I’ve written previously about the benefits of a high-performance workplace. Others have produced reams of copy on how to motivate employees and achieve maximum efficiency. Many advocate complex bonus systems or other perks and rewards.

None of these are wrong, but I often suggest another strategy that surprises a lot of people: get rid of the bad employees. It may be harsh, but it’s also true: The best thing you can do for your good workers and your company is to separate under-performing and marginal workers.

Statistically, there always are employees who seem disengaged or apathetic and some who are even working against the organization. Then there are those who are impaired by drugs or drink. Some may have problems that may, in some circumstances, be a danger to themselves or other employees. They should be separated from the company.

Another group is even more difficult: Those who are not bad enough to terminate, but aren’t good enough to be retained. These are the marginal producers.

Marginal employees produce errors, inaccuracies and affect the morale of the work group. These employees demand a larger percentage of managerial attention. Sometimes, they benefit from a wake-up call from their supervisor, but often they just lower the standards for the rest of the work group. Identifying and dealing with these employees may be among the most difficult challenges that managers face.

In many companies, the problem is simply ignored. But a marginal employee’s co-workers know who the trailing workers are and expect something appropriate to be done. When something is not done, they tend to turn on the manager for his/her dereliction.

How do you get rid of the marginal producer? The traditional way is to watch them fail, document the failure, tell them what they are doing that is failing and give them time to fix it. If they still fail, document it again, tell them what they need to fix and give them more time to fix it. If they continue to fail, then you can terminate. Still, be ready for a fight with the State Human Rights Commission or the EEOC. Legal battles are widespread here.

There is a better way. Let the marginal employee know that they are failing and on a path that will lead to termination. Tell them that just because they cannot make it with your organization does not mean that they cannot make it elsewhere. A termination will stain their record and will have to be explained for years to come, but a voluntary resignation can be explained. Assure them that if they resign, you will give them a neutral reference but that a termination gets the straight treatment. If they are terminated, that is what gets stated on any reference check. Explain that this may be their best shot at clearing their opportunities for the future.

Terminations are never easy, but negotiating win-win solutions like this are usually best for everyone. It’s certainly better than watching your organization go downhill.

You are reading

Worked Up At Work

Toxic Employee: Stop It or Leave

You can ignore toxic workplace behavior, but it won't go away.

Don’t Try to Kill a Dragon With One Arrow

Don't wait until a problem is so bad you're almost certain to make it worse

Seasons Change. So Do Laws and Regulations

Workplace policies must change with new laws and regulations—and that's tough!