Suffering soldier

Moral Injury

What Is Moral Injury?

Moral injury is the social, psychological, and spiritual harm that arises from a betrayal of one’s core values, such as justice, fairness, and loyalty. Harming others, whether in military or civilian life; failing to protect others, through error or inaction; and failure to be protected by leaders, especially in combat—can all wound a person’s conscience, leading to lasting anger, guilt, and shame, and can fundamentally alter one’s world view and impair the ability to trust others. 

A soldier in the line of duty may accept the necessity of shooting an enemy combatant. But when, in attempting to identify the assailant, he finds a picture of the dead man’s children, a sense of the value of service may itself be wounded.

A person who grossly violates what they believe is right may experience persistent self-criticism—feeling unworthy, unforgivable, or permanently damaged. Reflecting on the perceived transgression can fill a person with sorrow and bitterness.

Is It PTSD or Moral Injury?

The self-loathing and distrust of others that often follow moral injury can lead to depression and anxiety, occasionally aggression, and, at worst, suicidal thinking. Psychiatrist Jonathan Shay, who developed the concept of moral injury in working with Vietnam veterans for over 20 years, contends that violence and suicide among veterans stem more from moral injury than from PTSD.

Post-traumatic stress disorder and moral injury often go hand in hand, but there are important differences: PTSD is the result of a life-threatening experience that leads to chronic hypervigilance and fear; it is difficult to ever feel safe. Moral injury involves loss of trust; it is not a disorder but a reasonable response to having one’s ethical compass thrown off track. 

Moral injury is not currently included in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM). Scientific consensus has yet to be reached on the parameters of moral injury. 
 

Who Is Vulnerable?

Doctors, too, can feel the strain of moral injury. What is often labeled “physician burnout” may in fact come from deep frustration with ethical quandaries presented by the modern healthcare system. For example, electronic record-keeping isolates doctors from patients. Doctors may struggle with caregivers’ decisions to continue life support for loved ones who may be in great pain.

When the doctors’ oath to do no harm conflicts with the ability to prevent suffering, physicians can agonize personally. More than twice as many doctors die by suicide every year compared to the general population.

Anyone caught in a life-or-death or otherwise high-stakes situation with no good choices can suffer moral injury. Therapists, human rights workers, first responders, even survivors of abuse and political violence can all face dilemmas that pitch moral and professional or self-preservation values into conflict. 
 

CONNECTED TOPICS

Burnout, Compassion Fatigue

Is There Treatment for Moral Injury?

Treatments for moral injury are still in development. At the Department of Veterans Affairs in the United States, trials of cognitive behavioral therapy emphasizing forgiveness and self-compassion have been reported to bring about significant improvement in anxiety and depressive symptoms for veterans with moral injury.

The same treatment also fostered post-traumatic growth. Group therapy has also helped veterans restore a sense of trust through connection with others who have had similar experiences.
 

Recent Posts