Why Your Boundaries Aren't Working

Does setting boundaries even work?

Source: MangoStar_Studio/iStock Photo

"I've tried setting boundaries, but nothing changes."

I hear this from clients constantly, usually delivered with a mixture of frustration and defeat. They've read the books, practiced the scripts, and attempted to draw lines in the sand. Yet somehow, they're still fielding calls from demanding relatives, working weekends for ungrateful bosses, and feeling like human doormats in their closest relationships.

Here's the uncomfortable truth: boundaries without leverage are just suggestions.

The Leverage Nobody Talks About

My client Tanya discovered this when she tried to limit her mother's constant calling. Her mom would phone multiple times daily, becoming increasingly agitated if Tanya didn't answer immediately. The calls disrupted work meetings, date nights, and any semblance of personal space.

"I told her I could only talk once a day," Tanya explained, "and she acted like I'd asked her to disappear forever."

Tanya kept trying different approaches—gentler language, compromise solutions, elaborate explanations of why the boundary was necessary. Nothing worked because Tanya was missing the crucial element: her mother had no reason to respect the boundary.

Think about it this way: if someone consistently ignores your clearly stated limits and faces no consequences, why would they change?

The Uncomfortable Reality of Relationship Dynamics

Research on family systems shows that entrenched patterns resist change unless there's sufficient pressure to motivate new behaviors. In psychology, this is called "systems thinking"—the idea that relationships exist in delicate balance, and when one person changes their role, the entire system must adapt.

But adaptation only happens when the alternative—losing the relationship or facing meaningful consequences—becomes less appealing than changing.

Tanya's breakthrough came when she stopped trying to manage her mother's feelings about the boundary and started managing her own behavior instead. She called once daily at a time that worked for her. When her mother called outside that window, Tanya didn't answer—no matter what the "emergency" was. (She knew real crises would reach her through other family members.)

At first, the response was exactly what Tanya feared: anger, guilt trips, the silent treatment, and dramatic declarations that Tanya was destroying their relationship. But eventually, because Tanya kept to her plan, her mom mostly came around. She still attempted to contact Tanya more than once a day, but the guilt-tripping and accusations that Tanya is an unloving daughter stopped.

The Trauma Exception That Isn't

One of the biggest obstacles to effective boundaries is the belief that we should accommodate bad behavior if it stems from someone's past trauma. I often observe this in romantic relationships, where one partner's past behavior becomes a justification for present-day misconduct.

While past experiences profoundly shape us, they don't excuse harmful behavior in our current relationships. The idea that trauma absolves people of responsibility for their actions actually perpetuates cycles of dysfunction rather than healing them. Think about it this way: if someone is acting out in their current relationship based on their past trauma, they are no longer the victim—they are the perpetrator.

My clients Lisa and Matt illustrate this perfectly. When Lisa attended a work conference and didn't immediately return Matt's calls, he left 52 increasingly threatening voicemails in three hours. His explanation? His mother had left his father for another man when Matt was 6, so he was "triggered" by any perceived abandonment.

Boundaries Essential Reads

4 Boundaries You Need to Set During a Breakup

How to Keep Your Cool Around Pushy People

Lisa initially accepted this logic, telling herself that Matt's childhood justified his behavior. But as I pointed out to her: "What's it like to be punished for something Matt's mother did 20 years ago—something you've never done and would never do?"

The tears that followed told the whole story.

Real Leverage vs. Empty Threats

Effective boundaries require meaningful consequences—outcomes that actually matter to the other person. This might mean:

• Ending conversations that become abusive.
• Refusing to cover for irresponsible colleagues.
• Declining invitations from consistently disrespectful friends.
• Being genuinely willing to end relationships that can't be repaired.

The key word here is "genuinely." People can sense when you're bluffing, and empty threats actually weaken your position by proving you won't follow through.

When Lisa finally told Matt she wouldn't tolerate accusations of infidelity, name-calling, or multiple angry messages, she meant it. When he used the silent treatment as punishment after another series of missed phone calls, she didn't chase him or try to smooth things over. She told him to move out.

The Freedom of Real Choices

Leverage isn't about punishing others—it's about believing you have choices. When you truly know you could leave a job, end a friendship, or distance yourself from family members who consistently disrespect you, you can meaningfully change your life.

You stop walking on eggshells. You stop operating as the "shock absorber" to manage other people's emotions. You start speaking honestly because you're not terrified of the consequences.

This doesn't mean becoming harsh or abandoning everyone at the first sign of conflict. It means operating from a place of genuine choice rather than trapped obligation.

Your Turn: The Leverage Assessment

Take a moment to examine your most challenging relationship. Ask yourself:

1. What boundary have you tried to set that isn't being respected?
2. What consequences does this person face when they ignore your boundary? (Be honest—if the answer is "none," you've found your problem.)
3. What are you genuinely willing to do if the behavior continues?
4. What story are you telling yourself about why you "can't" implement meaningful consequences?
5. If this relationship never improved, could you live with that?

The last question is crucial. If your answer is "no, I absolutely couldn't handle it," then you don't have leverage—you have desperation. And desperate people can't set effective boundaries.

Remember: healthy relationships require two people who choose to be there. When someone knows you'll stay no matter how they treat you, they have little motivation to treat you well. But when they know you're there by choice, not obligation, the whole dynamic shifts.

Your boundaries aren't failing because you're doing them wrong. They're failing because they lack teeth. And sometimes, the most loving thing you can do—for yourself and the other person—is to show them you're serious.