What Does He Mean By That? by Isadora Alman,MFT

In my more than 25 years of writing an advice column I regularly get asked several different versions of "When a woman does Y, what does that mean?" or "My husband did X.  What did he mean by that?" 

There seems to be an underlying notion that there is a definitive handbook on human behavior,  perhaps passed out to everyone  in high school on a day you happened to be absent from class.  Therefore, everyone else knows something about people and their motives about which you have no clue.  That's the only assumption I can make about why a person might think a stranger or even a the consensus of group of strangers might have an understanding of the actions of someone he or she knows very well but I don't know at all.

Human beings are strange.  They do things for the strangest reasons.  Often, they have no idea themselves why they do things.  They just did it, acted on impulse.  If you ask someone why he did it, he will often make up some plausible reason on the spot – plausible to himself and/or to you.  Now you have your reason, but you need to know that there is no deep, well-planned thought behind it. They probably just made it up because they were asked.

I have a mentor who began training me in communication skills back in the 70's.  One of his many pithy pieces of wisdom is "Why is a lie".  What that means is exactly what I said in the previous paragraph.  Whatever anyone tells you about the reasons for their behavior was probably just made up on the spot, often to make the speaker look good.  "Why did you do that?"  "I have no idea" makes someone come across a dim bulb, to say the least.

If you want to know why someone behaves they way they do, says what they said, or is the way they usually are, the only possible person to explain why that is would be that person him or herself.   He's the one to ask, or she is.  Not your friends.  Certainly not a stranger. But now you know that once you have an answer, even one that even kind of makes sense to you, you still may not know much that you didn’t know before you asked!  You're probably better off coming up with a hypothesis of your own and then testing it out.  An in-home science project with your nearest and dearest. It will certainly liven things up between you.

My own preference about attributing motives to people’s behaviors, since I am unlikely to ever know the truth for certain, is to make up an explanation that feels good to me and decide to believe it without question.  “Why is that person over there giggling and looking at me?”  It could be because I’m ugly and my mother dresses me funny.  Is that a thought likely to make me feel good?  Even if I asked the giggler and my guess about the cause of merriment was spot on, is that person likely to tell me so to my face?  Not likely. So I can decide that the cause of such mirth is utter delight at seeing someone as lovely as I.  That’s not any more likely, of course, but I can amuse myself with the possibility (which can become a certainty the longer I entertain it). That person may be, and probably is, totally unaware of my existence, but I now can walk away with a smile on my face too.

What does he mean by that? Sheesh, I don’t know, but isn’t the power of positive thinking grand?

You are reading

Sex & Sociability

Requiem For Leon, A Cat

A eulogy for a beloved cat companion.

Sex and the Abuse of Power

Men in power often take advantage of women because they can. Are you surprised?

Can You Remain Friends With Your Ex?

Maybe I should ask "Can YOU"? I usually can because it's important to me.