Narcissists love - and hate - themselves deep, deep down.

Years and years ago, psychoanalytic thinkers (like Freud) argued that an inflated sense of self-worth (like in narcissism) reflects implicit, unconscious, dislike for oneself.

In a study published by W Keith Campbell, a psychology professor at the University of Georgia, and colleagues similar ideas were tested. Specifically, people were asked to rate themselves on both agentic and communal traits. Agentic traits reflect perceptions of power and ability, and communal traits include reflect kindness, generousity and cooperation. These traits were measured both at an implicit (unconscious, automatic) level and at an explicit (conscious, reflective) level. All participants were also given a scale to determine their level of narcissism.

Did narcissists hate themselves deep, deep down, like Frued would've have guessed? Well the answer is yes - and no.

Not surprisingly, explicitly, narcissists reported highly positive perceptions of their agentic traits. They also had positive implicit self-esteem on these agentic traits. That is, in terms of traits like dominant and assertive, narcissists implicitly and explicitly scored higher than other people. Frued then, was wrong about narcissists uniformly hating themselves implicitly.

However, Frued was right in one way - narcissism was unrelated to implicit self-esteem on the communal traits (kind, generous). That is, narcissists did not like themselves, deep, deep down on these traits. Interestingly, narcissism was also unrelated to explicit ratings on communal traits.

In combination, these results suggest, contrary to what many might believe, that narcissists do not love themselves on all traits. They think they are powerful and dominant, but not kind and generous. And further, these same attitudes exist at an implicit, automatic level.

Narcissists do love themselves - sort of -- both at an implicit and explicit level.

Reference:

http://www.sakkyndig.com/psykologi/artvit/campbell2007.pdf

Recent Posts in The Big Questions

Paying it Forward

Greed begets greed more than generosity begets generosity

Wanting to Feel Good, Familiar or Useful?

The appeal of familiar and useful emotions

Facebook Rainbows

On Why Gay Pride Support on Facebook Matters

The Body as (Part of) Protest

Protesting the Religious Freedom Act

The Eyes Reveal our Sexual Orientation

Pupil dilation and sexual arousal

Hope Floats

Feeling hopeful when pondering death