The Dark Side of Digital Show and Tell
Determining whether photo sharing or sexting involves consent or coercion
Posted Nov 08, 2019
Posting, sending, and receiving sexually explicit texts and emails can be risky business—but it's something that many people decide to do. Why? Although some engage willingly, others do not. Compromising material is often sent under pressure, as a result of partner persuasion and manipulation.
Does Digital Show-and-Tell Involve Consent or Coercion?
G-rated photo sharing is common among prospective paramours who are getting to know each other. Sharing photos of family, pets, vacations, and even high school memories can be a natural, wholesome aspect of becoming acquainted.
Yet it happens. Many romantic relationships involve intimate photo sharing—either willingly or under some type of duress. The mere fact that a sexually explicit photo was sent does not automatically mean the sender wanted to share it. Some senders are persuaded to sext with partners as a result of persuasion, manipulation, or coercion.
In addition to anxiety over inadvertent or intentional disclosure of compromising text messages or photos, research indicates that coerced sexting is also linked with darker consequences, such as intimate partner aggression and negative mental health.
Sexting Coercion and Intimate Partner Victimization
Jody M. Ross et al. in “Sexting Coercion as a Component of Intimate Partner Polyvictimization” (2019) examined the role of sexting coercion within the larger issue of intimate partner abuse (IPA).[i] They define “sexting,” which they note is a combination of “sex” and “texting,” as the “sending of sexually explicit messages or images by cell phone.”
They note that sexting may be defined broadly, as related activity may include filming and sending explicit self-videos, or using social media to send sexual content. Adding the additional element of coercion, Ross et al. defined sexting coercion to include “experiencing coercion from an intimate partner to send sexually explicit text messages.”
In their research, they used a sample of 885 young adults (301 males and 584 females) to investigate whether sexting coercion was a form of intimate partner aggression that could create a risk of sexual, psychological, and attachment problems. In their sample, 40 percent had experienced coercion with respect to sexual behavior or sexting—or both. In terms of gender differences, women were more likely than men to have been coerced into sexting behavior.
Ross et al. conclude that their data suggests that digital sexual victimization constitutes a new component of “IPA polyvictimization,” with the potential to increase negative effects experienced by individuals who are subjected to intimate partner aggression in multiple forms.
Sexting Coercion and Negative Mental Health
Specifically, Ross et al. found coercive sexting to be linked to attachment dysfunction, sexual problems, and more generally, symptoms of negative mental health. As compared to other forms of dating aggression, they note the unique potential of sexting coercion, especially when it prompts unwanted sexting, to produce future psychological trauma because of the victim's concern and anxiety about the recipient sharing the images.
The Relationship Between Sexual Coercion and Coerced Sexting
Other research links sexual coercion and coerced sexting. HyeJeong Choi et al. (2016) examined the association between sexual coercion and sexting in adolescent women.[ii]Using a sample of 450 females from ethnically diverse backgrounds and an average of 19 years old, they found that in-person sexual coercion was significantly associated with being asked to send a naked image, as well as receiving one. They conclude that sexting can function as “an online extension of offline forms of sexual coercion.”
Poco D. Kernsmith et al. in a piece entitled “Online, Offline, and Over the Line” (2018) studied the relationship between coercive sexting and other maladaptive dating behaviors in young people.[iii]They found coercive sexting was more frequent in high school than at younger ages and found boys were more likely to pressure a partner to sext than were girls. They also found coercive sexting to be associated with other types of sexual coercion including insisting on unprotected sex, and the use of threats.
Freedom From Coercion
Wholesome relationships are free from coercion in any form. Research reveals that sexting coercion is a maladaptive relational dynamic linked to sexual coercion, as well as negative outcomes both psychologically and possibly physically. Healthy relationships, in contrast, allow both partners to thrive and grow in a comfortable atmosphere of mutual trust and respect.
[i] Ross, Jody M., Michelle Drouin, and Amanda Coupe. 2019. “Sexting Coercion as a Component of Intimate Partner Polyvictimization.” Journal of Interpersonal Violence 34 (11): 2269–91. doi:10.1177/0886260516660300.
[ii]Choi, HyeJeong, Joris Van Ouytsel, and Jeff R. Temple. 2016. “Association between Sexting and Sexual Coercion among Female Adolescents.” Journal of Adolescence 53 (December): 164–68. doi:10.1016/j.adolescence.2016.10.005.
[iii]Kernsmith, Poco D., Bryan G. Victor, and Joanne P. Smith-Darden. 2018. “Online, Offline, and Over the Line: Coercive Sexting Among Adolescent Dating Partners.” Youth & Society 50, no. 7: 891–904. doi:10.1177/0044118X18764040.