Why You Shouldn’t Compliment Someone on Weight Loss

Source: Priscilla Du Preez on Unsplash

In a world that values appearance, complimenting someone on their weight loss might seem harmless or even positive. However, as an eating disorder specialist, I see firsthand the harm such comments can cause. Even well-intentioned compliments on weight can reinforce unhealthy societal beliefs and send damaging messages about a person’s worth.

The Problem With Weight Loss Compliments

When you comment on someone’s weight loss, you may unknowingly reinforce the idea that thinner bodies are better, more attractive, or healthier. This belief stems from diet culture, which glorifies thinness and stigmatizes larger bodies. But the truth is that body diversity is part of the natural human experience. Just as people have different heights, skin colors, or hair textures, bodies naturally come in all shapes and sizes.

The notion that "thin is better" isn’t a universal truth; it’s a socially constructed ideal that has evolved over time. Society has created a false hierarchy that places thin bodies at the top, promoting the harmful idea that a person’s worth or health can be measured by their size. Complimenting weight loss often reinforces this false hierarchy and sends the message that thinness is something to strive for, regardless of the potential impact on a person's health or mental well-being.

When someone is praised for losing weight, we don’t know the full story behind the change. Weight loss can result from illness, stress, grief, or unhealthy behaviors like disordered eating. Complimenting weight loss can, therefore, unintentionally validate harmful actions or reinforce body dissatisfaction, particularly for those who may already be struggling with their relationship with food and their body.

Health Is More Than Appearance

One of the biggest misconceptions is that losing weight is always a sign of improved health. But health cannot be judged by appearance alone. Many factors, like mental health, genetics, and lifestyle, contribute to someone’s overall health. For example, a person may lose weight because they are dealing with chronic illness or emotional distress, not because they’ve made healthy choices.

Focusing on someone's weight dismisses these complexities and reinforces the misleading idea that smaller bodies are automatically healthier or more disciplined. Instead of praising changes in appearance, we should focus on more meaningful aspects of a person’s character, strengths, or accomplishments.

Compliments That Don’t Focus on Weight

If you want to show appreciation or compliment someone, there are many ways to do so that don’t focus on appearance. Here are some thoughtful and meaningful alternatives:

1. "I really appreciate the energy you bring to our conversation." Noticing someone’s positive presence can help them feel recognized for the way they engage with others.
2. “You have a great sense of humor; it always adds something to the moment.” Highlighting someone’s personality shifts the focus from appearance and acknowledges what makes them enjoyable to be around.
3. “You’ve been navigating some tough situations with a lot of strength and composure.” Acknowledging someone's resilience can show that you see and respect their ability to handle challenges.
4. “Your creativity really stands out in the work you do.” Complimenting someone’s unique talents or passions emphasizes what they contribute rather than how they look.
5. “You are very thoughtful and caring.” Noticing someone’s kindness acknowledges the positive ways they interact with others.
6. “I love how you’ve put together your outfit today.” Complimenting someone’s style or how they express themselves through clothing allows for a positive comment on appearance without focusing on body size.
7. “I feel like you truly listen when we talk, and I appreciate that.” Recognizing someone’s ability to listen well highlights the importance of connection and communication in relationships.

Moving Away from Weight-Centric Thinking

Before offering a compliment related to someone’s appearance, consider how it might affect them. Many people live with body-image struggles, disordered eating, or self-esteem issues that are directly tied to societal pressure to look a certain way. By steering clear of weight-focused comments, we can help shift the cultural narrative away from thinness as a measure of worth. Instead, we can focus on celebrating people for their contributions, personality, and character. By doing this, we help create a world in which individuals feel valued for who they are rather than how they look.

Ultimately, a person’s value is not defined by their weight or shape. Let’s change the conversation and offer compliments that recognize the qualities that truly matter—like kindness, resilience, and the positive impact they have on others. These are the things worth celebrating.