President Obama has joined President Bush in opposing the widest possible access for Emergency Contraception (Plan B). And he's done it for the two worst possible reasons: emotion and "common sense."
After years and years of dishonest stalling, the FDA has finally recommended that minors get complete over-the-counter access to Plan B. In a rare move, the HHS Secretary overruled the FDA's decision. The President says he supports Secretary Sebelius' decision, "as the father of two young daughters...we [should] apply some common sense to various rules when it comes to over-the-counter medicine."
This is anti-science doubletalk.
During the dark Bush years, the federal government stalled the availability of this miracle drug for adults, which was already being used safely in Europe. The objections have generally come from the religious community, "decency" crowd, and those who pretend to want a smaller role for government. After they exhaust their morality pitch, they simply lie. They say Plan B is an abortion drug (it isn't), and that it will promote "promiscuity" because it lowers the perceived cost of reckless sex (data from both Europe and the US show it doesn't).
The terror of "promiscuity" is the same argument used against the HPV vaccine, legal abortion, condom distribution in schools, contraceptive insurance coverage, and every other public policy measure designed to make sex safer or more enjoyable:
Some argue that young teens can't be trusted to use Plan B properly. That's undoubtedly true for some of them. But we let them have access to a lot of things in the drug store that they might not use properly: tampons, razor blades, ipecac. And there's nothing they can do with Plan B that will be as dangerous and life-damaging as carrying an unwanted pregnancy to term, much less getting an illegal abortion.
Every fertile person, regardless of age, should have Emergency Contraception in their medicine cabinet. It's for an emergency, get it?
Mr. President, when you were elected you promised us science and rationality. I don't want you making public decisions as a father, a husband, a Hawaiian, or a basketball fan. I want science from you and your administration. Save your "common sense" for the dinner table. And if you have any, make sure your kids understand Plan B.
And as a reminder: the most dangerous thing the average 13-year-old does is ride a bike while talking on a cell phone. You might want to talk to Malia about that, too.