Permission of Sy Montgomery and Liz Thomas
Source: Permission of Sy Montgomery and Liz Thomas

A few months ago, I was pleased to be asked to write an endorsement for Sy Montgomery and Elizabeth Marshall Thomas's new book called Tamed & Untamed: Close Encounters of the Animal Kind. As I read through the numerous stories written by these incredibly gifted writers, I found myself enjoying a most delectable potpourri of tales about a whole host of nonhuman animals. And, what was especially pleasing, is that they are consistent with what we have learned, and are continuing to learn, from researchers who are interested in the field of cognitive ethology, or the study of animal minds and animal emotions.

Permission of the publisher
Source: Permission of the publisher

Sy and Liz and have long been among my favorite authors, so I reached out to them to see if they could take the time to answer a few questions. Gladly, they said "yes." Liz's answers are in regular font and Sy's answers follow in italics. Our interview went as follows:

Why did you write Tamed and Untamed?

Liz: Tamed & Untamed is a collection of columns we wrote for The Boston Globe. This ended, we believe, because The Globe canceled the section of the paper they appeared in. We began to write the columns at the suggestion of Vicki Croke who at the time worked for The Globe and also has written the introduction for Tamed & Untamed, so the collaboration really involves three close friends, not just two.

As for the subjects, all of us are fascinated with the natural world and the life-forms in it, especially the animals. To us, animals are often more interesting than people, and are all we want to write about, so these opportunities were a blessing.

Sy: The Globe gave us a tremendous opportunity. We loved writing the column and the connection with enthusiastic readers. For this volume, in addition to the columns, we wrote a number of original pieces including opening essays for each of the six sections of the book: Animals and People, Birds, Dogs and Cats, Wild Animals, Tiny Animals, and Animal Abilities. 

How did you, two very gifted writers, divvy up the stories?

We took turns. Sy wrote the first week’s column, I wrote the next, and so on, each of us deciding what our subject would be. Sy knows more than I do and she has studied more animals, so Sy has a wider variety of subjects.

Not! Liz knows way more than I do, about animals and pretty much everything else. In addition to living among lions, hyenas, leopards, wolves, dogs, cats, and others, Liz has also carefully studied people—she researched her book about the Bushmen (now called the San) of Etosha desert of Namibia, before I was born; her first book, The Harmless People, was a national best seller and National Book Award finalist before I could speak. Liz observed the smart, skilled Bushmen with whom she lived with not only with fresh eyes but also with affection and respect. That, believe it or not, was quite uncommon among anthropologists writing about their “study subjects” in the 1950s. She brings this same open mind and open heart to her observations of other species.         

I love how you wove scientific findings into your array of diverse stories on so many different animals. Why is it important to do this?

Knowledge of animals comes from two directions—one from what one learns from scientists, the other from one’s own experience and observation. Sy has the soul of a journalist, so whatever she says is scientifically solid. She’s written books in a series called Scientists in the Field, combining the scientist’s work with observations of the animals under study, and she’s just finished a book, The Magnificent Migration, about wildebeests and Richard D. Estes, the scientist who knows most about them. Her work is therefore riveting, with fascinating stories about fascinating animals. These highlight the importance of science and scientists.

As for me, I aspire to be a poet, so whatever I write must scan. I watch any animal who comes into my line of vision, be it a bear or a mosquito, but I have little to do with scientists themselves. If I must discard a scientific concept because it has too many syllables, oh well.

Again, Liz is being too modest. She is both poet and scientist. She writes about what she has observed to be true—not through the lens of what she was taught in some classroom to be the case, but with fresh eyes, open to new possibilities. Some may say that recounting what you’ve seen is merely telling a story. But what, a scientist may ask, is the plural of story? The answer: Data.

What are some of your main messages?

For more than a century, most people—scientists included—clung to the notion that we are a species apart, a concept that resembled the Flat Earth theory. Other life-forms were said to be nothing like humans; they didn’t have consciousness or memory or emotions. We didn’t even credit them with gender, demanding that an animal is always called “it,” never “he” or “she.” Since nothing could be further from the truth, our object is to crush that notion.

Times are changing, but as far as we’re concerned, they can’t change fast enough. That other species are much the same as ours, with consciousness, thought, memory, and emotions, is essentially our only message. I just finished a book on this subject, The Hidden Life of Life is the tentative title. It’s being published by an academic press and was helpfully reviewed by scientists. This makes me sorry for bad things I may have said about scientists.

Right on, Liz! One of my favorite sayings was reportedly uttered by the pre-Socratic Greek philosopher, Thales of Miletus: “The universe is alive, and has fire in it, and is full of gods.” That’s what this book, and all our work, is really saying: that our world is full of fascinating individuals of all species, who love their lives as we do—and that their lives are far more brilliant, and far more sacred and holy, than we realize. I think Liz and I both write because we are constantly thrilled and surprised by the lives of our fellow creatures, and we can’t wait to share this with others. We hope our writing—along with your own, Marc, and that of so many of our colleagues—helps inspire our species to treat animals and the planet we share with greater respect and compassion. 

