10 Ways to Win Any Argument

New research suggests ten ways to win a debate, even if it's with your partner.

Posted Jun 23, 2018

VGstockstudio/Shutterstock
Source: VGstockstudio/Shutterstock

You and your partner seem locked in a dispute, and neither of you is willing to back down and concede. It’s a rather trivial matter — which relatives to invite to a cousin’s baby shower. You don’t want to invite your partner’s sister, because she tends to put a damper on the fun, and you can’t imagine her playing along with the silly baby-themed games you have planned. Your partner insists the opposite, adding that not inviting her will create an impossible rift with the rest of the clan. The argument has gone on far longer than you'd like, but you’re determined to win.

Being able to land on the winning side of an argument is an ability that takes some practice. If you’re used to stomping your feet, pouting, or giving your opponent the cold shoulder, you already know that these childish methods don’t work. Research by Katharina Bernecker, of the Leibniz-Institut fur Wissensmedien (Tubingen, Germany), and colleagues (2018) investigated the ways in which the goals of couples in a long-term relationship influenced their nonverbal communication during conflict. By contrasting the so-called approach and avoidance goals in relationships, Bernecker et al. believed they could predict the ways in which partners communicated either positive or negative messages through their body language. Obviously, communicating positive messages should contribute to higher satisfaction, both with the outcome of a conflict and in the long term.

As Bernecker and her fellow researchers observe, it is important to focus on nonverbal communication, because “nonverbal displays are, compared to verbal content, less intentionally controlled, and often perceived as a reflection of people’s authentic affective experience in a specific encounter or relationship." Determining how relationship goals influence nonverbal behavior, they reasoned, should therefore be important to understanding how partners can be more satisfied. The German study included 368 heterosexual couples in a relationship for at least one year, with some up to 60 years. The average length of relationship was 21 years, and the average age of the sample was 48: These were couples clearly committed to being together, and who had considerable experience with each other.

The key focus of the Berneker et al. study was on observing couples as they interacted in a situation involving a source of tension between them. The most frequent type of conflict involved communication, but the couples also disagreed in the areas of finances and annoying habits. Their interactions were videotaped and rated by observers in areas of nonverbal communication including positioning of the head (toward or away from the partner); movements of the head (such as nodding or head shaking); facial expressions (smiling or frowning); rotation of the torso (toward or away from partner); tilt of the upper body (forward lean or upright); position of arms (open or folded); and amount of touching. Prior to the interaction, couples rated themselves on relationship goals that included approach (wanting to deepen the relationship) and avoidance (trying to stay away from conflicts). Partners also rated their relationship satisfaction.

As the authors predicted, couples that wanted to enhance their relationship through approach motivation showed more positive nonverbal communication, and those that preferred avoidance were more likely to withdraw nonverbally and show lower positive involvement. Behind the avoidant individual’s motivation, the authors maintain, is the perception that conflict represents a threat to the relationship, rather than an opportunity to deepen the relationship further.

Turning to the question of how to win one of these conflicts, the German study suggests that it’s all about motivation. Even if you’re in an argument with a person with whom you’re not romantically involved, you can come out ahead and also enjoy the outcome of an improved relationship. With this in mind, consider these 10 strategies:

1. Arrange a face-to-face discussion.

The Bernecker et al. study showed that nonverbal communication plays an important role in conflict resolution. Even if it’s only a Skype call, being able to see the other person, and having that person see you, can help you make more on-the-spot adjustments than you can in an email or text message.

2. Wait until the right time and place.

Because you would be better off meeting in person rather than through the written word or even a phone call, time your discussion to allow for enough face-to-face interaction to be able to work the whole argument through.

3. Focus on what’s important.

Approach motivation was an important factor in the study of German couples. Looking at conflict as an opportunity to enhance and strengthen the bonds you have with the other person may help drive your nonverbal behavior in a more positive direction.

4. Frame your argument with “I” statements.

This is a well-known tactic in couples communication and can be applied to any argument, rather than just disputes in a long-term, romantic relationship. You avoid putting the other person on the defensive by stating your own perceptions of the situation.

5. Listen to the other person’s point of view.

You want to win the argument, but rather than barrel ahead with your own side of the story, hear what the other person has to say. You may find that you don’t disagree all that much, but strategically this will also allow you to plan your path toward victory.

6. Anticipate the other person’s objections.

If you time your dispute properly, you’ll have lined up ahead of time the complaints your opponent might have. This will allow you to think about how you will best state your case.

7. Avoid attacking.

Some of the negative body language observed in the Bernecker et al. study can also be applied to arguments in general. Verbal attacks will be counterproductive, because they will make the other person angry; nonverbal attacks will have the same result.

8. Be ready to make small concessions.

As you anticipate what your opponent will say, and then listen with an open mind to what he or she actually says, you can go into the situation ready to come up with an alternative plan that will be acceptable to both of you.

9. Test out your ideas with a neutral party.

In that baby shower scenario, it’s possible that only you feel this way about the cousin-in-law. Ask another relative if perhaps you’re overreacting, and if so, it may be best for you to follow Step 8 and make that concession.

10. Be nice when you win.

If everything has gone according to plan, you’ll have won the argument, and the conflict will be resolved. In order to keep that approach motivation going for you and your partner, be a good sport. The next time, it may be your partner who wins, and you would certainly appreciate the same response.

Arguments don’t have to erode a relationship, but avoiding them doesn't seem to be the best way to keep a relationship strong. If you follow these steps and engage productively, both you and your partner’s long-term fulfillment will benefit.

References

Bernecker, K., Ghassemi, M., & Brandstätter, V. (2018). Approach and avoidance relationship goals and couples’ nonverbal communication during conflict. European Journal of Social Psychology, doi:10.1002/ejsp.2379