Polish boy

As a boy in middle childhood, I'm skeptical of your supposed rule exception.

Some creativity advice involves "getting in touch with your inner child." It's the idea is that children are more creative than adults. Is this true?

Ellen Winner reports in her book Invented Worlds that before preschool years, children are quite creative with similies. They might say something like "quiet as a magic marker." But after the preschool years, they start using conventional similies, such as "quiet as a mouse." Interestingly, this is when school starts, and when kids start getting interested in social rules, both ones they create (in games with other children) as well as as the rules of the adult world. Middle childhood is characterized by a fierce conventionalism—they might object to a female wearing male clothing even more than an adult would. It's only with age that they loosen up about rules and see nuance. 

Early childhood is when we see the most creative "pretend play," in which children actively create their own imaginary worlds. These games, if you even want to call them that, can involve other people in a shared imagined experience, but are often non-competitive. After age five, though, they start getting interested in games with rules, and you'll see them argue about the rules and who is or is not following them. 

If you're getting in touch with your inner child, make sure your inner child is young enough. 

Reference:

Winner, E. (1982). Invented worlds: The psychology of the arts. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Recent Posts in The Science of Imagination

What Happens to Consciousness When Your Brain Splits?

How many instances of consciousness can one brain have?

The Psychology of Hating the Star Wars Prequels

Why do people hate the Star Wars prequels? We might never really know.

Is It Possible to Feel Sympathy For Many People at Once?

Our feelings respond to images, not numbers.

Do You Think You're a Bad Writer?

We have prejudices about what skills require practice.

Man's Search for Meaning and Korean Karaoke

Why does our mind search for meaning even when there isn't any?

Is This Documentary Fair?

What does it mean for a presentation of arguments to be fair?