What Actually Helps Someone Feel Free to Say No? A Script!

Source: Viktor Koldunov/Adobe Stock

Most of us have said yes to a request when we would have rather said no. Maybe a neighbor asked you to pet sit his dog and, despite your busy schedule, you said yes. Or maybe a child’s friend asked to have a sleepover, and you agreed even though you were already tired. In these cases, saying no often feels harder than it should—not because we lack the right, but because we lack the script.

A study published in Scientific Reports by researchers at Cornell University's School of Industrial and Labor Relations puts that everyday experience under a microscope. The results are helpful for anyone who manages relationships, teams, or children.

The research team—graduate fellow Rachel Schlund and Professor Vanessa Bohns from Cornell, along with University of Michigan law professor Roseanna Sommers—set out to test a deceptively simple question: what actually makes someone feel free to say no?

In two experiments, undergraduate participants were asked to unlock their password-protected phones and hand them to a stranger to look through in another room—an intrusive request most people say they'd rather refuse. They were compensated for their participation.

Half of the participants were reassured of their right to refuse, being told: "If you'd like to refuse, you may do so. Refusing will not affect your payment." The other half were given a script to say no: "If you'd like to refuse, please say the words, 'I'd rather not.'"

Afterward, everyone rated how easy or difficult it felt to say “no.”

Across both studies—which included more than 500 participants in total—the groups who were given a specific phrase said it felt significantly easier to decline compared to those who were told they had the right to decline. In other words, being reminded of their rights didn’t help, but being given a script did.

Interestingly, the intervention didn't significantly change how many people actually refused to share their phone—most participants complied either way. But it did change how participants felt about the choice. The researchers noted that distinction matters—a "yes" that feels forced can breed resentment and regret, even if the behavior looks identical to a "yes" freely given.

Providing participants with a script most likely overrides unspoken societal rules that dictate compliance with a request. As a result, people can feel more comfortable refusing, making their decision feel more voluntary.

You can imagine how this may play out in your daily life. For example, imagine you are asking a friend to water your plants while you are out of town. Rather than telling them, “If it’s inconvenient, you don’t have to do it,” try saying, “It’s OK to say, ‘I’d rather not.’” Research shows using this language can help protect your neighbor’s feelings that they are free to choose.

The take-home message: If you want someone's agreement to mean something, don't stop at telling them they can say no; give them the words for how. The people around us are more likely to feel truly free—and truly heard—when we tell them how to refuse, rather than just offering permission.