Dating Violence, Warning Signs
Research shows risk of domestic violence can be predicted.
Posted Aug 10, 2016
With endorphins flooding their brains, young people (or middle-aged people in mid-life crisis) are apt to enter into an intimate relationship, with their feet not quite on the ground. The outcome usually is positive, because most people are fairly normal. But in other situations, the personality traits of one of the partners can lead to a lot of pain and misery for both of the individuals. “If only I had known what I was getting into; if only I had seen the signs.” This is a statement made by many battered women who found themselves in a relationship that had gotten frightening and that they couldn’t see any way of getting out of. Even when their friends warned them to it break off, they already felt powerless to take action.
But what if way back in school, they had learned the signs of what to watch out for, signs that could lead to serious problems and even violence later. What if they had learned about all-or-nothing thinking patterns in themselves or others and about personality traits such as possessiveness and jealousy that can do so much harm? Love and hate can be closely intertwined in such a relationship.
Schools need to teach about emotions such as jealousy so that girls when they are dating, instead of being flattered by bringing out jealousy in a boyfriend will recognize the insecurity that this emotion may represent. Schools need to teach about thought patterns that are unhealthy and about how extremist notions and behaviors can be controlled through self-awareness and training to catch the unhealthy self-talk.
Many health education programs today are teaching about feelings and how the feelings can be controlled. This is part of harm reduction programming that also is a part of drug use (and binge drinking) prevention. Such classes should also focus on dating violence prevention.
The time to help teach adolescents about the hazards of dating violence coupled with the heavy drinking that is often associated with it is in middle school when dating first begins. To this end, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has begun developing a violence prevention campaign to help change social norms that support victimization. To first learn what the middle school dating norms are, they set up boys’ and girls’ focus groups. The common form of female-to-male violence discussed by the teens was slapping. Girls slapped boys as punishment when the boy was “out of line” or in self-defense. Male participants described situations of retaliation or to assert themselves in front of their peers as reasons guys hit their girlfriends. The participants strongly disapproved of sexual violence.
The consequences of involvement in an unhealthy relationship may range from psychological abuse to threats of suicide and even rarely to murder-suicide. In writing the book, Death by Domestic Violence, I filtered out from the literature on teen domestic violence warning signs that a relationship is abusive and that such violence is likely to escalate. Here are the signs that could be discussed with young people in schools and religious group settings:
Teen Dating Abuse: Warning Signs
Based on the literature on domestic violence, we can note the following list of warning signs that a young woman should consider to determine if the relationship is likely to become violent. The warning signs are geared toward heterosexual female teens but can be adjusted to pertain to same-sex or male respondents and for different age groups.
____1. Does your date or boyfriend brag about beating up or intimidating people?
____2. Does he ever suggest that he knows how to kill, for example, by playfully putting his hands on your neck, then say he was only joking?
____3. Does he own or have access to a gun or show a fascination with weapons?
____4. Has he ever forced you to kiss or have sex? Does he show a lack of awareness of your feelings?
____6. Does he get drunk on a regular basis or brag about his high tolerance for alcohol? Does he push you to drink alcoholic beverages or take illicit drugs?
____7. When you are with him, does he control how you spend your time? Is he always the one to drive or criticize you severely if you take the wheel?
____8. Is he constantly jealous? Does he control your friendships with other people and seem to want to have you all to himself?
____9. Is he rapidly becoming emotionally dependent on you; for instance, does he say things like ‘‘I can’t live without you?’’ Is his thinking of an all-or-nothing pattern (either you are his best friend or his worst enemy—often about past relationships)?
____10. Do you have the feeling that only you understand him, that others do not or cannot?
____11. Note the relationship between his parents. Is his mother very submissive to his father? Is there heavy drinking and/or lots of tension in his family?
____12. Is there a history of past victimization by his father?
____13. Is there a history of animal abuse in his background?
____14. Has he ever struck you? Have you known him to lose control of his anger for certain periods of time?
____15. Has he ever threatened or tried to commit suicide?
____16. Does he get out of patience quickly with children or is he verbally abusive toward them?
______Total ‘‘Yes’’ answers.
If you have answered yes to two or more of these items, you should talk to a mature person before pursuing this relationship further. Before getting romantically involved with someone, consider what it would be like to break up with this person. Would you be able to cool the relationship and still remain friends or end the relationship if you wanted to? Consider how he would handle this. It is a lot easier to get out of a potentially dangerous relationship in the early stages than to wait and see how things turn out or to see whether or not you can change a person.
Source: Death by Domestic Violence: Preventing the Murders and the Murder-Suicides by K. van Wormer and A.R. Roberts, 2009. Westport, CT: Praeger, pp. 154–155.