Reducing Personal Shame and Stigma Helps With Recovery

Source: RDNE Stock Project / Pexels

People addicted to drugs or alcohol are stigmatized in our society, which can impede their recovery. We cannot readily understand how they are thinking and why they are making the unhealthy choices they make. Alcoholics Anonymous advises us to separate the person from the disease. We might “hate the sin” or disapprove of harmful, self-defeating, and destructive drug use. But we love the sinner, maintain compassion and empathy, and want to help.

Stigma originates from outdated beliefs viewing addiction as a moral failing rather than an acquired, chronic, relapsing brain disease that is treatable. Often, society’s negative beliefs are internalized by people with substance use disorders, leading to social isolation and reluctance to pursue treatment. Reducing the stigma and shame associated with addiction is crucial to recovery, according to the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM), the Addiction Policy Forum (APF), and Nora Volkow, M.D.

The Addiction Policy Forum (APF) offers anti-stigma training and initiatives, deploying resources at the community level. Founder and CEO Jessica Hulsey (author of Understanding Addiction: A Guide for Families) told me, “APF has delivered our novel anti-stigma interventions to 5,827 individuals across 44 states since 2021. The data shows our programs improve understanding of addiction as a health condition, while reducing manifestations of stigma towards individuals in treatment and recovery from addiction, including stereotypes, prejudice, and discrimination.”

The American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) published ethical guidelines for addiction medicine practitioners, emphasizing the importance of respecting patient autonomy, providing nonjudgmental care, and offering a multifaceted approach to combating stigma in addiction medicine.

Persistence and Recovery

Overcoming addiction requires dogged persistence, day after day. If a person lapses, they need to forgive themselves and work on what’s needed to stay off alcohol and/or drugs. Perfection is not expected. Just as Tom Brady did not complete every pass, and Michael Jordan did not make every game-winning shot, these athletic legends were not defined by perfection—they were defined by how they navigated imperfection.

Resilience

Psychiatrists Dennis Charney and the late Dr. Steven Southwick were pioneers in the study of resilience. Based on over two decades of clinical research, interviews, and neuroscience, Charney and Southwick identified core factors consistently associated with resilient individuals: optimism, managing fears, finding meaning, building relationships, faith, cognitive and emotional flexibility, perseverance, and physical fitness and self-care. Their work helped move psychiatry from a deficit-focused view of trauma to one highlighting human strength, neuroplasticity, and the potential for post-traumatic growth.

Finding meaning is key to surviving trauma without disintegration of the self. Relationships are the most protective factor. Belief in something beyond oneself often provides existential grounding and purpose in hardship. Exercise is neuroprotective and supports resilience.

Resilience is deeply embedded in the philosophy and practices of Alcoholics Anonymous (AA), predating the science of resilience. The Big Book, the Twelve Steps, and the Twelve Traditions all emphasize the spiritual, emotional, and social dimensions of resilience, particularly as they relate to overcoming long-term adversity, shame, and relapse. Resilient people are not mindlessly optimistic—they maintain hope while accepting reality.

AA writings provide numerous discussions on shame, stigma, acceptance, humility, spiritual growth, and resilience in a communal context. Self-worth is rebuilt through attending meetings, maintaining connections, and making daily contributions rather than focusing on perfection.

"Recovery is not about staying up all the time. It is about learning how to get up—every time." — AA speaker.

Harvard Psychiatrist George Vaillant

Dr. George E. Vaillant, a pivotal figure in psychiatry and addiction medicine, brought key concepts of resilience, emotional development, and long-term recovery into the scientific spotlight. His landmark research was “The Natural History of Alcoholism” and the Harvard Grant Study—a long-term prospective study of 600-plus men, some with alcoholism, tracked over 40 years. This study provided detailed longitudinal insights into how people recover, adapt, and grow over decades. Among his most significant findings was that recovery is not a linear process. Multiple relapses often preceded sustained abstinence.

Addiction Essential Reads

What if Addiction Isn't the Problem?

Carfentanil Was an Elephant Sedative. Now It's a Human Drug Problem

According to Dr Vaillant: “You have to remember that very few doctors have ever seen a recovered alcoholic. If you’re recovered, you don’t have any reason to tell your doctor you’re an alcoholic. And if you’re not recovered, you go back to see him a hundred times, so you’re forever etched in his memory. Consequently, doctors overcount the failures and have no knowledge of the successes. They don’t understand that 40 percent of all recovery has probably occurred through Alcoholics Anonymous.”

Vaillant supported emotional development and understanding stress and cravings by thinking about and helping others. This is a core dynamic in 12-step programs like Alcoholics Anonymous, where going to meetings, supporting others, telling your story, sponsorship, and service play key roles in long-term sobriety.

Vaillant found warm, sustained relationships were the most powerful predictor of long-term recovery and life satisfaction—more predictive than IQ, education, or socioeconomic status.

Impaired Doctors

Dr. Robert DuPont, Dr. Lisa Merlo, Dr. Thomas McLellan, and I made substantial contributions to our understanding of physician health programs (PHPs) and addiction recovery among healthcare professionals. The key features of PHPs were long-term treatment and monitoring (5 years or more), mandatory abstinence and regular drug testing, structured treatment phases of evaluation and detox, inpatient or residential care, and outpatient follow-up.

Successful recovery in physicians is about helping people face shame, forgive themselves, reconnect with others, and rebuild their sense of meaning. The PHP model works because it involves working through stigma and ultimately leading to self-forgiveness. Former addicts change their thinking to such thoughts as, “I’m a grateful recovering addict.” And “I’m not bad—I was sick, and now I’m getting better.”

Final Thoughts

Compassion and empathy towards individuals with addictions are associated with better treatment engagement and outcomes than seeing them as morally flawed. Experts urge a chronic disease framework that addresses risk early in life, not by pathologizing youth, but by equipping them. This shift away from “What’s wrong with you?” toward “How can we help you grow stronger?” may be one of the most promising paradigms for long-term impact in addiction prevention. Addiction is not a permanent, immutable identity, but is a condition from which a person can recover.

Resilience and forgiveness offer a constructive, forward-looking framework for prevention and early intervention. Stigma reduction is crucial in successful treatment and recovery. The drug is stigmatized, not the user.