.”

Some will welcome this return to fantasyland. For others, the first trip left them feeling queasy. Jackson turning a 300-page children’s book into a trio of three-hour movies — by adding a prologue, flashbacks, and extra scenes and characters taken from Tolkien’s other writings — struck many critics as a misstep. Or, “sort of stretched,” as Bilbo once said, “like butter that has been scraped over too much bread.”

There's more of this massaging in “Desolation,” plus extended battles, extra chase scenes, and cliffhangers that many would say are better suited to a theme park ride than the Tolkienverse.

“What if it’s a trap?” asks goofy wizard Radagast in a scene from the new film. “It is undoubtedly a trap,” replies Gandalf. Or take this line from Thorin, enhanced with extra-crispy dark and stormy angst: “If this is to end in fire, then we will all burn together.”

In “Desolation of Smaug,” screenwriters Jackson, Fran Walsh, Philippa Boyens, and Guillermo del Toro again pump up lesser players and invent new faces. Bard (Luke Evans), the Lake-town hunk whose bow skills will later prove pivotal, is given a family. Legolas (Orlando Bloom), the elf from the “Rings” movies but never mentioned in the book, makes an unscheduled appearance. The writers invented a fresh female elf character named Tauriel (Evangeline Lilly) to thicken the plot.

“[Jackson] has this amazing capacity to keep everything developing and changing as he goes,” said Howe, “and some kind of miraculous grasp of the movie as a whole that lets him achieve these changes.”

This is all either a good thing or a travesty, depending on one’s fealty to the original text. That said, “An Unexpected Journey” grossed $300 million domestically and $1 billion worldwide, so expect even frustrated fans to be on the hook.

Faithful readers have been carrying around their own private film versions of “The Hobbit” in their heads. With part two of this unexpected trilogy, Jackson’s version will be further set in stone harder than dragon’s scales. Questions about the adaptation abound. Why do the barrels the dwarves escape in have no lids? Will Tolkien’s talking spiders speak? What will Smaug look like? How many more iconic, bass-ass, superhero Legolas moments will augment the already action-packed plot? What has been added, fabricated, or lost, and where exactly will this middle passage through Middle-earth end?

All of that and more awaits us in a theater as dark as any enchanted forest.

As for part three, getting Bilbo & Company there and back again will require one more year of labor for Jackson & Company. “The Hobbit: There and Back Again” is slated for December 2014 release.

“Until everything is delivered,” Howe said, “Peter is capable of all kinds of surprises.”

More from Ethan Gilsdorf
More from Psychology Today