Donor Families: Navigating Disenfranchised Grief

Source: Zovicota on 123rf

Donor families: A complex tapestry

When expanding sperm, egg, and embryo donor families, joy, love, acceptance, ambivalence, confusion, rejection, and grief can intertwine, creating a tapestry of emotions that can be uplifting and challenging to navigate. There might be disappointment related to not finding relatives, pain caused by feeling rejected by them, or feelings of loss at finding out that a close donor relative has already passed away. These scenarios can elicit various emotional responses, including a grieving process for the connection that never comes and a dream that’s never realized.

Many donor-conceived persons, parents, and donors who search via mutual consent contact (for example, the Donor Sibling Registry) approach the experience of seeking out biological relatives with a sense of hope and possibility. When people search via commercial DNA websites, while hopeful, their genetic connections might be shocked, unbelieving, or fearful about the DNA connection. Rejection, or the perception of rejection, is then much more likely. This can lead to disappointment, loss, and disenfranchised grief. Understanding what this grief entails and how it can manifest in donor families is crucial for emotional healing, personal growth, and supporting others.

Rejection can feel personal

Rejection is an inevitable part of life. It can bring about adversity, leading to growth and resilience. For the donor-conceived, their parents, the egg and sperm donors, and other family members, rejection can feel profoundly personal. This can culminate in a haunting fear of not being good enough or not measuring up in some fundamental way. Imagine the disappointment of reaching out to a biological relative only to be met with silence or a clear refusal.

Some donors fear connecting with genetic progeny and their families, preventing them from responding to outreach attempts. Some fears are based on the fear of rejection or disappointing the offspring or parents¹, some don't have the emotional bandwidth, fear telling their families that they donated their gametes, and others might have other life circumstances or situations that can't be reconciled. Parents may feel threatened by the idea of knowing their child's unknown biological parent, and the donor-conceived might not be willing to respond to a donor for fear of hurting or somehow betraying their parent(s). Although the odds of connecting with genetic relatives can be fairly high, the journey is often uncertain, and the waiting game can feel excruciating. The hope of finding family members can quickly turn into the despair of prolonged absence or the pain of feeling rejected. A grieving process, including feelings of shock, loss, emptiness, sadness, anger, guilt (feeling responsible for the rejection even though it was nothing they could control), and isolation, are common and can be difficult to process.

Looking around your Thanksgiving table, you might observe that being biologically related doesn't automatically translate to a close bond. We often desire relationships characterized by shared interests and values, and having a genetic connection doesn’t guarantee these bonds. Each person’s journey is unique; while some might find meaningful connections with some donor relatives, others may need to reframe their understanding of family and identity. Feelings of rejection can be intensified by the knowledge that no guarantees exist when attempting contact with unknown donor relatives—no promise of acceptance, relationship, or acknowledgment. This struggle is compounded when there is no external support and validation.

Close friends, family members, and others might not fully comprehend the depth of the seeker's disappointment and grief. Donor family connections might be perceived as unimportant, and the associated grief, therefore, illegitimate. Missing relatives, connections, and bonds that may never be realized can then trigger depression and or disenfranchised grief.

Disenfranchised grief: What is it?

Disenfranchised grief is a term coined by researcher Ken Doka² describing grief experienced without the acknowledgment, validation, or social support essential for healthy grieving. The sorrow associated with feeling cut off from close biological family members may be overlooked or minimized by others. Some people can not understand the loss felt by people who have never been known and for whom a genetic connection is the only binding factor. Sometimes, parents resist or turn away because it's just too upsetting to acknowledge that the way their deeply desired child was conceived is also a cause of discomfort or pain. This can be exacerbated by family members feeling threatened by this genetic connection to unknown persons.

The donor-conceived person experiencing disenfranchised grief often feels that their pain is not socially sanctioned and is thereby dismissed by others. "You should just be happy to be alive" is a common refrain that is usually unappreciated. Such sentiments fail to recognize the unique struggles of the donor-conceived being deliberately cut off from their ancestry, family medical history, and close genetic relatives. Their grief is exacerbated due to these misunderstandings from friends, family, and even from mental health professionals. When the donor-conceived express their feelings, they may face skepticism or outright denial. “Those people are not your family.” Such reactions can perpetuate the cycle of disenfranchisement, where individuals feel increasingly distanced from the people they trust most. When the donor-conceived feel unvalidated and isolated, they might withdraw from the process that could provide healing. Without acknowledgment of such loss, they may struggle to cope with their emotions, potentially escalating to complicated grief patterns.

The need for validation and support

Whether through counseling, support groups, or safe friend or familial environments, donor family members need acknowledgment that their feelings are valid and deserving of empathy and space. Finding others who have managed this loss and this grieving process can be extremely helpful. The Donor Sibling Registry offers support and advice from donor family members who are well-equipped and well-versed in all donor family matters. Understanding why donors, offspring, and parents may not respond to attempts to connect is an important part of the process. Donor family experts and counselors can provide strategies for navigating heavy social interactions with unhelpful judgments. An understanding advisor can guide clients through the stages of their grief, helping them reformulate their identities and perceptions of ancestry, family, connection, and belonging.

Grief Essential Reads

Don’t Let AI Speak for the Dead

Recovering From the Death of a Loved One

Finding peace

Grief is an innate expression of loss and an unavoidable human experience. Having associated feelings and emotional responses honored and validated is important but not always possible. Self-care, self-validation, focusing on strength and resilience through sustained connection to the emotional experience, learning to coexist with the absence, and finding meaning in what remains moves us forward. For those striving to connect with their donor relatives, it can be helpful to recalibrate expectations and understand that some relationships may take time (a "no" now doesn't mean a "no" forever), and some may never come to fruition. It's not about fixing grief but accepting the circumstances even though the situation and reactions from others might not feel fair or just.

Having biological ties is just one facet of life. Focusing on establishing a sense of self through positive connections found elsewhere, for example, with supportive friendships, chosen families, or community. Seeking outlets for expression—whether through art, writing, or conversations with trusted individuals—can also help process feelings of grief and the exploration of resilience. Fostering personal environments that honor the grieving process and celebrating the beauty of human connection by engaging with others who share similar stories may provide a sense of belonging and understanding. The essence of family extends beyond genetics; it lies in connection, understanding, support, and love—which can be found in many places and with many people.