The Rare Truth About Sexual Compulsivity
Most alleged sex addicts aren’t addicted or out of control, just misinformed.
Posted Dec 01, 2019
Sexual compulsivity, also known as out-of-control sexual behavior, has been documented. So has being sexually turned on by bees—melissaphilia. Like melissaphilia, true sexual compulsivity is rare. It hardly ever appeared in the psychology literature until the 1980s after the coining of the term “sex addiction.” Since then, sex addiction has entered the lexicon. Many consider it prevalent and disastrous.
Today we have a tiny number of true sexual compulsives who do things like getting repeatedly arrested for public masturbation. We also have a large number who fear or believe or have been told they’re sex addicts. But oddly, when surveyed about what purported addicts actually do sexually, they don’t have any more sex or any wilder, less controlled sex than boatloads of people who feel certain they’re psychologically fine.
Why Men Self-Sex to Porn
So-called sex addicts are overwhelmingly men. Most men feel lustier than most women, and have most of their sex with themselves. They masturbate largely for stress relief. Why do men feel stressed? In part because of testosterone. The hormone causes tension and irritability. Researchers at Dennison University in Ohio asked 249 adults for all the reasons they had solo or partner sex. Among the women, 25 percent cited stress relief, among the men 80 percent.
Meanwhile, many women also masturbate, some frequently. More than half of adult American women own vibrators, and most use them only solo. But when stressed, women are more likely than men to cope non-sexually, for example, by talking with friends.
Some men also de-stress by conversing, exercising, playing video games, or watching sports. But many masturbate to pornography—girlie and porn magazines before the late-1990s, Internet porn since. Masturbation requires erotic fantasies. Men’s own get stale so they turn to the zillions available for free on porn sites. They ejaculate, which calms them. Then they return to their sane, functional, loving, in-control lives.
Many women cannot fathom why so many men feel such a deep need to polish pipe. Many also believe that only evil men watch porn. Actually, almost every man has and does. Canadian researchers wanted to compare sexual attitudes among men who had and had never watched porn. They couldn’t find a single adult man who hadn’t—not one.
The best research shows that around 25 percent of women think porn is a disgusting abomination. However, the vast majority of porn-watching men love and respect their mates. Stroking to videos is simply a way to feel entertained while managing their stress.
The Top Symptom of “Sex Addiction”
The number one symptom of “sex addiction” is masturbation to porn. But how much is too much? There’s no consensus. Everyone is sexually unique. If you’ve had more than one lover, were any two erotically identical? The more researchers explore human sexuality, the more diversity they find. And if everyone is sexually unique, beyond sex the legal system defines as criminal, who’s to say what’s normal or abnormal, healthy or harmful?
Some guys stroke to porn regularly and consider it an efficient way to manage their stress. Others do the exact same thing and decide they’re sex addicts—especially if their mates learn they self-sex to porn and label them.
The Main Culprit in Sexual Compulsivity
What distinguishes men who think self-sexing is fine from those who fear it’s pathological? Almost always religiosity. Those who consider themselves sex addicts usually come from fundamentalist backgrounds. They were raised to believe that sex should be reserved for having children and cementing holy wedlock, never just for fun, and especially never for self-sexing to porn.
Like all men, those who believe they’re sex addicts want sexual satisfaction, and have it solo. But they also believe this proves they’re deranged and on their way to Hell. They feel deeply conflicted, which causes great stress. When they get labeled sex addicts, they may become even more distraught. To calm themselves, guess what they do. Which fuels a vicious cycle resulting in emotional desperation.
The Cure for Purported Sex Addiction
Several studies have explored effective treatment for those convinced they’re sex addicts. The best approach is cognitive (a.k.a. cognitive behavioral) therapy. Cognitive means thinking. Cognitive therapy recognizes that severe distress can result from mistaken thoughts. By correcting faulty thinking, cognitive therapy reduces distress—and the behaviors distressed individuals use to cope.
Men labeled sex addicts typically hold beliefs that scientific sexology shows are mistaken, for example:
• Sexual thoughts and fantasies are wrong, harmful, sinful.
• Only bad people masturbate.
• Porn is evil.
On the contrary, cognitive therapists cite a great deal of research to show that:
• There’s nothing wrong with sexual thoughts and fantasies. Everyone has them. They’re perfectly normal and they enhance sex. There are no thought crimes. Accept your fantasies. Control your actions. In fantasy, everything is permitted and nothing is wrong.
