Cognition
Wake Up, People! Get Your Thinking Brain Going!
Our lower brains are taking the human species down.
Posted May 15, 2025 Reviewed by Hara Estroff Marano
Key points
- Abstract thinking and judgment do not function during chaos.
- We cannot solve humanity's problems without clear and creative thinking.
- Learning the skills to regulate our physiology is critical to our survival.
One thing that distinguishes human beings is their capacity for proactive, prolonged aggression, a human characteristic that results from the complex consciousness created by language.1 Since threats in the form of thoughts and concepts are perceived as concretely as physical threats, many threats are physically acted on.2
Many aggressive human behaviours are based on cognitive distortions, stories people make up about themselves and others. One of the most damaging ones is labeling others as "less than." The physiological effects of threat on the brain compound the problem.
Imagine this: You're in a heated argument with a friend. Your heart races, your face flushes, and, suddenly, you say something you instantly regret. Sound familiar? In that moment, your thinking brain went offline. Blood flow to the brain was reduced, and its activity was consequently less intense. You cannot access your better judgment in a state of anger, and that explains why terrible deeds are often done.3
Our ancient ancestors relied on their fight-or-flight response to survive predators and other threats. When a saber-toothed tiger appeared, their bodies flooded with adrenaline, shutting down complex thought so they could react instantly. This survival mechanism saved lives.
But here's the problem: your brain can't distinguish between a tiger and a tense conversation with your teacher. That looming deadline? Your brain processes it as if it were a life-threatening danger. That argument on social media? Same. Your body goes into survival mode for both perceived and real threats.
The Human Survival Paradox
Here is our paradox: The same brain that gave us language, creativity, and the ability to build societies also reacts to everyday stress as if we're fighting for our lives. When we feel threatened—whether by an actual danger or an imagined one, such as an upcoming test—anxiety kicks in. And when we can't find a solution, that anxiety can transform into anger.
Anger makes people feel powerful for a moment. It gives you a rush, a feeling of control. In reality, your thinking brain (the prefrontal cortex) has shut down, and you're operating on pure emotion and instinct.
Your Brain on Stress
Here's what happens physiologically. Every moment of every day, the human brain is only 2% of the body's weight, but consumes a massive amount of fuel; it demands about 20% of your body's energy—compared to just 4 to 8% in other mammals.4 When you're stressed, blood flow shifts from your prefrontal cortex (your rational, thinking center) to more primitive parts of the brain focused on survival.
Think about a basketball player who misses a critical shot and then plays poorly for the rest of the game. They didn't suddenly lose their skill. Their brain got stuck in survival mode, foreclosing th e possibility of accessing the complex skills they've practiced thousands of times.
The same happens when you bomb a test you studied for or freeze during a presentation. It's not that you don't know the material—your brain can't access that information when it's in threat mode.
How Beliefs Get Stuck
Your brain forms beliefs through repetition. That's why propaganda works: tell a lie often enough, and people start believing it. This phenomenon occurs in politics, social media, and even within your friend groups.
A part of your brain called the insula acts as the "womb" of belief formation. Once a belief takes root, a challenge to it feels like a personal attack. This can lead to cognitive dissonance, that uncomfortable feeling when new information conflicts with your existing beliefs.
When faced with such discomfort, most people don't change their minds. Instead, they double down on their original beliefs and invest themselves in it, regardless of the evidence. Why? Because when we're stressed, our rational thinking center (the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex) shuts down, and the emotional insula takes over.
This explains why arguments rarely change people's minds. Once someone feels their identity is threatened, their brain prioritizes emotional security over logic. The more invested someone is in a belief, the harder it is to let go—whether it's about politics, religion, or which lunch table is the coolest.
The Social Media Trap
Social media algorithms grasp such brain functions remarkably well. They provide you with content that reinforces your beliefs, seldom confronting you with opposing views. People can wind up in echo chambers where beliefs grow increasingly rigid and extreme, fueling cultural divisiveness.
Throughout history, those seeking power have exploited chaos and fear to control people. When we're afraid, our rational thinking goes offline, making us targets for manipulation. We focus narrowly on perceived threats rather than seeing the bigger picture.
Breaking the Cycle
So, how can we break free? It starts with a simple principle: No action in a reaction.
When you feel yourself getting angry or defensive:
- Recognize the reaction: Notice when your heart races, your face flushes, or your thoughts narrow to just the threat.
- Pause: Don't say or do anything while your brain is in survival mode. You literally cannot think clearly in such a state.
- Wait it out: The initial surge of stress hormones typically peaks within 20 seconds and begins to subside after 90 seconds if you don't feed it with more reactive thoughts.
- Re-engage with your thinking brain: Only after you've calmed down should you address a situation.
Beyond individual moments, we can build environments that encourage healthier thinking:
- Create psychological safety: People are more likely to take in new information and reconsider their beliefs when they feel secure.
- Expose yourself to various perspectives gradually: Sudden challenges to deeply held beliefs usually backfire.
- Practice reflection: Ask yourself, "What evidence would change my mind?" to engage your rational brain.
- Build resilience against discomfort: Learn to embrace the uncomfortable feeling of having your beliefs challenged.
The Wake-Up Call
Our world faces complex problems that require clear thinking and cooperation. Yet we spend much time with our rational brains offline, reacting to perceived threats instead of thoughtfully responding.
The survival of our species depends on our ability to engage our thinking brains most of the time. We must recognize when we are in survival mode, learn and implement the strategies to bring our brains online. They are readily available.
This isn't achieved just by avoiding arguments or making better decisions. It's about evolving beyond our primitive responses to create a world in which cooperation outweighs competition, dialogue replaces division, and we use our remarkable human brains to their fullest potential.
So the next time you feel your anger rising, remember: Your thinking brain has gone offline. No action in a reaction. Wait until you can think again.
For humanity to thrive, we must all wake up to how our brains work—and learn to use them more effectively. "Wake the fun up." Your brain, your relationships, and our collective future depend on it.
References
1. Wranham RW. Two types of aggression in human evolution. ePNAS | January 9, 2018 | vol. 115 | no. 2 | 245–253
2. Eisenberger N. “The neural bases of social pain: Evidence for shared representations with physical pain.” Psychosom Med (2012); 74: 126-135.
3. Blarir RJR. Considering anger from a cognitive neuroscience perspective. Wiley Interdiscip Rev Cogn Sci . 2012 ; 3(1): 65–74. doi:10.1002/wcs.154.
4. Raichle ME, and Debra A Gusnard. Appraising the brain's energy budget. PNAS (2002);99: 10237-10239 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.172399499

