Consumer Behavior
Consumer behavior—how people buy and use goods and services—is a rich field of psychological research, especially for companies trying to sell products to as many potential customers as possible. Because what people buy—and why they buy it—affects many facets of their lives, consumer behavior research connects several key psychological issues. These include communication (How do different people respond to advertising and marketing?), identity (Do our purchases reveal our personality?), social status, decision-making, and mental and physical health.
Contents
Why Consumer Behavior Matters
Corporations, political campaigns, and nonprofit organizations all consult findings about consumer behavior to determine how best to market products, candidates, or issues. In some cases, these entities manipulate people's fears and unhealthy habits, or even worse tendencies. Consumers can be their own worst enemy, making rash purchasing decisions based on anxiety, faulty logic, or a fleeting desire for social status. But consumers aren’t powerless. They can learn more about the strategies companies employ and the explanations for people's often confusing purchasing decisions. This can help individuals more consciously decide on what, why, and whether they buy.
In developed countries, people spend only a portion of their money on what they need to survive, with the rest on non-essentials. Purchasing decisions based on want—rather than need—aren’t always rational. Instead, personality, emotion, and trends influence these decisions. To keep up, marketers continuously investigate how individuals and groups make buying choices and respond to marketing techniques.
Political marketing is, in many ways, like product marketing: it plays on emotions and people’s desire for compelling stories, rather than pure rationality, and aims to condense complex issues into short, memorable soundbites. Smart politicians use marketing research to tailor their messages, connect with voters who share their values, and counter their opponents’ narrative.
Humans are social animals. We rely on a group to survive and are evolutionarily driven to follow the crowd. To learn what is “correct,” we look to others—a heuristic known as the social proof principle. Fads happen because we assume a product’s popularity signals value, boosting its popularity even further.
Natural or man-made disasters can trigger panic buying or hoarding, either before the disaster or after it has passed, usually of products deemed necessary for survival. In the weeks and months after a disaster, some evidence suggests that “hedonic purchases”—such as alcohol or unhealthy foods—rise as victims of the disaster attempt to cope.
After large-scale recessions, such as the Great Recession of 2007 to 2009, consumers typically become more frugal and price-sensitive. These changes become permanent for some consumers, especially among those who were particularly hard-hit; for others, behaviors revert back to baseline once the economy has stabilized and any personal financial challenges have been overcome.
It already has. Consumers are shifting more toward purchasing online and spending less on in-person events. Whether those changes will endure, though, is unclear. Some experts predict that most people will revert to old habits post-COVID; a small few, it’s predicted, will become more frugal and less materialistic in the long term.
The Psychology of Buying and Spending
Much of what people purchase—like food, shelter, or medical care—is necessary for their health and security. But what compels someone to buy unnecessary items, like the latest iPhone or an impractical pair of high-heeled shoes? The study of why people make such purchases—often irrational—is closely related to behavioral economics, which examines why people deviate from the most rational choice.
Behavioral economists, marketing professionals, and psychologists have concluded that extraneous purchases may be driven by a need to display social status or by responding to an emotion like sadness or boredom. Retailers may also manipulate the desire for a “good deal” by making an unneeded item seem especially affordable or portraying it as being in limited supply.
Learning how to recognize common manipulation tactics may help individuals and families save money—and stress—in the long term.
Many human behaviors are driven by reward. A new gadget or item of clothing triggers dopamine, which creates pleasure. Though the glow of a new purchase may not last long, the desire for repeated dopamine drives us to buy more.
It depends. Some research suggests that experiential purchases like vacations bring more happiness than material goods, in both the short and long term. However, this rule may not apply universally. For lower-income people, spending on material goods that meet basic needs can bring happiness, especially if the items remain useful over time.
Consumers are often irrational. Instead of just buying items they need, they also buy unnecessary items—often because the purchase makes them feel good, soothes negative emotions, or boosts social status. A consumer may also buy something framed as especially attractive by a marketer; “buy one, get one free” offers are hard to resist and encourage people to buy things they don’t need.
Certain impulses can ultimately be harmful, but they often serve a psychological purpose. Purchasing unhealthy foods or excessive alcohol, for instance, can temporarily offer comfort from painful emotions; buying a new pair of designer jeans might break the bank, but it can also help the purchaser prominently display their social status.
Dissonant buying impulses—purchases that conflict with one’s resources, needs, and goals—can be hard to manage, especially when driven by negative emotions. Learning emotional regulation skills—such as naming negative feelings, redirecting attention to productive activities, or practicing mindfulness—or creating physical “barriers” (such as freezing credit cards to avoid impulsive use) can help.
Anxiety is known to spur impulsive purchases—in part because buying things offers a sense of control and can be used to self-soothe. Anxiety can also lead someone to prioritize products that promote safety or a sense of security—such as toilet paper, hand sanitizer, or canned goods.