• Everyone has masturbated and most people continue throughout life, particularly men who feel stressed. Unless self-sexing interferes with life responsibilities or partner lovemaking, it’s not a problem, no matter how frequent. Millions of normal, productive, loving, mentally healthy single—and coupled—men masturbate daily.
• Porn is not evil. It’s a cartoon version of men’s fantasies of effortless sexual abundance. Virtually every Internet-connected man on Earth has seen porn, many frequently, some daily or more.
Once sexually distressed men understand that their beliefs are mistaken, they usually calm down. They feel less anxious—and don’t feel the need to self-soothe as much by stroking to porn.
The Myth of Sex Addiction
When mates, clergy, or others call men sex addicts, the men rarely calm down. Confronted with such a scary label, they’re much more likely to feel more distressed—and self-soothe with one hand. Consequently, the term “sex addiction” does more harm than good. It’s not useful for correcting men’s mistaken thinking or soothing their emotional distress.
Over the past 70 years, psychological thinking about sexual compulsivity has changed considerably. In the 1950s and ’60s, the condition was considered rare and pathological. In the standard guide to mental health problems, the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM), the few sexually compulsive women were diagnosed with “nymphomania,” the few men with “satyriasis” (after the lusty satyrs in Greek mythology) or “Don Juanism” (after the fictional Spanish libertine).
Periodically, the nation’s mental health community has revised the DSM in light of compelling new research. Discussions about the most recent revisions began in 2003 and lasted 10 years. The process involved thousands of stakeholders who spent a decade reviewing and debating tens of thousands of studies.
Some argued in favor of including sex addiction in DSM-5 (2013). Others not only wanted that diagnosis excluded but also argued for the deletion of all diagnostic terms for sexual compulsivity based on many studies showing that very frequent sex by itself is not pathological. Some people really love sex, have a great deal more than others, and yet still live functional, loving, mentally healthy lives.
In the end, the large majority of mental health professionals rejected the whole idea of “sex addiction” and deleted all previous diagnostic terms. In addition, the main organization that credentials U.S. sex professionals now says: “We find insufficient evidence to support ‘sex addiction’ as a mental health disorder.”
Americans often use the term “addiction” loosely. Coffee lovers are java junkies, chocolate lovers chocoholics. But as far as most mental health professionals are concerned, the idea of sex addiction belongs in the trash.
If you were raised in a fundamentalist Christian home and fear you might be sexually compulsive, I urge you read Advancing Sexual Health for the Christian Client by Rev. Beverly Dale and Rachel Keller, both evangelical Christians, who deftly cite Christian Scripture to correct fundamentalists’ mistaken sexual beliefs. They wrote the book for therapists, but it's very accessible to the general public, particularly those Christians who fear they're sexually compulsive.
Facebook image: Photographee.eu/Shutterstock
Carroll K. et al. “Differences Between Males and Females in Motives for Engaging in Sexual Intercourse,” Archives of Sexual Behavior (1985) 14:131.
Cranney, S. and A. Stulhofer. “‘Whosoever Looketh on a Person to Lust After Them:’ Religiosity, Use of Mainstream and Non-Mainstream Sexually Explicit Material, and Sexual Satisfaction in Heterosexual Men and Women,” Journal of Sex Research (2017) 54:694.
Grubbs, J.B. et al. “Internet Pornography Use, Perceived Addiction, and Religious/Spiritual Struggles,” Archives of Sexual Behavior (2017) 46:1733.
Hallberg, J. et al. “A Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy Group Intervention for Hypersexual Disorder: A Feasibility Study,” Journal of Sexual Medicine (2017) 14:950.
Kellett, S. et al. “Testing the Effectiveness of Cognitive Analytic Therapy for Hypersexuality Disorder: An Intensive Time-Series Evaluation,” Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy (2017) 43:501.
Klontz, B.T. et al. “The Effectiveness of Brief Multimodal Experiential Therapy in the Treatment of Sexual Addiction,” Sexual Addiction and Compulsivity (2005) 4:275.
Leonhardt, N.D.et al. “Damaged Goods: Perception of Pornography Addiction as a Mediator Between Religiosity and Relationship Anxiety Surrounding Pornography Use,” Journal of Sex Research (2018) 55:357.
Perry, S.L. and A.L. Whitehead. “Only Bad for Believers? Religion, Pornography Use, and Sexual Satisfaction Among American Men,” Journal of Sex Research (2019) 56:50.