Should happiness or productivity be the measure of whether you’ve lived a good life?

Marty Nemko thinks that the answer is productivity.  As he points out in his latest book What’s The Big Idea: Reinventions for a Better America: “the extent to which you have left the world better is, in my view, the most valid criterion for assessing whether you’ve lived a worthwhile life.”

Instead of filling our lives with things that might make us happy in the moment like video games, movies, tasty foods, fancy clothes, vacations, or a nice car, he recommends that we live life by using The Meter.  The idea is simple yet powerful:

Selling drugs to kids would register a -10.

Playing a video game would register a 0.

Working to cure a disease would register a +10.

Marty thinks we should live our lives by always asking ourselves how our next activity would register on the meter.

I think that just about everyone will be unable to register a +10 or even a positive number on the meter with every block of time they have, no matter how hardworking or well-meaning they are.  However, I do see the value of repeatedly considering whether our next actions will add to, take away, or do nothing for society.  I also can see how productivity directed at making the world a better place might lead to genuine personal happiness and fulfillment.

What do you think?

© 2013 by Jonathan Wai

You can follow me on Twitter, Facebook, or G+. For more of Finding the Next Einstein: Why Smart is Relative go here.

Recent Posts in Finding the Next Einstein

Igniting a Renaissance

How do we parent and educate determined and intelligent children?

The Power of Wisdom to Enact Social Change

Will technology really solve our problems? A conversation with Kentaro Toyama

As A Nation, How Can We Best Empower Our Gifted Kids?

What is the impact of educational acceleration?

Does It Really Matter Where You Go to College?

Frank Bruni may be wrong about elite schools

Love the Child, Not the Gift

A conversation with Sidney Moon and Felicia Dixon

What Happens to Students on the Fast Track to College?

Research on students entering college early shows generally positive effects