In a word, panic. Anxiety and fear make the world appear frightening and senseless; stocking up on certain items like toilet paper is one way to restore a feeling of control. Panic buying is also driven in part by herd mentality; if people see others hoarding hand sanitizer, they assume they should too.
Negative emotions may motivate Impulse buying, as purchasing something often temporarily boosts mood. Personality may drive this behavior—people naturally more impulsive or less conscientious may buy items on a whim. Marketing strategies, like advertising products as “limited-time offers,” can increase the tendency to impulse-buy.
How Advertising and Marketing Work
Two vast, interrelated industries—advertising and marketing—introduce people to products. And they convince people to make purchases.
The public’s desires change over time; however, what worked for one product’s campaign won’t necessarily work for another’s. To adapt messages for a fickle audience, advertisers employ focus groups, market research, and psychological studies to see what compels people to commit to purchases or become loyal to brands.
Everyone has heard the advertising maxim “sex sells,” for instance—but exactly what, when, and why sex can be used to market a product successfully is the subject of much debate among ad makers and behavioral researchers. Recently, some evidence has suggested that pitches to the perceived “lowest common denominator” may actually inspire consumer backlash.
Marketers regularly use psychology to convince consumers to buy. Common strategies include classical conditioning—training consumers to associate a product with certain cues through repeated exposure—creating a scarcity mindset (suggesting limited quantities), or using the principle of social proof to imply that everyone is buying a product—you should, too.
Marketers often exploit cognitive shortcuts, or heuristics, that influence consumers. One example is the anchoring bias, or the brain’s tendency to rely heavily on the first piece of information it learns. A savvy marketer may say a car costs $20,000, then quickly reduce the price by $1,000. The consumer is “anchored” on the initial $20,000 price tag; a $1,000 discount seems substantial, and the consumer may take the offer. But if the car were truly worth $15,000, it would still be overpriced, even with the supposed discount factored in.
Renowned marketing researcher Robert Cialdini found that we perceive advertisements very differently depending on our state of mind. Fearful consumers are more likely to respond negatively to ads that promote standing out in the crowd. However, consumers in a positive state of mind respond well to ads that encourage uniqueness; thus, timing and context are often critical to an ad’s success.
Limited-time offers feel urgent. Consumers then make quick decisions. A product only being available “for a limited time” (either at all or at a lower price) creates a sense of scarcity. Scarcity—whether real or manufactured—increases a product’s perceived value, heightening the chance of an impulsive purchase.
Because the majority of humans desire and seek out sex, sexual stimuli naturally capture attention; thus, marketers often make use of attractive models or erotic imagery to make consumers take notice. Being “primed” with erotic content can change behavior, too; research has found that sexual priming can lead consumers to make riskier financial choices.
The effectiveness of sex in advertising likely depends on several factors, including gender and context. Women appear to respond more negatively to sexual ads than men, research finds. When the product is unrelated to sex, using erotic imagery in ads can trigger dissonance and trigger negative feelings about the brand.
How to Appeal to Consumers
In a crowded marketplace, a product or service needs to stand out. To succeed, marketers often turn to psychological research to identify and target their most likely consumers, grab their attention, and convince them that a product will fill a specific need or otherwise improve their lives. Aiming to inform and persuade consumers—rather than manipulate them—is widely considered the most ethical approach and is likely to help build brand loyalty more than cheap marketing tricks.
Both the message and the messenger matter for persuasion. Marketing researcher Robert Cialdini has found that first impressions matter greatly—a company (or individual) that appears trustworthy and warm is more likely to gain its audience’s trust. Cialdini also coined the term “pre-suasion.” Marketers must grab consumers’ attention before appealing—by offering free samples or framing a product pitch in an amusing commercial.
Turning to psychology can help. Appealing to consumers’ emotions and desire for connection is often a powerful marketing strategy, as long as it is not manipulative. Introducing novelty can also be effective—research shows that consumers respond to surprising ads, humorous ads, or even “experiential” ads (such as parties or events designed to promote a product). Repeating an ad enough times for a consumer to remember it—but not so much that they become frustrated—is also critical to any effective ad campaign.
Humans are creatures of habit; we don't like change. To spread a new message or idea, advertisers have learned that simplicity is key. Overcomplicated appeals are frustrating or confusing. Summarizing the benefits of a new product, service, or political campaign in pithy, memorable phrases or images—and then repeating the message as often as possible—is more likely to grab consumers' attention and convince them to take a chance on a new object or idea.
Customers trust honest businesses. Honest entities share accurate information about everything from the benefits of using their products to how they run their business. Ethical marketing guidelines also include clearly distinguishing ads from other content types (news, entertainment), prioritizing the interests of children and other vulnerable groups (by not marketing unhealthy products to children, for example), avoiding negative stereotypes, and respecting consumers’ intelligence and privacy.