Who is your intended audience?

It would be nice if people who cling to the anthropomorphism ban would read this book, and perhaps they will if they care about animals. So perhaps our intended audience is such people. But we had a fairly wide audience for our columns, with people from various walks of life and even from different cultures, so we hope for the same for this book.

People who already love animals are likely to pick up our book. But we hope they’ll share it with friends who are simply curious about the world around them, and who like quirky nonfiction. Who isn’t curious about relatives of elephants who are smaller than groundhogs, animals who get drunk, the real reason why dogs pee in the house, and what electric eels’ dream about?    

What are some of your current and future projects? Do we have the pleasure of waiting for another collection of stories?

We have certainly considered writing another collection of stories, and would very much like to do so. For a few days last summer, we had a wonderful time trying to figure out which of Sy’s chickens was speaking, what was she saying, and to whom. We were getting somewhere with that project when we both became too swamped with other work to continue. We would like to resume and we will if we can. That would be one story. We’d then need to find material for about thirty more stories, which would keep us happy for months.

There’s nothing I’d rather do than another book with my best friend! In the meantime, in the next six months I’ll be heading to California to meet California Condors and to Peru and Ecuador to swim with Giant Manta Rays, for two new books. And the same year that Liz’s epochal The Hidden Life of Life is published, I’ll have three new books for younger readers: The Hyena Scientist (about Kay Holecamp’s long-term studies of the spotted hyena), How to Be a Good Creature: A Memoir in 13 Animals (for a young audience), and for very young readers, a picture book illustrated with gorgeous art by Amy Schimmler, titled Inky’s Great Escape: How a Very Smart Octopus Found His Way Home.     

Is there anything else you’d like to tell readers?

I think we’d like to tell them that because animals are so much like us in their thoughts and feelings, we should do our best to treat them as such. I think of the story I wrote for this book about a woman who no longer wanted her pet rabbit and abandoned him in our field. The rabbit, born in captivity, had never been in a wild place and knew nothing about how to live there. All he knew was that he was far from home with no hiding place in a wide open field where a predator could see him, and when he saw our house in the distance he came there, hoping for help.  The only door open was in the garage, so he went in. I didn’t know he was there. I would have cared for him had I known what had happened, but one of our dogs found him, saw him as an intruder, and killed him. I know the owner. She’s a good person. She thought she was doing the right thing. But if she knew then what I know now, she wouldn’t have thought to “set the rabbit free.” She would have brought him to my house and handed him to me. 

Yikes! Thank you, Liz—I just remembered that the mouse who was visiting our silverware drawer has been waiting for an hour in a hav-a-art trap—and I need to release him (three miles away, where the rest of his family now lives). What would happen, Liz, if I didn’t have you in my life? Gotta go!  

Thank you so much, Sy and Liz. I love how you offer not only information about your lovely new book, but also how you work together, and weave in some light humor along the way. Your book is a perfect cocktail for getting people interested in the private and public lives of other animals. It's also clear that you are interested in the life of every single individual animal, the main message of Jessica Pierce and my recent book called The Animals' Agenda: Freedom, Compassion, and Coexistence in the Human Age. I'm sure the animals would thank you for your concern.

I hope that Tamed & Untamed: Close Encounters of the Animal Kind receives a broad global audience. Your stories are a perfect way not only to let people know about the exciting discoveries we're learning from research on the science of animal behavior and animal minds, but also how two awesome authors work together. The personal vignettes and your senses of humor also are so refreshing.  

Marc Bekoff’s latest books are Jasper’s Story: Saving Moon Bears (with Jill Robinson); Ignoring Nature No More: The Case for Compassionate ConservationWhy Dogs Hump and Bees Get Depressed: The Fascinating Science of Animal Intelligence, Emotions, Friendship, and ConservationRewilding Our Hearts: Building Pathways of Compassion and CoexistenceThe Jane Effect: Celebrating Jane Goodall (edited with Dale Peterson); and The Animals’ Agenda: Freedom, Compassion, and Coexistence in the Human Age (with Jessica Pierce). Canine Confidential: Why Dogs Do What They Do will be published in early 2018. Learn more at marcbekoff.com.

You are reading

Animal Emotions

Choose a Dog Trainer as Carefully as You Would a Surgeon

Dog training is an unregulated industry in which dogs and humans suffer.

Do Wolves Understand Cause and Effect Better Than Dogs?

The headline of an essay asserts they do, but dogs aren't dumb-downed wolves

What It's Like to Be a Dog

New MRI research shows startling similarities in what lights up animals' brains.