Skip to main content

Verified by Psychology Today

Eating Disorders

Hope and Hesitation in the Journey of Anorexia Recovery

Moving forward by embracing ambivalence in anorexia treatment.

Key points

  • When we uncover the "benefits" of anorexia, we take a step towards recovery.
  • The anorexic wish delves into the desire to stay thin while yearning for physical and emotional health.
  • Through an attuned treatment approach, using compassion and validation, we navigate ambivalence in therapy.
  • Expanding self-evaluation means strengthening domains well beyond food and weight control.

Anorexia is like having a distorted mirror in your mind that makes you see yourself as bigger than you really are. It's this relentless fear of gaining weight that drives people to skip meals or eat very little, sometimes to the point of starvation. But it's not just about wanting to be thin; it's also this constant battle with yourself, feeling like you're never thin enough. Anorexia can be devastating, impacting your mental and physical health along with your relationships and career.

But My Anorexia Feels So Good

One of the biggest challenges in treating anorexia nervosa is that individuals often hold onto aspects of the disorder that they experience as positive or beneficial. These perceived "benefits" invariably create resistance to treatment and make it difficult for individuals to fully commit to recovery.

It may be surprising to some, but there are many aspects of anorexia that people find gratifying. There can be pride in the sense of control anorexia offers, both in terms of body control and more general feelings of control in one’s life. There can be a sense of achievement associated with weight loss in a culture that values thinness. Individuals with anorexia often get attention and validation from unsuspecting acquaintances for adhering to strict dietary habits. The food management of anorexia and the never-ending quest for thinness may serve as a distraction from underlying emotional pain and sometimes even a substitute for emotional connection. Often, people with anorexia form their identity around being thin or disciplined. All of these aspects, while providing temporary relief or validation, ultimately perpetuate the disorder and pose significant risks to physical and mental health.

The Anorexic Wish: To Feel Better but Stay Thin

A great example of ambivalence in anorexia recovery is what can be referred to as “the anorexic wish.” The anorexic wish is the desire to stay thin but restore both physical and emotional health. There's often a genuine desire to recover and reclaim one's health, happiness, and autonomy, but not at the expense of weight gain. Individuals may recognize the toll that anorexia has taken on their physical and mental well-being, as well as its impact on their relationships, goals, and overall quality of life. They may long for freedom from the relentless cycle of food and weight obsessions, the isolation of their illness, and the constant fear of physical deterioration or death. Still, however, there’s a profound fear of gaining weight or losing control over one's body, fueled by the pervasive societal emphasis on thinness and the internalized belief that being thin equates to worthiness, success, or acceptance. This desire to maintain a thin body may be intertwined with a sense of identity and self-esteem, making it challenging to let go of even when faced with the negative consequences of the eating disorder.

Addressing Ambivalence in Anorexia Treatment

Navigating this dual desire to stay thin while also wanting to get well requires a compassionate and individualized approach in treatment. Therapists work collaboratively with individuals to explore and validate their conflicting emotions and motivations, helping them untangle the complex web of thoughts and feelings that underlie their eating disorder. This may involve addressing core psychological challenges, such as low self-esteem, perfectionism, or trauma, that contribute to the fear of weight gain and the need for control. The therapeutic space remains a place where individuals feel heard and understood, free from judgment or pressure to change.

In overcoming ambivalence about recovery, therapists help individuals challenge distorted beliefs about body image and worth, fostering a more flexible and compassionate relationship with food, exercise, and their bodies. Through cognitive-behavioral techniques, such as cognitive restructuring and exposure therapy, individuals learn to challenge the irrational fears and beliefs driving their eating disorder while gradually reintroducing nourishing behaviors and self-care practices.

Expanding How You See—and Value—Yourself

An important additional feature of treatment is the expansion of what we call “domains for self-evaluation.” Enhancing domains for self-evaluation in eating disorder treatment refers to identifying and strengthening specific areas of an individual's life—outside of food and weight control—that contribute to their sense of self-worth, identity, and overall well-being. These domains are targeted to help individuals develop a more balanced and positive self-image, which is crucial for recovery from eating disorders like anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, or binge-eating disorder.

The Delicate Balance

Ultimately, recovery from anorexia involves finding a balance between honoring one's desire for thinness and prioritizing one's overall health and well-being. It's a journey of self-discovery and self-compassion, guided by the understanding that true healing comes from nurturing the body, mind, and spirit in harmony.

Navigating ambivalence in anorexia treatment requires a delicate balance of compassion, patience, and understanding. It's essential to acknowledge the conflicting emotions individuals may experience as they confront the daunting journey of recovery. By fostering a supportive environment that respects autonomy and honors the struggle, we can help empower those affected by anorexia to gradually embrace the possibility of healing and embark on a path toward reclaiming their lives. Progress may not be linear, but every step forward, no matter how small, is a triumph worth celebrating on the road to recovery.

To find a therapist near you, visit the Psychology Today Therapy Directory.

More from Melissa Gerson LCSW
More from Psychology Today